User Panel
Posted: 12/7/2022 3:30:00 PM EDT
Have received some pocket-sized "emergency fishing gear" items from County Comm and Exotac.
I know ZERO about fishing. I reckon I'll take all the items down to local fishing/tackle shop and let the owner/proprietor examine them. Hopefully after he stops laughing, he'll be able to make useful suggestions on how to augment them. Will report back. County Comm Item Exotac Item Exotac Item |
|
I always have simple fishing stuff in my truck. Never know when you’ll find yourself near water with nothing to do. I’ve got small hooks for perch and bigger circle hooks for throwlines or trotlines.
|
|
Quoted: I always have simple fishing stuff in my truck. Never know when you'll find yourself near water with nothing to do. I've got small hooks for perch and bigger circle hooks for throwlines or trotlines. View Quote Going to local fishing expert seems to me to be very useful first step--for me. I admit my ignorance, and willing to learn from experts. |
|
Quoted: Willing to bet that your personal experience and locally useful fishing gear trumps anything I have. Going to local fishing expert seems to me to be very useful first step--for me. I admit my ignorance, and willing to learn from experts. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: I always have simple fishing stuff in my truck. Never know when you'll find yourself near water with nothing to do. I've got small hooks for perch and bigger circle hooks for throwlines or trotlines. Going to local fishing expert seems to me to be very useful first step--for me. I admit my ignorance, and willing to learn from experts. I hear that. Honestly, I can’t remember a part of my life when fishing of some type wasn’t involved. I fish more than I shoot, and I shoot whenever I can. Just a basic “survival” type fishing setup would be really cheap to build. I guess that’s pretty much what I have in the truck, though unintentionally. In a true survival situation, though, fish traps or gillnets would probably be more productive, but a few well placed throw lines might catch enough fish to provide some protein. I don’t really worry about that kind of stuff much, though. |
|
No Expert, but I reckon successful fishing is a combination of both gear and personal skill/experience.
Since I have zero skill/experience, asking local folks to help with gear. The rest is on me. Understood about gill nets and so forth being useful in survival situations but illegal otherwise, and risky to practice using them. Much obliged for your informed comments! |
|
While I have fished a lot over the years I pretty much suck at it. I could care less about the latest and greatest gear. In a survival situation I would go with the basic. Fishing line, small basic hooks, and some type of live bait be it a worm, grub or whatever. Small hooks can catch both small and large fish, but big hooks and lures only catch big fish. In a survival situation any fish counts. Think watered down flavored soup broth with a few chunks and bones in it vs a nice fish filet.
I have always been interested in those wallet card things where you pop the hooks out but have never bought one. I always felt a few actual hooks and other things link sinkers and leaders in a pill vile would work better, but you have to have it with you to use it so 6 to 1 half a dozen the other. |
|
My thoughts pretty much. OTOH, and not being any sort of expert, I'm seeking expert advice.
|
|
Quoted: No Expert, but I reckon successful fishing is a combination of both gear and personal skill/experience. Since I have zero skill/experience, asking local folks to help with gear. The rest is on me. Understood about gill nets and so forth being useful in survival situations but illegal otherwise. Much obliged for your informed comments! View Quote I probably have more experience than most, but I’m no expert either. I’m just a dude that likes to fish. I do listen to people that are better than me, which helps. If I had to fish to survive, and gill nets or traps weren’t an option, I’d use small hooks to catch bait for trotlines and throw lines. It’s a trade off, to try and catch a big meal by sacrificing a small meal. I guess that’s a trade off that must be balanced against need. I can always catch bugs or dig worms for perch bait. I say throw lines and trot lines because they’re passive, and the more hooks in the water, the better chance of catching something. It’s a little like a trap or snareline- you don’t set one and hope for the best. |
|
Not an expert or even an enthusiast, just a guys who has a pole and license and has dabbled before.
I came to the conclusion that for survival sake, fishing is a waste of time. Most fish caught by fisher men are stocked (atleast where I am), not alot of natural fish. I once spent 4 hours finishing in a stocked pond at my club, with a rod and real and a plethora of bait and lures. I caught nothing. I thought to myself "if I can't catch a fish under perfect conditions, with decent equipment, in a stocked pond, how the hell am I gonna do it in the middle of the woods, when I'm tired and hungry, with a spool of line and a hook, and a worm from under a log?the damn water.might not even have fish! |
|
I know this topic is probably just for fun, but what circumstances result in a need to survival fish in Rhode Island?
