Etcee,
Where are you located in the Empire State? I live in the southern tier, south of Buffalo in the sticks. If you are close we could get together sometime.
For all listening in on this post, NY has an exact mirror of the now defunct federal AWB EXCEPT there is no sunset provision and hell will freeze over before Albany would ever vote to rescind this ban.
As stated soem brakes are better than others and some are louder than others, also there is a difference between a brake (meant to check recoil impulse) and a compensator (primarily for reducing or mitigating muzzle climb, but may be designed to act as a brake as well). I like Cav comps personally, they are great for muzzle flip and do act as a brake to a certain extent but are not obnoxiously loud, to my ears they sound no different than an A2 FH/Comp. Now, I have a 20" SP1 upper with a Smith Enterprise brake/comp that is quite efficient but unfortunately is ver good at directing muzzle blast reward and is painful to shoot with foam plugs and barely tolerable with muffs, I also have this type of muzzle device for my tanker Garand but interestingly it is not as loud out of an 18" .30-06 barrel as the 20" 5.56mm barrel
I would say that for casual shooting or hunting that you would encounter here that a bare muzzle is fine, if you hunt woodchuks you typically wont get a follow up shot anyway unless you catch him away from the hole then you can chase him back (which I have done
) but even then with a varminter you dont need a muzzle device, really the only time one would be truly necessary is during competition as BR stated. I hunt chucks with a 24" fluted Bushy V-Match upper on a Cav Arms MKII lower (very light) using a Russian POSP weaver based 8X scope, it has a bare muzzle and I have never lost my sight picture on a chuck out to 500 yards and have made follow up shots for the kill out to 400 or so, even my 20" SP1 with the Smith brake/comp removed alows for very quick follow ups.
If your close I can let you play with some of my rifles in different configurations so you can see the difference, mostly it is cosmetic and if you buy a rifle already equipped that is dandy, otherwise living here in NY its really not worth spending money to have a barrel threaded especially when you just have to have the damn thing welded/pinned inplace anyway and if you end up not liking it, well you just wasted hard earned cash. Now if you want to get a pre-ban then you can have anything you want with a flick of the wrench.
Jeff