I would like to chime in as an adoptive father. My son is Dominican and was adopted at 6-days old. He is also a naturalized American citizen.
My wife and I went for a foreign adoption due to the crazy patchwork of US adoption laws, the waiting, etc. When we were looking to adopt 17 years ago the state of US adoptions was dismal. Every lawyer and agency wanted a cut of the action, no one could guarantee us a son- we were told if when we came to the top of the list if it was a girl and we refused then we dropped down to the bottom. The wait list was 2+ years. Every year would be more and more fees to "keep our place" and to "recertify your paperwork". Plus in some states adoptions were open, in others a birth parent years after the fact could challenge the adoption if some archaic law was overlooked, etc.
Finally we met a woman who had adopted an Ecuadorian child. We were put in touch with LAPAA (Latin American Parents Adoptive Association). Within a year we had our son at a total cost that was less then even trying for a year for a domestic adoption. There is a reason American go to Eastern Europe, Latin America, Asian, and African adoption sources that have nothing to do with "white guilt". We dont feel guilty- we just wanted a son to raise that was happy, healthy, and that we did not have to fear someone showing up on our doorstep trying to either get him back or insinuate themselves into our lives. How would any of you feel if you knew there was a chance of this?
If the US would ever streamline the adoption process- to include a law where adoptions are final and non-revocable barring criminal acts and allowing either party to make an adoption "closed"- this may go a long way towards having more US adoptions. As it stands now the process is still fractured and shadowed by local, state and federal laws that make internal adoptions a tremendous headache and heartache as well as a financial strain. Who needs that emotional rollercoaster when many couples want the chance at a family? Why the surprise that American couples seek to adopt overseas?
Life has been pretty good with our son even though he currently is the typical middle-class teenager (I told him toleave home now while he still knows everything!)