I have a 552 and have had zero issues. Mine gets knocked around a bit from use and has held up better than any other optical sight I have ever owned.
I leave mine on when I am on duty and it takes over a month to run the batteries down. My brother has the same kind purchased at the same time (they were gifts from our Dad) and his batteries last just days and he does not run his on while he is on duty like I do. Bottom line some Eotech's have issues, but what mass produced product does'nt?
The battery drain problem is a known issue and will be repaired by Eotech. I have no personal experience with this but I understand that it is for a fee but dont quote me on that. My brother is about to move on to another sight so if I can talk him out of his I might be able to get back with you on this:).
Incidentally I have been using a Mako magnifier on a paintball quality swing to he side mount for the last 6 months with excellent results out to 400 yards.. There are better sighting systems out there for this kind of shooting I know, but I happened to already own the Eotech and a magnifier set up was cheaper than a comparable Eotech quality new scope sighting system. Still I have been pleasantly surprised by the the set up.
Bottom line, if I found a smoking deal on a used Eotech 552I would take it and not look back.
..........Mounger