User Panel
|
|
Weren't the Vietnam guys experienced shit hot infantry types as opposed to current day if you can pass the test you're in?
|
|
Quoted:
High school level wannabe thread. Green Berets don't really do the things. They mostly teach the things to indigenous "freedom fighters." You are probably confusing them with Delta. View Quote My Purple Heart, BS(V), and CIB would indicate that you don't know what much about SR/DA, CIF, or UW. If you would like the opportunity to correct your educational lack, PM me and we can discuss the most direct route to SFAS. 18Z50.....Nous DeFions. |
|
|
Quoted:
Until you have talked to (at length) one who was there in VN,,,STFU. My father served with a group of em for a year in the jungle, shit he has told me made my spine tingle. To be fair I did not myself have the honor to serve in Iraq/AFG as I was already out..(Cold Warrior) So I also should STFU as I don't know what those guys went through either....but to say one would easily outdo the other is asinine. View Quote that's just fucking stupid. why not stfu unless you have talked (at length) with one who was there in Iraq or Afghanistan ? |
|
|
Quoted: While both were badasses modern ones would kick the shit out of the old guys. View Quote Basic fieldcraft goes to the old guys, I think. Most everything else goes to the present day. Look a pics of "fit" people back then versus now. Put the old guys on the same exercise and nutrition regimen? They'll do just as good. Pluck them from time and space and line them up as is? New GWOT guys. Without question. |
|
Quoted:
Get both! See: Billy Waugh View Quote Technically he was with SAD during his time in GWOT. But yes, I see what you mean. Dude is 125% bad ass, from the Korean War all the way OIF and who knows what else. To sit down with him over a beer in his backyard and here stores. Man he could probably go on for days. |
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
High school level wannabe thread. Green Berets don't really do the things. They mostly teach the things to indigenous "freedom fighters." You are probably confusing them with Delta. What if it is OJT? Or CIF ? |
|
My Dad was a medevac medic in Vietnam, came back went to Ranger school did that for a couple years then went into SF. this was in the 80's-90's. And, yes he was definitely the "My dad can kick your dad's ass" guy.
|
|
Quoted:
Read the MACV/SOG book written by John Plaster. Some of the most hardcore soldiers ever to walk the earth. They walked into certain death, did incredible things and kicked some serious ass. They pretty much pioneered SF as we know it. Straight bad MFers. Modern SF are some of the best fighters in the world, and I have the utmost respect for these warriors. I wouldn't say one group is better than the other. All are heroes. View Quote That would be these guys... |
|
|
|
They died in Vietnam for maybe 5 years without any regular US troops supporting them. That is hardcore.
|
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
High school level wannabe thread. Green Berets don't really do the things. They mostly teach the things to indigenous "freedom fighters." You are probably confusing them with Delta. What if it is OJT? Or CIF ? CIF, CRE, potato, spuds. SR/DA were top of the list for so long, JADE HELM was created to balance out the UW shortfalls. My friends at USASOC still cringe when I remind them of that PR nightmare! |
|
|
Billy Waugh fought in both. I read his book. He said he liked combat in Vietnam more. He said something along the lines of it was "more personal" or something. He said he didn't like finding the enemy and calling in air support or something like that.
