My first (and only so far) shotgun is a Benelli Nova. I went to the gunstore wanting a semi-auto, but couldn't bring myself to spend 600+ on my first shotgun.
Look at them all, shot my friends remmington and his brothers Mossburg 590.
I left the store with a Benelli Nova. Cheap, quality built (IMHO), and with the Mag EXT. the gun looked very good, I will admit it sorta is ugly to me without it.
As far as the Nova being hard on the shoulder, the person who said that is high because my nova has been the easiest on my shoulder then any other pump shotgun I've shot.
Plus it came with Ghost ring sights, the ability to shot 3 1/2 shells, sling hookups, and the ability to remove shell out of chamber without entering new one. I installed the recoil reducer, witch is a must with 3 1/2, OUCH!
Easiest pump to clean as well, take apart a mossberg and then take apart the Nova, it speaks for itself.
The overall value is there, just do yourself a favor and drop another $40-$50 into the mag ext.
and your set.
I say go for it, I haven't been disappointed by my Nova yet. All my friends looking for Pumps, after they shot mine and I told them how much I spent total, lets just say I have 2 friends now with same shotgun.
Did I miss something