I like the cheaper plain tubes personally. You can buy a set of three, pistol, carbine, and full length, that use the same threaded base, so you can change the lengths with ease for different applications. And the cost of three of the cheapies is less than one railed guard in many cases.
Since you have a MG or SBR, .22LR barrel swaps for different lengths would be cake because torque and alignment isn't critical for .22LR, and by keeping the torque light, you can quickly swap barrels, silencers, and guards when they have a common bbl nut/guard base.
They are lighter, too, and feel good in the hand. How much stuff do you want to hang on a .22LR guard anyhow? I definitely think that the current trend towards huge amounts of rail is a goof. Pretty soon, guys are going to mount Pic rails on their baseball hats!
Dan, I really like your setup. Nice job on that tube. I dislike big fat guards combined with smaller OD cans. Is that a "Bust-Off" mag? It's huge!