A1 or A2 Dissipators are great guns for iron sight use. A3 Dissipators are unnessecarily over heavy. A3's indicate at some point you'd get some optics for it. If you plan to use iron sights only, skip the flat top and just go for the fixed carry handle. If you DO plan on optics; Great idea, there are some extrordinary optics out there to use from dots to scopes.
In any case, if you are planning to go the A3/optics route, I would not get the Dissipator. The Dissipator is a great design, FOR IRON SIGHT USE. As you know it takes a carbine length barrel, but puts the full length handguards and sight radius. Like I said, great option for iron sight use. It is heavier than other carbines, but the advantage of the full length sight radius is worth it if iron sights will be your primary sighting system. If iron sights are going to be your primary sighting system, consider getting it with the Bushmaster A1 upper, it uses their simpler and lighter A1 sights. The A1 sights do not have elevation adjustments, which saves on weight. And really, when is the last time anyone adjusted the elevation on a general purpose rifle? If you like the elevation, thats cool too, just get the A2, it is slightly heavier than the A1, but both are lighter than the A3 with a carry handle. A3 with carry handle is the heaviest option...
Either way I would surely get the M4 Dissipator barrel. HBARs are really good for nothing on a general purpose rifle. All they do is add weight. Manufacturers love them and push them because they are the easiest to make (they require less machining). But HBARs stink IMHO.