User Panel
Posted: 11/27/2018 3:40:27 PM EDT
It's a lot of money for a SUV, even on the used market, but drives like a tank, feels like a tank, but seems like a poor value compared to the rest of the MB lineup. Always been on the fence with these. Have a C63 I'm looking to trade, and it's a hard pill to swallow to think you'd pay almost the same price for a used G63 as compared to a brand new E63S, M5, etc. Not sure if the value is there? Cool factor, debatable hmm.
|
|
[#1]
Personally, I don't get it. Benz makes good shit, but I just can't figure out the Gwagon. Small, super pricey, honestly pretty fugly, I'm sure it's capable, but to me it seems to reinforce the idea "jack of all trades is master of none."
I'd rather have a sedan or coupe, and then have a second vehicle like a Suburban/Yukon XL Denali or the new extended Navigator. |
|
[#2]
I think they're awesome, albeit strange in today's current lineup. A bit like buying a Land Rover Defender.
If I were to buy one it would be with the intent to own it forever. I dont think the value is there other than if you simply want it. Its unique and has a kickass engine. |
|
[#3]
Yeah I think this is definitely one of those vehicles where you either love it or hate it. I was in the hate it, looks ugly, don't get it camp for a long while and I find myself switching after going for a short test drive. One of the appeals of it's retro boxy looks is it will never go out of style since it's been out of style for the last 20 years aha!
But I agree it's unique, but not as roomy inside as I thought by looking at it. If trying to use logic or common sense to buy the G, I think all good senses would say to stay away. But not everything has to make sense :) |
|
[#4]
You will not be happy going from a very sporty car to a solid axle suv. The g is fast in a straight line. That's all it does.
|
|
[#5]
|
|
[#6]
Yup the G is cool but it really has no rhyme or reason.
It's a fast sled though. Someone already got himself killed with one of the few here, looks like he overcooked it badly on a provincial road and crashed in a field. |
|
[#8]
Quoted:
You will not be happy going from a very sporty car to a solid axle suv. The g is fast in a straight line. That's all it does. View Quote I have a G350D Professional and a 911 GT3 Touring. They're the absolute best cars I've ever owned which includes a long line of sports cars and Ford trucks. They're both exceptional cars to own and events to drive - obviously in different ways. What I wouldn't be happy is going from a very sporty car to a lessor, cheaper sports car. I equate what you're saying to be comparable to "if you drive a Ferrari you wouldn't enjoy driving around in an Abrams tank." Maybe that analogy will help you realize how wrong your comment is. That's not all the G does either. The G goes through beat up poorly kept roads like an absolute champ and allows me to explore ancient German castles with my dogs and girlfriend. I equate my G to a luxury, higher-end Jeep Wrangler Rubicon. |
|
[#9]
Benz dealer tech here.I love them,as stated some hate them.Quirky issues.
Main complaints are rough ride,(its a truck) and steering is hard to turn and shimmy..(its a truck) |
|
[#11]
|
|
[#12]
Quoted: False. I have a G350D Professional and a 911 GT3 Touring. They're the absolute best cars I've ever owned which includes a long line of sports cars and Ford trucks. They're both exceptional cars to own and events to drive - obviously in different ways. What I wouldn't be happy is going from a very sporty car to a lessor, cheaper sports car. I equate what you're saying to be comparable to "if you drive a Ferrari you wouldn't enjoy driving around in an Abrams tank." Maybe that analogy will help you realize how wrong your comment is. That's not all the G does either. The G goes through beat up poorly kept roads like an absolute champ and allows me to explore ancient German castles with my dogs and girlfriend. I equate my G to a luxury, higher-end Jeep Wrangler Rubicon. View Quote |
|
[#13]
Quoted: There is nothing wrong or false about my statement. A G63 has little or no use off road, and because it was purpose built for off road use, is not particularly good ON the road. A GLE63 or GLS63 is a far better choice. They just lack the classic look of the G. That classic look comes at a great deal of expense in other areas. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: There is nothing wrong or false about my statement. A G63 has little or no use off road, and because it was purpose built for off road use, is not particularly good ON the road. A GLE63 or GLS63 is a far better choice. They just lack the classic look of the G. That classic look comes at a great deal of expense in other areas. Quoted:
The g is fast in a straight line. That's all it does. As to not being good on the road I disagree. Mine is great for cruising on the autobahn. The guys in their G63's passing me on the autobahn don't seem to have an issue either. The only thing it sucks at is driving through roads in tight European cities; a total non-issue in most of America. I actually prefer driving it to my A45 AMG and usually pick it over the GT3 because of the extra utility. Quite frankly if I had to choose between a middle of the road sports car like an M5 or a G I'd choose the G every time. It's simply a more special vehicle and you can use it every day for everything - just like a Wrangler. |
|
[#14]
I test drove one. So that’s my brief experience (very brief), I had it for a weekend. I thought the road noise was unacceptable. My car at the time was a Cayenne.