Maybe you need one of these: Attached File |
|
Quoted: I know this topic is probably just for fun, but what circumstances result in a need to survival fish in Rhode Island? Maybe you need one of these: https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/64501/99D07265-AC69-46DF-8CE9-B29811DE1E9A_jpe-2628507.JPG View Quote I have no idea. I don’t carry that stuff for survival, I just carry it for spontaneous fishing, should I feel the need. It’s a happy coincidence that it would also make a good survival fishing kit. |
|
Quoted: Just for shits and giggles, here is what I have behind the seat of my truck… https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/69531/9F10CE5E-AA51-4696-BED8-2A4D7E8E5561-2628499.jpg https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/69531/CDE88FC4-3421-403F-AC1F-3DD3EECA2F82-2628500.jpg Using rocks for weights, I can make a couple of throw lines in 5 mins, or a trot line in 30 mins, and have the gear to fish for bait (just need a stick to use for a pole). Anywhere, any time. The smallest hooks and the circle hooks are newest, because I used the previous ones on a camping trip to demonstrate how easy they were to use (used the braid to make throwlines and some of the mono to fish for bait. Some of the perch hooks were also used in a creek on the side of the road when my kids were littler, because they asked if there were fish there. I fished that way when I was in 2nd grade, and it still works today. If I’m fishing for fun, I use the real gear. View Quote I'm familiar with trot lines but can you describe what you mean by a "throw line"? |
|
I say carry a seine net. Maybe make or buy one that can double as a hammock so it's got some more purpose. In an emergency, you cant waste time standing with a line, and a net will catch more fish than a trot line.
|
|
A fly fishing setup can catch about anything and is very compact with a 4 piece rod. A reel and box of flies takes up little space also. I keep one in my truck 24/7, under the back seat by the jack.
|
|
Quoted: I'm familiar with trot lines but can you describe what you mean by a "throw line"? View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Just for shits and giggles, here is what I have behind the seat of my truck… https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/69531/9F10CE5E-AA51-4696-BED8-2A4D7E8E5561-2628499.jpg https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/69531/CDE88FC4-3421-403F-AC1F-3DD3EECA2F82-2628500.jpg Using rocks for weights, I can make a couple of throw lines in 5 mins, or a trot line in 30 mins, and have the gear to fish for bait (just need a stick to use for a pole). Anywhere, any time. The smallest hooks and the circle hooks are newest, because I used the previous ones on a camping trip to demonstrate how easy they were to use (used the braid to make throwlines and some of the mono to fish for bait. Some of the perch hooks were also used in a creek on the side of the road when my kids were littler, because they asked if there were fish there. I fished that way when I was in 2nd grade, and it still works today. If I’m fishing for fun, I use the real gear. I'm familiar with trot lines but can you describe what you mean by a "throw line"? Tied to something solid on one end, weighted at the other, with one or more “drops” with hooks. You throw it where you want it to be, then tie it off. If you have a boat, you tie it off to a tree limb that overhangs the water. The downside of the former is that it gets fouled easily if it’s too long and has too many hooks, but it’s easy to set up. They’re best when they dangle almost straight down with no slack between the weight on the bottom and the tie-off. The wire leaders in my pics have easy swivel attachments for a couple of hooks, easy to assemble quickly (don’t really need this, you can make one with just lines, but it’s handy and I had a couple around. |
|
|
Quoted: Tied to something solid on one end, weighted at the other, with one or more “drops” with hooks. You throw it where you want it to be, then tie it off. If you have a boat, you tie it off to a tree limb that overhangs the water. The downside of the former is that it gets fouled easily if it’s too long and has too many hooks, but it’s easy to set up. They’re best when they dangle almost straight down with no slack between the weight on the bottom and the tie-off. The wire leaders in my pics have easy swivel attachments for a couple of hooks, easy to assemble quickly (don’t really need this, you can make one with just lines, but it’s handy and I had a couple around. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: Just for shits and giggles, here is what I have behind the seat of my truck… https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/69531/9F10CE5E-AA51-4696-BED8-2A4D7E8E5561-2628499.jpg https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/69531/CDE88FC4-3421-403F-AC1F-3DD3EECA2F82-2628500.jpg Using rocks for weights, I can make a couple of throw lines in 5 mins, or a trot line in 30 mins, and have the gear to fish for bait (just need a stick to use for a pole). Anywhere, any time. The smallest hooks and the circle hooks are newest, because I used the previous ones on a camping trip to demonstrate how easy they were to use (used the braid to make throwlines and some of the mono to fish for bait. Some of the perch hooks were also used in a creek on the side of the road when my kids were littler, because they asked if there were fish there. I fished that way when I was in 2nd grade, and it still works today. If I’m fishing for fun, I use the real gear. I'm familiar with trot lines but can you describe what you mean by a "throw line"? Tied to something solid on one end, weighted at the other, with one or more “drops” with hooks. You throw it where you want it to be, then tie it off. If you have a boat, you tie it off to a tree limb that overhangs the water. The downside of the former is that it gets fouled easily if it’s too long and has too many hooks, but it’s easy to set up. They’re best when they dangle almost straight down with no slack between the weight on the bottom and the tie-off. The wire leaders in my pics have easy swivel attachments for a couple of hooks, easy to assemble quickly (don’t really need this, you can make one with just lines, but it’s handy and I had a couple around. Got it, thanks. |
