I'm sold on the Lifeproof Fre as well. Quick story as to why...
A couple of years ago, I was upgraded to an iPhone 7 and I bought the Fre on a whim (I'm pretty hard on phones). 3 days later, I was duck hunting and didn't zip up a coat pocket all the way. I bent over to unhook the boat from the blind and watched my brand new Iphone and case fall into the lake. Needless to say, I couldn't let that stand. The next morning I was able to go back and dive to retrieve my phone. At that time, Lifeproof would warranty the Fre for 30 minutes at a depth of 2 meters. Mine was at 2 meters for 27 hours when I recovered it. When I was able to break the case open and clean it, there was a little mud starting to seep through the lighting port cover that had not reached the phone yet. Other than that, it was clean and dry. Additionally, I am in swift water environments occasionally and have had no problem with the case/phone is a pocket of my PFD.