Well I currently have two of the Carbon 15's from Bushmaster.
My first was the AR pistol that was my first purchase after the ban was over. I had attempted to build my own AR pistol before that but couldn't get it to function properly, and even if it would have, the weight was just too much to be worth it.
I wanted an AR pistol, but didn't like the post ban models, so as soon as the no ban model came out it was mine.
I have fired it several thousand times (I would estimate 3-4)and had no problems to speak of. It did FTF on a real dirty chamber, after about a thousands rounds. (several range trips without cleaning) I cleaned it and it was fine. Pistols seem to get dirtier then Carbines when you shoot them????? maybe it is just me?
Although I have never had a quality control problem with Bushmaster products, I have a buddy that did once (during the pre Y2K production ) and they fixed the problem first time. If I ever have to return a weapon, I feel confident that they will fix it.
This is why I went with the 9mm Carbon 15. I already had a 9mm set up that I built on a Colt 9mm LEO lower(without block) and an OLY upper. While I like it a lot, it dosen't have bolt lock open on the last shot and I have always wanted that. If the BM 9mm didn't have that option, I would have never bought it.
I have yet to fire it but like I said, IF I have problems I feel confident that BM will fix it.
I doubt that I will ever buy a regular Carbon model simply because I prefer Mil Spec AR's. But when you are talking about AR pistols and sub caliber AR's, neither is issued to the military so I figured what the heck
I guess what I am saying is that while I think that they are fine weapons, for me they don't replace the real thing but are fine additions to them.....