Quoted:But i was also thinking about maybe hunting next year. .223 is an alright hunting round is it not? And not that i'm arguing, just wondering, could you specify why it is impractical to mount a scope on top of a carry handle?
From the Lyman reloading manual:
"In addition to its military service, the cartridge has been used for varmints, small game and target shooting with great success along with use by law enforcement agencies. The 223 Remington should not be considered a deer cartridge. Many states mandate the 6mm/.243" bore size as the minimum caliber for whitetails."
Hornady manual:
"The 223 Remington is an excellent choice for varmint hunters."
Nosler manual:
"Some will look down their nose at those who use 22 calibers for hunting deer. Most assuredly, this disdain is due in part to lack of experience with Nosler's smallest Partition. I have conducted extensive bullet expansion and penetration test with this bullet and at 100-yard impact velocities it will perform on par with any 30-30 Winchester load even if bone is struck." [...] "However, the true forte of the 223 Remington is predators and varmints..."
Speer:
Doesn't mention deer. Warns against the use of lightweight varmint bullets in barrels (like many ARs) that have 1-in-7" twist, because the rotational speed can rip them apart.
So I would say if you are an experienced hunter, or are going to be hunting smallish deer at closer ranges, you'd probably be fine. But the ability of the bullet to kill game is going to go down with range, as the bullet loses energy. You don't want to wound an animal that is 600 yards away because you didn't use enough gun.
The flat top is easier, stable, consistent and offers a lower height to mount the scope. Long range is challenging enough without adding complications that could be avoided by going with a flat top. You can also put a removable carrying handle on it if you want. The picatinny rail is designed for optics; on the carry handle they are an afterthought. It's not necessarily impractical, just less practical.