|
if you have access within 50yd to schooling fish that are visible on the surface, a "snatch hook" works very well... it used to be legal in Florida and I was pretty good at it... basically you use a slightly weighted 12 O or so large treble hook, coupled with a stiff rod, and some heavy line... I used a large Daiwa spinning reel, but don't remember what line... you cast across the schooling fish, let the hook settle for a moment, than rip the hook through the school to foul hook the fish
additionally, if you have access to a platform or sea wall where you have visible schooled fish, even at a slight depth, a cast net works well ...the best way to gather small bait fish |
|
Quoted: Tied to something solid on one end, weighted at the other, with one or more "drops" with hooks. You throw it where you want it to be, then tie it off. If you have a boat, you tie it off to a tree limb that overhangs the water. The downside of the former is that it gets fouled easily if it's too long and has too many hooks, but it's easy to set up. They're best when they dangle almost straight down with no slack between the weight on the bottom and the tie-off. The wire leaders in my pics have easy swivel attachments for a couple of hooks, easy to assemble quickly (don't really need this, you can make one with just lines, but it's handy and I had a couple around. View Quote |
|
Quoted: I know this topic is probably just for fun, but what circumstances result in a need to survival fish in Rhode Island? Maybe you need one of these: https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/64501/99D07265-AC69-46DF-8CE9-B29811DE1E9A_jpe-2628507.JPG View Quote |
|
Flat card hooks like that look gimmicky. Squared sharpe edges that seem like they would cut your line right at the knot with any degree of pressure. Much cheaper to use normal hooks.
I guess you could use the modern wonder braided lines but they are all solid color unlike monofilament that is a lot less visible. Just my hack fisherman’s opinion. |
|
Quoted: Flat card hooks like that look gimmicky. Squared sharpe edges that seem like they would cut your line right at the knot with any degree of pressure. Much cheaper to use normal hooks. I guess you could use the modern wonder braided lines but they are all solid color unlike monofilament that is a lot less visible. Just my hack fisherman's opinion. View Quote |
|
Quoted: Flat card hooks like that look gimmicky. Squared sharpe edges that seem like they would cut your line right at the knot with any degree of pressure. Much cheaper to use normal hooks. I guess you could use the modern wonder braided lines but they are all solid color unlike monofilament that is a lot less visible. Just my hack fisherman’s opinion. View Quote I’d say this is a legit concern (another hack fisherman’s opinion). It might work for very short term use with braided line or paracord strands. My guess is that it’d be bad for monofilament, but that’s just a guess. It might be fun to screw around with though, and find out. |
|
The card thing is worthless. The hand reel is slightly less worthless only because it has actual hooks and line.
You can put together a much better kit in the Walmart fishing section for under 10 bucks. Remember, a hell of a lot of survival gear is sold as essentially, a novelty. No one ever actually tried using it. I would ignore the hook and line entirely and go with a small cast net. I can feed an entire family with one as long as they are not picky as what they eat. A couple pounds of finger mullet in 20 minutes is pretty much how I collect bait for the day. If you have the time to stay in one location a trot line is a good idea. Remember, you have to find bait for it too. |
|
Quoted: The card thing is worthless. The hand reel is slightly less worthless only because it has actual hooks and line. You can put together a much better kit in the Walmart fishing section for under 10 bucks. Remember, a hell of a lot of survival gear is sold as essentially, a novelty. No one ever actually tried using it. I would ignore the hook and line entirely and go with a small cast net. I can feed an entire family with one as long as they are not picky as what they eat. A couple pounds of finger mullet in 20 minutes is pretty much how I collect bait for the day. If you have the time to stay in one location a trot line is a good idea. Remember, you have to find bait for it too. View Quote Cast nets are big, bulky, and take skill to use. If you’re going that way, might as well use gillnets. The hand reel looks like a more expensive variant on using a used can for a reel, which third worlders have done for ages (and can actually work, by the way). Trying to feed yourself with a single hook in the water is going to make for a hungry trip most of the time, unless you’re catching bait for traps/multi-hook setups. The nice thing about them is that (aside from baiting) they’re passive, and catching food while you’re doing something else. |
|
The goal is to assemble an emergency fishing kit, hopefully of small size/weight/bulk that is a reasonably well-set up kit with decent components. It's possible that both fresh and saltwater fishing might be done. Things like hammocks/gill nets and so forth might well be useful, under dire circumstances.
