That is absolutely correct. But as with anything, you can always find exceptions to the general rule. You can make it run with odd-ball buffers and springs, and it will work with some loads, but IMO what good is a rifle if it will run with 300 gr. TTSX but jam every other round with a 500 gr. solid? The standard buffers and springs, rifle or CAR, will run with any load you put through it. That is not saying you cannot fine tune a particular load to give less recoil with a XP spring or HB, Endine... but if you find you need to switch loads do not be surprised if it becomes unreliable. And for God's sake do not shoot yourself in the foot by getting a midlength gas. Yes, you can make it run with midlength gas but you limit yourself to powders that do not give you the top velocities, and face the facts, the .458 SOCOM is no speed demon to begin with. The ONLY reason Rock River produced the midlength, and they even said so on ARFCOM, is because so many 5.56 people thought that if it is good in the 5.56 then it must be equally good in the .458 SOCOM, and nothing could be further from the truth. I have rifles in barrel lengths from 13.5 to 20 inches and different gas lengths, including the midlength, and the midlength is by far the most finicky of the three lengths. As to a rifle length gas system, if ANYONE tries to steer you toward a rifle length gas run away, run away VERY fast!
Since you are new, also, barrel length. There is NOTHING to be gained by going over 16 inches. As I said, 13.5 to 20 inches, same loads over the same chronograph on the same day and there is less than 50 fps difference between them. All that extra 4 inches gives you is a longer sight radius if you are using it, and more stick to maneuver through the woods. Don't think for a second that you are going to gain the often claimed 50 fps per inch by going to a longer pipe. Not going to happen. The faster powders that give you top speed give up all they have to give in about 14 inches of barrel, so even if you go SBR you lose nothing, and going longer than that only makes your life easier by not having to do a Form 1, but there will be no significant gain in velocity.