Leather or Kydex?
Straight up or canted?
Drop in or retention?
Belt loop or clip?
I like a thumb break for OWB and I have a very well-broken-in Mitch Rosen Express for my Kahr 45. It conceals well and gives something resembling "retention." It's how I carry my Kahr .45.
I have a High Noon Holsters "Hooker" (no joke, that is the name) Kydex for my J-frames. I really, really like it. High Noon has a ton of OWB offerings and crazy names for all!
I am in the process of getting a 2A Holster "Liberator" for my J-frames. This will clip to the belt and should be easier to get on compared to the High Noon Holsters "Hooker."
For open carry I like Safariland ALS (Active Locking System) paddle for my 1911 but my mid-section is too short / too much of a "high ride" to draw efficiently. I have to literally bend over to my left to clear the holster on a draw.
Andrews Leather is a great, great company and man to deal with, give him a try. He does some really nice work, and in like 20 different exotic leather skins if you want to go that route.
Good luck, let us know what you get.