It's obvious that some compromises will need to be made in order to keep the kit small and light. Listening to people who have far more experience than I do will surely help. I'm as ignorant as can be about all this; any help from experienced folks will be much appreciated. |
|
Quoted: The goal is to assemble an emergency fishing kit, hopefully of small size/weight/bulk that is a reasonably well-set up kit with decent components. It's possible that both fresh and saltwater fishing might be done. Things like hammocks/gill nets and so forth might well be useful, under dire circumstances. It's obvious that some compromises will need to be made in order to keep the kit small and light. Listening to people who have far more experience than I do will surely help. I'm as ignorant as can be about all this; any help from experienced folks will be much appreciated. View Quote If you ever hear me talking about surf fishing (or saltwater fishing in general), you can immediately conclude I have no clue what I’m talking about. I’ve done it, but I can’t claim to have a clue about what I’m doing. When I was in kindergarten, my buddy and I sat on a dock and caught little mullet with pieces of bacon on a hook. Every other time in salt water has been either random luck or me doing what some other dude says, after he’s out a boat in a particular place that (to me) looks like any of a thousand other places. |
|
Crap, I just realized my little fishing kit has zippers, and Raf hates zippers….
|
|
|
I would only use the hooks in the Country Com kit in a real survival situation where there were no other options. The Exotac reel would do nothing better then wrapping some string around a stick. I would go to Walmart and pick up a small takedown rod and reel. You can then grab a small Plano storage box and fill it with hooks and small jigs. Remember that you can catch big fish on small hooks, but you cant catch small fish on big hooks. You might want to pick up a couple of YoYo reels also.
|
|
Quoted: I would only use the hooks in the Country Com kit in a real survival situation where there were no other options. The Exotac reel would do nothing better then wrapping some string around a stick. I would go to Walmart and pick up a small takedown rod and reel. You can then grab a small Plano storage box and fill it with hooks and small jigs. Remember that you can catch big fish on small hooks, but you cant catch small fish on big hooks. You might want to pick up a couple of YoYo reels also. View Quote A big fishing kit is desirable, but bigger than I want for an emergency kit which might have compromises but be much smaller and more portable. Thanks for useful comments! |
|
Quoted: Good suggestions. I think the Exotac item is kinda like a Yo-Yo rig. A big fishing kit is desirable, but bigger than I want for an emergency kit which might have compromises but be much smaller and more portable. Thanks for useful comments! View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: I would only use the hooks in the Country Com kit in a real survival situation where there were no other options. The Exotac reel would do nothing better then wrapping some string around a stick. I would go to Walmart and pick up a small takedown rod and reel. You can then grab a small Plano storage box and fill it with hooks and small jigs. Remember that you can catch big fish on small hooks, but you cant catch small fish on big hooks. You might want to pick up a couple of YoYo reels also. A big fishing kit is desirable, but bigger than I want for an emergency kit which might have compromises but be much smaller and more portable. Thanks for useful comments! There is a lot of good advice in this thread and a lot of ways to design a kit that serves your needs. For a bare minimum, compact kit you might go with one of these: https://www.cabelas.com/shop/en/eagle-claw-75-piece-hook-swivel-sinker-assortment and two packs of leader material. For the leader I would get one of 4lb test and one of 8 or 10lb test but you'll need to decide what is best for your area. Best way to start is to get some basic skills in fishing with conventional rod and reel before moving to improvised methods. You'll need such essential skills as knot tying, properly weighting the line, lure/bait presentation, when to strike, and how to softly play the fish (or horse it in) so you don't lose it once hooked. You're on the right track going to your local fishing store to get started but I would approach them as if you were a new angler wanting to learn the basics of road and reel and once you gain experience then mess around with survival methods. |
|