I read it a few years ago... |
|
One still in VN
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2316937/John-Hartley-Robertson-US-Army-veteran-living-Vietnam-village-44-YEARS-shot-down.html |
|
Quoted:
Billy Waugh fought in both. I read his book. He said he liked combat in Vietnam more. He said something along the lines of it was "more personal" or something. He said he didn't like finding the enemy and calling in air support or something like that. I read it a few years ago... View Quote Yeah, I read his book too. He didn't like outsourcing the job to the Air Force and Navy. |
|
|
Quoted:
High school level wannabe thread. Green Berets don't really do the things. They mostly teach the things to indigenous "freedom fighters." You are probably confusing them with Delta. View Quote Based upon the book I read awhile back they fight with the freedom fighters. Actually I read a book back in high school about Vietnam Green Berets and it was the same thing with that. Both are said to be non fiction but I don't kick doors or carry guns for a living so I don't know from experience. |
|
|
Quoted:
High school level wannabe thread. Green Berets don't really do the things. They mostly teach the things to indigenous "freedom fighters." You are probably confusing them with Delta. View Quote You are literally fucking joking right? Speaking of high school level posting.... Maybe in Thailand, Colombia, and Kenya that is true....but there are these other places where America has been involved in some fighting for the past few years. Maybe you have heard of one or two of them. |
|
|
Quoted:
The SOG guys were absolutely fucking nuts. Posted Via AR15.Com Mobile View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
While both were badasses modern ones would kick the shit out of the old guys. The SOG guys were absolutely fucking nuts. Posted Via AR15.Com Mobile Technology aside... pound for pound a SOG team at peak performance was the equal of any operator/s on the planet, then or now...... just MHO |
|
|
One thing unique about Vietnam is the in-theater training rotations that the Army established for SF and also for LRRPs. The turnover rate was very high, establishing the Jungle Schools in theater was very successful. I'm sure the key was in selecting the proper instructors. And going on a for-real, no shit clandestine mission to Laos as your final exam, could you imagine?
We had friends of our family, to be more precise my mom's best friend's husband, was a VN SF veteran. A cocky, 4'10" Italian from Chicago. I think he went over post AB and Ranger school with the 101st AB as the LRRP teams were being reorganized and then went to SF school in theater. I do remember that in their wedding pic (they got married while he was on leave somewhere around 69 or 70 maybe) he is wearing dress whites with Airborne, Ranger, and SF scrolls. He liked to tell the story about how he got medivaced out after getting his calf blown off in an ambush. One of the things I always remember him saying was "I walked point, loved the M14 but it was a big heavy bitch in the jungle". He said he carried a grease gun for awhile, then "when the new M16s came out I ditched the piece of shit and carried a sawed off shotgun with beehive rounds". Dude was not afraid of a fucking thing and loved to fight. When I was a snot nosed teenager in the 80s, we were drinking one time (if you were a teenager you could drink and smoke with Uncle Larry as long as you could "handle your shit") and wandering through the ghetto on foot on our way to the liquor store to get another bottle of Brandy. I asked him something to the effect of "why do you like to fight when you are only like three feet tall?" to which he replied "If you don't care, it doesn't fuckin' matta! Most people are scared to get hit and get hurt, I'm not. I tell those assholes to take their best shot, I've already had my ass kicked by bigger, uglier, meaner assholes than you", then flicked his cigarette into my chest and put me on my 6 foot ass. Apparently in the 90s the gang bangers started to get froggy and broke into his van a couple of times. Also threatened some friends next door. His response was something along the lines of "Gran Torino". They quit coming around. This guy is in his late 70s now, still walks with a swagger, dances like he gives no fucks, greases his hair in a pompadour, and still ain't afraid of shit. He's alot like a present day Navy SEAL. On the other hand, a friend of mine recently retired from 22 years in, he did 82ndAB, then Ranger School and SF. Was a 18C with 5th SFG, did a lot of different stuff and capped off his career with multiple combat tours in the ME and AFG. Same mentality, a lot more humble. Whereas my "Uncle" Larry sticks out, my friend blends in. Also has multiple degrees, he's more of the "thinking" warrior type. |
|
Quoted:
One thing unique about Vietnam is the in-theater training rotations that the Army established for SF and also for LRRPs. The turnover rate was very high, establishing the Jungle Schools in theater was very successful. I'm sure the key was in selecting the proper instructors. And going on a for-real, no shit clandestine mission to Laos as your final exam, could you imagine? We had friends of our family, to be more precise my mom's best friend's husband, was a VN SF veteran. A cocky, 4'10" Italian from Chicago. I think he went over post AB and Ranger school with the 101st AB as the LRRP teams were being reorganized and then went to SF school in theater. I do remember that in their wedding pic (they got married while he was on leave somewhere around 69 or 70 maybe) he is wearing dress whites with Airborne, Ranger, and SF scrolls. He liked to tell the story about how he got medivaced out after getting his calf blown off in an ambush. One of the things I always remember him saying was "I walked point, loved the M14 but it was a big heavy bitch in the jungle". He said he carried a grease gun for awhile, then "when the new M16s came out I ditched the piece of shit and carried a sawed off shotgun with beehive rounds". Dude was not afraid of a fucking thing and loved to fight. When I was a snot nosed teenager in the 80s, we were drinking one time (if you were a teenager you could drink and smoke with Uncle Larry as long as you could "handle your shit") and wandering through the ghetto on foot on our way to the liquor store to get another bottle of Brandy. I asked him something to the effect of "why do you like to fight when you are only like three feet tall?" to which he replied "If you don't care, it doesn't fuckin' matta! Most people are scared to get hit and get hurt, I'm not. I tell those assholes to take their best shot, I've already had my ass kicked by bigger, uglier, meaner assholes than you", then flicked his cigarette into my chest and put me on my 6 foot ass. Apparently in the 90s the gang bangers started to get froggy and broke into his van a couple of times. Also threatened some friends next door. His response was something along the lines of "Gran Torino". They quit coming around. This guy is in his late 70s now, still walks with a swagger, dances like he gives no fucks, greases his hair in a pompadour, and still ain't afraid of shit. He's alot like a present day Navy SEAL. On the other hand, a friend of mine recently retired from 22 years in, he did 82ndAB, then Ranger School and SF. Was a 18C with 5th SFG, did a lot of different stuff and capped off his career with multiple combat tours in the ME and AFG. Same mentality, a lot more humble. Whereas my "Uncle" Larry sticks out, my friend blends in. Also has multiple degrees, he's more of the "thinking" warrior type. View Quote Sorry, 4' 10" I don't believe it. I think Valor may have been stolen. |
|
|
Quoted:
Sorry, 4' 10" I don't believe it. I think Valor may have been stolen. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
One thing unique about Vietnam is the in-theater training rotations that the Army established for SF and also for LRRPs. The turnover rate was very high, establishing the Jungle Schools in theater was very successful. I'm sure the key was in selecting the proper instructors. And going on a for-real, no shit clandestine mission to Laos as your final exam, could you imagine? We had friends of our family, to be more precise my mom's best friend's husband, was a VN SF veteran. A cocky, 4'10" Italian from Chicago. I think he went over post AB and Ranger school with the 101st AB as the LRRP teams were being reorganized and then went to SF school in theater. I do remember that in their wedding pic (they got married while he was on leave somewhere around 69 or 70 maybe) he is wearing dress whites with Airborne, Ranger, and SF scrolls. He liked to tell the story about how he got medivaced out after getting his calf blown off in an ambush. One of the things I always remember him saying was "I walked point, loved the M14 but it was a big heavy bitch in the jungle". He said he carried a grease gun for awhile, then "when the new M16s came out I ditched the piece of shit and carried a sawed off shotgun with beehive rounds". Dude was not afraid of a fucking thing and loved to fight. When I was a snot nosed teenager in the 80s, we were drinking one time (if you were a teenager you could drink and smoke with Uncle Larry as long as you could "handle your shit") and wandering through the ghetto on foot on our way to the liquor store to get another bottle of Brandy. I asked him something to the effect of "why do you like to fight when you are only like three feet tall?" to which he replied "If you don't care, it doesn't fuckin' matta! Most people are scared to get hit and get hurt, I'm not. I tell those assholes to take their best shot, I've already had my ass kicked by bigger, uglier, meaner assholes than you", then flicked his cigarette into my chest and put me on my 6 foot ass. Apparently in the 90s the gang bangers started to get froggy and broke into his van a couple of times. Also