What do you guys think is more comfortable?

i have a 19x and will be switching from an xc1 to a x300. What do you think will be more comfortable to carry it in? A 19 length sized holster or a 34 length size holster?  Im guessing the 34 since the muzzle end of it is the length as the x300 and wont have just a little "nub" poking me. Pics for reference on what i mean. Will be getting another Tier 1 Concealed Axis Slim Elite.

thanks for any info

I use a 19 holster with my tlr-1 hl.  Yes it's more or less the same length as a 34 slide.  However, even in aiwb the holster is still canted slightly.  Having a 19 length holster keeps added pressure off the "little general".  It also helps when using the urinal at a public restroom.  Leaves just enough room where you don't have to twist your pants just to make things happen.

Same here but I’m switching to a smaller light, Olight Mini2 because I got tired of having my business getting pinched and pressed in certain situations. The full-sized WPL’s are a little to large to carry AIWB for me....

Thanks for the replies gentlemen, i completely forgot about giving mr squiggles there a little breathing room, looks like ill be ordering the 19 length for the above mentioned reason.

I currently carry an xc-1 but feel it lacks in lighting up a room enough for me. Also i felt  like i was going through triple a's. At least with 123's it will match all my other lights.