3006deer, I use the #22, high throw rings without the 19A rail. I needed the high rings because my scope has a 50mm objective. The rings repeat a perfect zero, which for me, is 300 yards. I can remove the scope in about five seconds and reinstall it in about the same amount of time. Brat is correct about the cheek weld though, the higher you go the harder it is to get a good weld. You may have to install a cheek pad whichever way you decide to go. My brass does bounce off of my windage turret cover. However, this is not a problem for me. It leaves a lot of brass on the turret cover and dings it up a bit, but I do not have a hang up about it. Others might.
Another thing to consider is eye relief. The ARMS #18 has limited cross slots for mounting the rings. Depending upon the relief you need the 19A might be a good choice since it gives you more slot locations for your rings.