threatened some friends next door. His response was something along the lines of "Gran Torino". They quit coming around. This guy is in his late 70s now, still walks with a swagger, dances like he gives no fucks, greases his hair in a pompadour, and still ain't afraid of shit. He's alot like a present day Navy SEAL. On the other hand, a friend of mine recently retired from 22 years in, he did 82ndAB, then Ranger School and SF. Was a 18C with 5th SFG, did a lot of different stuff and capped off his career with multiple combat tours in the ME and AFG. Same mentality, a lot more humble. Whereas my "Uncle" Larry sticks out, my friend blends in. Also has multiple degrees, he's more of the "thinking" warrior type. Sorry, 4' 10" I don't believe it. I think Valor may have been stolen. He might have been 5'2" or something, he wasn't a fucking midget but he was very short to my 6 foot tall self. As far as stolen valor, I've been a military fan my whole life and there is no stolen valor. I also saw his decorations including his purple heart, all boxed up sitting in a dusty closet in a spare bedroom. What is interesting is that when he came home he tried the Illinois NG for a tour (Artillery was the local unit) and he hated it. Said they were a bunch of slacker dipshits that couldn't find their ass with both hands. So he got out entirely after his NG stint, hung his shit in the closet, and that was it. Keeping in mind that I was an invited guest on base at my friend's retirement ceremony, I've seen a few uniforms and know what an infantry/Ranger/SF uniform is supposed to look like. This isn't a stolen valor deal. He doesn't go around bragging to random people. He has no army shit displayed anywhere, no SF shit stuck on everything. If you aren't family, you have no idea what he did in the 60s and he likes it that way. He has ONE friend from the military named Rey that he used to go to the American Legion hall with to play cards. |
|
So which team's trained locals win? Team Hmong/Montagnard or Team Sunni Awakening/Hazaras?
|
|
Quoted:
As far as I know, none of the current crop have released hit records. Advantage: Vietnam vintage. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
As far as I know, none of the current crop have released hit records. Advantage: Vietnam vintage. <mic drop> Quoted:
Fighting in desert is very different from fighting in canopy jungle. This is not a worthy adversary. I fucking love this thread. |
|
Quoted:
Read the MACV/SOG book written by John Plaster. Some of the most hardcore soldiers ever to walk the earth. They walked into certain death, did incredible things and kicked some serious ass. They pretty much pioneered SF as we know it. Straight bad MFers. Modern SF are some of the best fighters in the world, and I have the utmost respect for these warriors. I wouldn't say one group is better than the other. All are heroes. View Quote SOG did not pioneer SF. SOG was a separate entity composed of people from various places, many of whom were Chinese mercenaries paid by SOG, and led by their Team Leaders, in addition to the aviation, logistics, and intelligence cells. SF was pioneered from the OSS format of Jedburgh Teams in WWII. Aaron Banks started 10th Group in 1952. There was quite a bit of SF history well before SOG. SOG was a specific unit organized for the SEA theater. |
|
Quoted:
I can tell you as a kid my grandpa (far right) commanded my total respect http://i57.tinypic.com/2zgrj7o.jpg View Quote That guy on the left is a dead ringer for FREEFALLE7. |
|
|
Quoted:
That guy on the left is a dead ringer for FREEFALLE7. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
I can tell you as a kid my grandpa (far right) commanded my total respect http://i57.tinypic.com/2zgrj7o.jpg That guy on the left is a dead ringer for FREEFALLE7. And the grandpa looks familiar as well. Rambo maybe? Or A-team? Bad ass grandpa. |
|
Quoted:
Technology aside... pound for pound a SOG team at peak performance was the equal of any operator/s on the planet, then or now...... just MHO View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
While both were badasses modern ones would kick the shit out of the old guys. The SOG guys were absolutely fucking nuts. Posted Via AR15.Com Mobile Technology aside... pound for pound a SOG team at peak performance was the equal of any operator/s on the planet, then or now...... just MHO A Squad of guys from Ranger Regiment would crush them today. SOG was known for getting its mercenaries killed on a regular basis, most of whom were initially trained by SF, then snatched up with higher pay from SOG. A Squad of hooahs from Regiment out of the 80's would crush them, although it wouldn't be as easy as rolling up bugger-eaters. SOG had some excellent indigs and mercenaries they trained, and some pretty innovative tactics, but they would get wrecked by the studs if we're talking movement to contact or chance contact. There are only a few units with standards as high as Ranger Regiment, one of them is in the US (comprised of at least 66% former Ranger Regiment), and the others are in the UK. It's one thing to read the books, watch all the movies, and another to see the rubber meet the road. The modern Ranger Regiment is something even more refined than at any time in its history. |
