SUCCESS!!
No-chill turned into a delicious, clean, cream-ale - just as it was supposed to be.
One thing I did different:
- at the end of the 60 minute boil, I poured the hot boiling wort directly into the 5 gallon fermenter (trying to keep as much of the trub in the brew kettle as possible).
I first sterilized the fermenter, but that was probably overkill since the boiling wort probably would have killed off anything left in the fermenter.
But in the “original Australian” method for no-chill brewing, they used a “cube” made of a temperature resistant plastic, before they pour the wort into the fermenter the following day. Like this:
I think the idea was to not expose the wort to air. But I’m not sure the small surface area left in a 5 gallon bucket makes that big of a difference - especially since I also used an airating stone to add pure O2 to the cooled wort just before I pitched the yeast.