Quoted: There is a lot of good advice in this thread and a lot of ways to design a kit that serves your needs. For a bare minimum, compact kit you might go with one of these: https://www.cabelas.com/shop/en/eagle-claw-75-piece-hook-swivel-sinker-assortment and two packs of leader material. For the leader I would get one of 4lb test and one of 8 or 10lb test but you'll need to decide what is best for your area. Best way to start is to get some basic skills in fishing with conventional rod and reel before moving to improvised methods. You'll need such essential skills as knot tying, properly weighting the line, lure/bait presentation, when to strike, and how to softly play the fish (or horse it in) so you don't lose it once hooked. You're on the right track going to your local fishing store to get started but I would approach them as if you were a new angler wanting to learn the basics of road and reel and once you gain experience then mess around with survival methods. View Quote TANSTAAFL! |
|
Quoted: I would only use the hooks in the Country Com kit in a real survival situation where there were no other options. The Exotac reel would do nothing better then wrapping some string around a stick. I would go to Walmart and pick up a small takedown rod and reel. You can then grab a small Plano storage box and fill it with hooks and small jigs. Remember that you can catch big fish on small hooks, but you cant catch small fish on big hooks. You might want to pick up a couple of YoYo reels also. View Quote Have you ever seen someone work a can fishing rig? It’s actually pretty neat. That’s just a fancier version. I can’t do it, but I’ve watched Mexican kids make it look easy. Catching big fish on small hooks is harder than it looks. Don’t buy the mythology. Small fish can also be caught on surprisingly big hooks. Like anything else, there’s a right size tool for the job. |
|
Quoted: Have you ever seen someone work a can fishing rig? It’s actually pretty neat. That’s just a fancier version. I can’t do it, but I’ve watched Mexican kids make it look easy. Catching big fish on small hooks is harder than it looks. Don’t buy the mythology. Small fish can also be caught on surprisingly big hooks. Like anything else, there’s a right size tool for the job. View Quote Can fishing as in wrapping the line around a can and using as a sorta hand held spinning reel? I've done it fishing for squid in Guam and the PI and a couple times here shorefishing just for the challenge. |
|
Quoted: Can fishing as in wrapping the line around a can and using as a sorta hand held spinning reel? I've done it fishing for squid in Guam and the PI and a couple times here shorefishing just for the challenge. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Have you ever seen someone work a can fishing rig? It’s actually pretty neat. That’s just a fancier version. I can’t do it, but I’ve watched Mexican kids make it look easy. Catching big fish on small hooks is harder than it looks. Don’t buy the mythology. Small fish can also be caught on surprisingly big hooks. Like anything else, there’s a right size tool for the job. Can fishing as in wrapping the line around a can and using as a sorta hand held spinning reel? I've done it fishing for squid in Guam and the PI and a couple times here shorefishing just for the challenge. Yeah - it’s pretty neat, IMO |
|
|
around the beginning of the BHO administration I started looking at some of the "survival" videos and looked at several fishing kits... I built a proof of concept of a rather unique fishing kit.... used a large plastic pill bottle, ... drilled a couple of holes in the cap and looped a piece of para cord for a wrist loop... assorted orange and red jigs, small sinkers, plastic baits, and hooks inside, but attached one end of the monofilament and wrapped the line on the outside of the pill bottle... slip hand through the wrist loop, and with an underhand flip, cast the bait, and let the line free unravel like a spinning reel...bicycle inner tube section to keep the line in place when not used
|
|
Fishing is typically a time intensive method of food procurement. They only methods that are really necessary useful are the aforementioned techniques that can function unattended. You can do a heck of a lot while those methods are in use. And in a real survival situation you don’t have time to sit around.
I have a military manual from the 70’s that to feed larger groups of people, grenades work well. |
|
Quoted: Fishing is typically a time intensive method of food procurement. They only methods that are really necessary useful are the aforementioned techniques that can function unattended. You can do a heck of a lot while those methods are in use. And in a real survival situation you don’t have time to sit around. I have a military manual from the 70’s that to feed larger groups of people, grenades work well. View Quote Grenades are hard to procure, heavy, and one-time use. But they are a multi-tasker. |
|
For coastal area bait, consider fishbites
https://fishbites.com/products/saltwater-fishbites-longer-lasting-e-z-shrimp/ |
|
One good thing about this thread is it has inspired me to go fishing this weekend when I get back home.
|
|
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.