|
Quoted:
One thing unique about Vietnam is the in-theater training rotations that the Army established for SF and also for LRRPs. The turnover rate was very high, establishing the Jungle Schools in theater was very successful. I'm sure the key was in selecting the proper instructors. And going on a for-real, no shit clandestine mission to Laos as your final exam, could you imagine? We had friends of our family, to be more precise my mom's best friend's husband, was a VN SF veteran. A cocky, 4'10" Italian from Chicago. I think he went over post AB and Ranger school with the 101st AB as the LRRP teams were being reorganized and then went to SF school in theater. I do remember that in their wedding pic (they got married while he was on leave somewhere around 69 or 70 maybe) he is wearing dress whites with Airborne, Ranger, and SF scrolls. He liked to tell the story about how he got medivaced out after getting his calf blown off in an ambush. One of the things I always remember him saying was "I walked point, loved the M14 but it was a big heavy bitch in the jungle". He said he carried a grease gun for awhile, then "when the new M16s came out I ditched the piece of shit and carried a sawed off shotgun with beehive rounds". Dude was not afraid of a fucking thing and loved to fight. When I was a snot nosed teenager in the 80s, we were drinking one time (if you were a teenager you could drink and smoke with Uncle Larry as long as you could "handle your shit") and wandering through the ghetto on foot on our way to the liquor store to get another bottle of Brandy. I asked him something to the effect of "why do you like to fight when you are only like three feet tall?" to which he replied "If you don't care, it doesn't fuckin' matta! Most people are scared to get hit and get hurt, I'm not. I tell those assholes to take their best shot, I've already had my ass kicked by bigger, uglier, meaner assholes than you", then flicked his cigarette into my chest and put me on my 6 foot ass. Apparently in the 90s the gang bangers started to get froggy and broke into his van a couple of times. Also threatened some friends next door. His response was something along the lines of "Gran Torino". They quit coming around. This guy is in his late 70s now, still walks with a swagger, dances like he gives no fucks, greases his hair in a pompadour, and still ain't afraid of shit. He's alot like a present day Navy SEAL. On the other hand, a friend of mine recently retired from 22 years in, he did 82ndAB, then Ranger School and SF. Was a 18C with 5th SFG, did a lot of different stuff and capped off his career with multiple combat tours in the ME and AFG. Same mentality, a lot more humble. Whereas my "Uncle" Larry sticks out, my friend blends in. Also has multiple degrees, he's more of the "thinking" warrior type. View Quote SF Scroll? SF School in Theater? The JFKSWC has always been where it is, and Teams from the States trained up pre-deployment with an integral ODA. 5th Group ran a certain course for LRRP units out of Nha Trang, but the Special Forces Training Courses for the different MOSs was at Bragg and some of the Medic Course at Sam Houston back then. Jungle Schools? Tube mag fed shotgun over detachable box mag M16 (the primary shoulder fired weapon on every ODA in SEA)? I'm going to have to throw the BS flag. |
|
|
Quoted:
Yep. Just wait until an ODA is being lead by a Female and she is having to deal with her local counter-part who just so happens to be a moslem man. Thats when their training will really kick in. View Quote I don't think you knuckle-draggers get the strategic value that female Captain will bring to the table when she's advising a Yememi Political Security Officer on human rights and shit. You need more Marie Harf in your life. |
|
|
|
I remember reading somewhere in "Hunting the Jackal" where Billy Waugh says modern SOF is much stronger than it was when he was in VN. Considering he served as a GB and SOG in VN, then worked with GB/CIA in Afganistan (and I haven't done any) I'll defer to his opinion.
Although, in reading his book what stuck out to me was the "we had the right ideas, but the technology wasn't there". Considering modern SOF builds on the lessons learned over the last several decades, with GWOT accelerating that, it makes sense. We've had advancements in weapons, TTPs (conventional and un-conventional), technology, communications, exercise/health sciences, medicine. We can straight up build better soldiers today than in the past with newer tooling. That doesn't take away from the VN era SOF, it's just a natural progression of what's able to be accomplished. |
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.