As a long range shooter, I feel better about having an elevation and windage adjustment on my back up iron sights.
If my optic is damaged, and I can't get replacement, I might still want to be able to use the gun at a longer distance . With my BUIS, I can do that if I want.
There is a small amount of difference in weight and size, but that is not a big enough concern to me to over-ride the additional benefit to me. For the additional ounce or so that they weigh, it's worth it to me for the flexibility in use. Also, if I want to just use the gun as an iron-sighted carbine to save the weight and bulk that comes with optics mounted, I can just remove the optic and still have fully adjustable sights.
For other users who have no desire to take a long shot with irons, then they don't need it.
I've shot many 600yd matches with irons, and they can work just fine if you know how to use them.
And BTW, they still work just fine as backup CQB irons too.