|
|
[#15]
Quoted: Yet before you said, ...but now you've admitted that it's a purpose built off-road vehicle so obviously it does a lot more than drive in a straight line. I'd add it's also fun as hell to drive, looks great, and grabs the right kind of attention. A GLE63 or GLS63 is an ugly boring SUV for clueless soccer moms with rich husbands. As to not being good on the road I disagree. Mine is great for cruising on the autobahn. The guys in their G63's passing me on the autobahn don't seem to have an issue either. The only thing it sucks at is driving through roads in tight European cities; a total non-issue in most of America. I actually prefer driving it to my A45 AMG and usually pick it over the GT3 because of the extra utility. Quite frankly if I had to choose between a middle of the road sports car like an M5 or a G I'd choose the G every time. It's simply a more special vehicle and you can use it every day for everything - just like a Wrangler. View Quote P!ease stop trying to twist my words to support your point. I get that you have some enthusiasm for your personal choice of a specific model that is substantially different than the one being discussed. I also have a great deal of experience with the models that OP is considering. In my opinion the G63 is a giant compromise, in comparison to a more purpose built car. |
|
[#16]
Quoted: I also have a great deal of experience with the models that OP is considering. View Quote Don't buy a G63 if you want to off-road, you might have to buy some new tires |
|
[#17]
Neither of which are laughable. Your taste in automobiles is not everything to everyone.
|
|
[#18]
Quoted:
Neither of which are laughable. Your taste in automobiles is not everything to everyone. View Quote |
|
[#19]
Only worked on the surplus ones, was not impressed. Ultimately it's a Jeep. (a MB/GPW, not what they sell now).
|
|
[#20]
|
|
[#21]
I guess I'll go be poor somewhere else with my G500.
Which by the way, I love. The 5L V8 has plenty of power on the freeways here and the drivabilty both on road in crappy weather nad off road in moderate rough terrian makes me grin. Way better than my 94 D90, and makes me miss my 95 County a lot less. Tho almost nothing can beat the LWB County for interior space and multi surface drivability. |
|
[#22]
Quoted: This isn't a forum for soccer moms asking advice on what car they should buy. I can only conclude from having direct knowledge of the cars in question that you typed in the wrong web address. View Quote |
|
[#23]
|
|
[#24]
|
|
[#25]
I've always liked the G wagon because it is different, but I never even thought about buying one. For their size, there isn't much room and the interior felt old. It seemed like a compromise on all fronts. It isn't going to handle like anything meant to go fast, it won't provide as much utility as most other SUVs, it isn't as luxurious as any luxury car with that sticker price....to me, it is simply a statement piece. If that's what someone wants then great. I don't begrudge anyone for spending their money how they want.
