1dreamer,
It does not sound like the problem is reloads in general, but like it is your particular reloads. In order for the cartridge to stick like that, the case is oversize somewhere:
Diameter through the body;
Length from shoulder to case head (headspace);
Less likely, the neck interfered (a doughnut forms at the bottom of the neck and interfere and raise pressures - this usually requires several loadings).
Examine the cartridge carefully for marks from the chamber. Then measure and compare it to the ejected empties that worked fine. Where to measure and how is below.
My bet is that your cartridge is long from case head to shoulder, and the shoulder shows marks. A chamber gage or set of Stoney Point gages will show the length to the shoulder of a fired case. You need to adjust the sizer to set the shoulder back at least 0.002 more than the fired case.
The other possibility is that your cases are too big through the body. Measure the fired cases just below the shoulder and just above the extraction groove, then check the reloads. If the reloads are much bigger, you either have a sizer die problem or you used a neck sizing die.