Unless you qualify for LE Only rifles, the shortest you can get is 16" regardless of manufacturer. I happen to like RRA very much, I've got the national match A2 and it's sweet. As far as carbines, do you plan on tricking the thing out with all kinds of attachments/lights/optics/etc? If you do, you might want to look at something with a free float quad rail. Make sure you get the light barrel under the handguards otherwise it'll weigh about 8 pounds (which most would say is too much for a carbine). Talk to Pete with Legal Transfers, he's on the equipment exchange, he can help you out. As long as you don't get a national match lower, everything should fit fine. Even the NM lower will still work, it'll just be very tight for a while, you may need a punch to get the pins out and a little rubber hammer to take it apart. By the way, check out the hometown forum for virginia, they have a place where new members can check in, we keep a running tally of how many members we've got. Welcome to ARFCOM! MJD