On another note, have you ever done the AMG driving experience? I did it out at lime rock park a while back. It gave me a real appreciation for the AMG cars....they didn't use the G wagons for anything other than looks but we got to go nuts in everything else. Highly recommended |
|
[#26]
|
|
[#27]
Quoted:
I've always liked the G wagon because it is different, but I never even thought about buying one. For their size, there isn't much room and the interior felt old. It seemed like a compromise on all fronts. It isn't going to handle like anything meant to go fast, it won't provide as much utility as most other SUVs, it isn't as luxurious as any luxury car with that sticker price....to me, it is simply a statement piece. If that's what someone wants then great. I don't begrudge anyone for spending their money how they want. On another note, have you ever done the AMG driving experience? I did it out at lime rock park a while back. It gave me a real appreciation for the AMG cars....they didn't use the G wagons for anything other than looks but we got to go nuts in everything else. Highly recommended View Quote To use your terms it's a statement piece with a lot more utility than a statement piece typically offers. |
|
[#28]
A Gwagon has always been on my bucket list. I like all the different models but really wish Mercedes would sell a basic stripped down version here without the electronic gadgets. I’d buy one, have the entire exterior Line-X’d, throw some decent off road tires on it and keep it as my “forever” car...
|
|
[#29]
|
|
[#30]
|
|
[#31]
Quoted:
A Gwagon has always been on my bucket list. I like all the different models but really wish Mercedes would sell a basic stripped down version here without the electronic gadgets. I’d buy one, have the entire exterior Line-X’d, throw some decent off road tires on it and keep it as my “forever” car... View Quote |
|
[#32]
Quoted: The rear seats are short on legroom but the storage space is huge. If you never put adults in the back it's a non-issue and if you do it's not that horrible. The dash on the G is the same as the rest of the Mercedes of the era. The truck feels very well built. To use your terms it's a statement piece with a lot more utility than a statement piece typically offers. View Quote When I was talking about utility, my point was that you aren't likely to put anything other than groceries or sporting equipment in the back. If you have enough money for that car you have enough money for a proper truck or delivery if you are needing to haul anything serious. I've never owned anything close to the G63, but I had an X5 M and had this issue. I didn't even want it on gravel roads. I loved driving it but there was very little "utility". I'm going to have to look up the one you said you own. I've never hears of it before. European model? |
|
[#33]
G Wagon is my dream car but I’m poor so I got a JKU.
Both have plenty of utility for the ‘burbs. They haul more groceries than the neighbors car, sit high up, haul people, tow trailers and adventure off-road better than 90% of vehicles on the road. They do have a lot of road noise, have a very high center of gravity, and are bumpy. It’s very difficult to design a nice interior when the vehicle is shaped like a box. You don’t get sports car handling, Bentley interior finishes, and a quiet and smooth ride in a vehicle designed to excel off-road. |
|
[#34]
I'd take a used one for cheap if such a thing existed. But I can't fathom one of these being more capable off road than any Jeep Wrangler with the same amount of money in it.
I just watched some videos of these things off road and they look like they can do pretty damn decent. But I'm doubtful many in America buy them for that purpose. Or would even deign to let them get dirty. Overlooking the price tag they seem like nice little rigs. |
|
[#35]
Quoted: You Toyota fan boys are losing your edge. Almost 20 hours before you shit on a car thread. View Quote |
|
[#36]
Quoted: They are built like a tank! No denying that. With the right wheels and tires you could probably keep up with most off road because the G wagons, unless the 63 is different, have all of the locking diffs and what not to make life easier. I would venture to guess that no one is using it for that purpose or you wouldn't drop the extra coin on having it AMG badged. When I was talking about utility, my point was that you aren't likely to put anything other than groceries or sporting equipment in the back. If you have enough money for that car you have enough money for a proper truck or delivery if you are needing to haul anything serious. I've never owned anything close to the G63, but I had an X5 M and had this issue. I didn't even want it on gravel roads. I loved driving it but there was very little "utility". I'm going to have to look up the one you said you own. I've never hears of it before. European model? View Quote |
|
[#37]
|
|
[#38]
Keep your C63 and get a CPO GL500/450.
AMG on a SUV is just gratuitous bling. TC |
|
[#40]
View Quote |
|
[#41]
Quoted:
Around here we use them as cake wagons https://www.AR15.Com/media/mediaFiles/214288/24CB4D6E-EA4F-4CAA-902F-92D3E7D196AF_jpeg-753311.JPG View Quote |
|
[#42]
|
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.