Posted: 5/21/2022 2:47:34 PM EDT
[#5]
Quote History Quoted:So, a few things... 1. Most authors who make it past the larval stage are bombarded with unsolicited ideas and opinions. By the time I published my first book, my more-established author friends had made it remarkably clear that, as flattering as imitation might be, the unsolicited nature makes the suggestions more than a little annoying. Imagine if random people walked up to you every day and kept trying to tell you how to do your job and you won't be far off the mark. I'm certainly still not established compared to them, but I'm starting to understand first-hand why some of the things I thought were innocuous got the reactions they did. 2. More authors get their start writing fanfic than you'd think. Learning how to write generally involves doing it, after all. 3. A surprising number of published stories start off with "I liked this one guy's idea," followed by either "So I wrote stuff in his world, filed off the serial numbers, and published it" or "but I figured I could do it better, so here's where I went with it." 4. Despite having a few unfinished stories at the time, I started "By Dawn's Early Light" as an example of the latter. It's just the first one I finished and I managed to stick with it. 5. As discouraging as #1 might sound, #2 through #4 are really what you should take away. File off the serial numbers, apply putty/JB Weld where necessary, sand and polish, and go get paid, sir. You've already written something that's yours alone. Repainting over where you had to take an angle grinder to it to eat of the VINs is less work than starting over, usually. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quote History Quoted:Quoted: If anyone is interested...
I started reading Christopher Nuttall's "Schooled in Magic" series one day when I had nothing else to read. I wasn't expecting much of it, but found myself hooked. By the time I started reading the series was close to the end - so I "binge read" (is that a thing?) it, and only had to wait a few weeks for the last book.
While waiting, I had some ideas about a few of the things that he had left dangling/unexplained. So emailed him to see if he thought my ideas might be a possible path for future books. When I didn't get a response, I actually wrote a couple of chapters do demonstrate what I was getting at.
That got a response. I ended up writing another chapter. He basically said "Ok, but this isn't the way I would take it".
That is ok - his universe, his characters. But I still like the idea. So over the next year I added more and more to my scribblings. A few weeks ago, I decided that this (now) book was at a point where I could wrap it up. Now, since it is based upon someone else's works, I can't really publish it, and certainly can't try to sell it, but I think it might be of interest to anyone that has read that series (or maybe not...).
There is a website that hosts "fan fiction", so I dropped a copy on there. If anyone wants to take a look: https://archiveofourown.org/users/PhilipPeake
BTW: for anyone who hasn't read any of Chris Nuttall's work, he has a lot. Some hard Sifi and some magic. He also has a world view which would fit in here very well. Gets him some negative reviews from lefty readers on Amazon. So, a few things... 1. Most authors who make it past the larval stage are bombarded with unsolicited ideas and opinions. By the time I published my first book, my more-established author friends had made it remarkably clear that, as flattering as imitation might be, the unsolicited nature makes the suggestions more than a little annoying. Imagine if random people walked up to you every day and kept trying to tell you how to do your job and you won't be far off the mark. I'm certainly still not established compared to them, but I'm starting to understand first-hand why some of the things I thought were innocuous got the reactions they did. 2. More authors get their start writing fanfic than you'd think. Learning how to write generally involves doing it, after all. 3. A surprising number of published stories start off with "I liked this one guy's idea," followed by either "So I wrote stuff in his world, filed off the serial numbers, and published it" or "but I figured I could do it better, so here's where I went with it." 4. Despite having a few unfinished stories at the time, I started "By Dawn's Early Light" as an example of the latter. It's just the first one I finished and I managed to stick with it. 5. As discouraging as #1 might sound, #2 through #4 are really what you should take away. File off the serial numbers, apply putty/JB Weld where necessary, sand and polish, and go get paid, sir. You've already written something that's yours alone. Repainting over where you had to take an angle grinder to it to eat of the VINs is less work than starting over, usually. Well, I didn't want to write an essay here ... I didn't exactly get brushed off. It was just not what he had/has in mind. Even suggested that I might want to develop it into fanfic. I certainly don't think I can write better ... or that my ideas are better (or even as good). I left those (sample) chapters for a while, then went back and re-read them. They seemed ok to me, the idea(s) were sound. I continued adding to it, developing the story. Never had any intent to do anything with it, and probably would have just stopped at some point ... except that I didn't. I was sort of surprised at what it was turning into. I don't think I ever got better than a C- in my English classes at school, so the idea of writing something that might turn into a book was laughable. Well, 111k words later, I decided that it was time to finish it. Still no intent to do anything with it. After a while, and a couple of clean-up sessions I wondered about if/how to make it available for anyone that might want to read it. Chris worked with me on appropriate disclaimers, and explained about the problems with fan fiction, which, of course, never having done anything in the writing/publishing world I was unaware of. So, it's there. Tucked away in a corner of the Internet where people who want to can take a look, and unlikely to worry any publisher. BTW, people are always telling me how to do my job :-)
|