Quote History Quoted:
@raf
Thank you for the recommendation. Tappan's "Why Prepare" strikes me because of the dollars mentioned. My first instinct was to chuckle; I'd love a $300 service pistol! Our enemies and the threats they present have changed. We've gone from ICBMs to dirty bombs. That said, all it means is that matters are getting worse on a micro-level scale. I don't think we face the threat of large scale nuclear war any more. Same with foreign invasion from a foreign military action.
But Tappan seems to see into the future as he discusses the dawn of terrorism in Europe, crime in the US, the ballooning welfare state, financial funny business, and the nature of our government bureaucracy. That said, we're approaching 40 years since he offered these warnings, as have countless others. Yet here we still are. It's clear there are good reasons to prep; if anything, government has become less able or even less willing to help in emergency situations. Katrina and other Gulf Coast hurricanes, police standing aside when Antifa and their ilk decide to hit the streets and riot, California's inability to keep the power on, Flint's inability to provide basic water... Are we worried unnecessarily about these large scale bogeymen? Should we be concentrating on the micro level instead of the macro level? Or are these "small disturbances" really symptoms of the larger problem that's just taking longer than expected to arrive?
Your statement implies an interesting question- what would Tappan say and advise today? I'll also add another question- what would Tappan see in the future from our vantage point in 2019?
More reading to do, but you're right- he gets you to think if you're willing to listen.
View Quote View All Quotes
View All Quotes
Quote History Quoted:
Quoted:
Provided is a very old link to Mel Tappan's book "On Survival". Tappan was one of the earliest "Survivalist' authors, and his writings had/have great credibility. His book is obviously dated, BUT the intelligence of the author, and his method of reasoning about general survival situations is something worth reading.
http://giltweasel.com/stuff/Tappan%20on%20Survival.pdf
Times have changed, and technology marches on. Personally, I would like to have a voice of reason, like Tappan, advising us nowadays. I'm sure some of his advice might have changed over time, but some would still valuable. Most important is his logical approach/evaluation of what he had to deal with as regards firearms. Keep that point in mind, please.
it is entirely reasonable to believe that a modern-day Tappan would have written a very different book. What is also entirely reasonable is that a modern-day Tappan would apply the same logical approach to modern-day survival issues.
I commend Tappan's very intelligent approach to such issues for consideration. He was a very wise man, and I do not use that term lightly.
@raf
Thank you for the recommendation. Tappan's "Why Prepare" strikes me because of the dollars mentioned. My first instinct was to chuckle; I'd love a $300 service pistol! Our enemies and the threats they present have changed. We've gone from ICBMs to dirty bombs. That said, all it means is that matters are getting worse on a micro-level scale. I don't think we face the threat of large scale nuclear war any more. Same with foreign invasion from a foreign military action.
But Tappan seems to see into the future as he discusses the dawn of terrorism in Europe, crime in the US, the ballooning welfare state, financial funny business, and the nature of our government bureaucracy. That said, we're approaching 40 years since he offered these warnings, as have countless others. Yet here we still are. It's clear there are good reasons to prep; if anything, government has become less able or even less willing to help in emergency situations. Katrina and other Gulf Coast hurricanes, police standing aside when Antifa and their ilk decide to hit the streets and riot, California's inability to keep the power on, Flint's inability to provide basic water... Are we worried unnecessarily about these large scale bogeymen? Should we be concentrating on the micro level instead of the macro level? Or are these "small disturbances" really symptoms of the larger problem that's just taking longer than expected to arrive?
Your statement implies an interesting question- what would Tappan say and advise today? I'll also add another question- what would Tappan see in the future from our vantage point in 2019?
More reading to do, but you're right- he gets you to think if you're willing to listen.
Thank you for your kind comments. As noted above, the
technological stuff in Tappan's books is somewhat dated--but much of it is as relevant today as it was long ago. My primary purpose in re-introducing his book "On Survival" was to give some folks who might not heard of him an opportunity to read the thoughts of a first-class mind, and observe his reasoning process.
There are many more very good tid-bits on Giltweasel's site; read the index here, and go exploring:
http://www.giltweasel.com/stuff/
For general informational purposes, "Tappan on Survival" was a re-written version of many of the columns he wrote for various magazines.
Tappan authored a "Personal Survival Letter" for many years There are PDF downloads available, if one looks hard enough, and some personal effort will be well worth it. I can't tell if member Solothurn is still with us, but here's something from the archives wherein he offered a PDF download of the complete Newsletter files:
https://www.ar15.com/forums/outdoors/Mel_Tappan__Personal_Survival_Letter/17-661461/? It's a trip into the past, and some names might sound familiar to longstanding members.
Tappan's "Survival Guns" is certainly his seminal work, and the one which has to deal the most with the march of technological progress. That notwithstanding, it is eminently worth reading for the insights it gives to his cool, calculated decision-making process. Again, there may be free PDF versions available for download, and your searching for them, and finding such will be of considerable value, and posting such links here will be of value to others. Of course, the book remains on-sale at Amazon and other locations, and presumably includes the pix which the PDF likely omits.
As to what Tappan might write about today, one can only speculate. I think it reasonable to believe that he would comment on how American society is more ideologically polarized than at any time since the Viet Nam War era. It is also likely to presume that he would comment on how American society, as well as the world in general, has developed a more
fragile society than existed back in Tappan's time. The increased fragility of our society, and its' global connectedness would, I think, give him reason to comment on its' increased vulnerability to many onsloughts, both natural and man-caused.
Of course, a modern Tappan would comment on other things, modern firearms certainly included. His was a logical, far-ranging mind, and I am sure that he would have had some thoughts on many other subjects.