Quote History Quoted:
Tactical shooting is different from competition shooting, and many of the skill sets for either of those specialties make a shooter less able, or less skilled in the other area. Skills that make someone a better tactical shooter will make them have worse scores in competition, and skills that make competition shooter better will put that person at risk in a true tactical environment.
Many of the skills cross over, but shooters who WANT TO EXCEL in either area, need to choose one area to specialize in. Choosing to be reasonably good in both areas is also a valid choice, but to truly excel in either area requires working harder on the skill sets for that area. This is no different than a competition swimmer choosing whether they want to specialize in back stroke, breast stroke, or be a medley swimmer.
ETA: In one match, I switched the pistol from right hand on the right side of a barricade to left hand for the left side of the barricade. Because I had trained at reducing how much of my body I exposed in various positions I didn't even realize I had switched hands until one of the other people in my squad asked me why I changed hands when it wasn't required by the course description. It would have been to my advantage in the competition to shoot the entire course strong handed, but tactically, switching to my support hand reduced how much of myself I exposed to the "threat" .
View Quote
Man I hear this a lot. I live near Bragg in NC. There are green berets coming out of the woodwork around here. It is also a Mecca for shooting competition of all kinds, with World Champions at many matches (Todd Jarret, Chris Tilley, etc).
Many of these soldiers shoot competition as well. Some are world class. So they do excel at
both. Last 3gun match I attended, HALF my squad was GB's! Some great and some learning. Some of these men are personal friends.
This idea that a highly trained military operator can't do both is
false.
If they thought competition "would get them keeelt on the too-way range". They wouldn't do it.
Just ask one. They will tell you the opposite is true. If they have ever shot competition.
I assure everyone: Robby Gordon can still drive a basic Hmmv. And if bombs were falling all around, he'd be the guy you want driving. This is a better analogy than the swimming one.
Shooting: firing a projectile at a target. Doing it faster and more accurately is
better no matter how you slice it or what your job or hobby is.
As Leatham once said: Shooting is shooting.
Learning how to clear a room, defend a position, call in air strikes is
not shooting. And, competition shooting will teach you none of these things. Because it is not shooting. But if you learn these things, being an awesome shooter can't possibly hurt, can it? Of course not. It would help tremendously.
These guys are there to improve their
shooting skills. Just my experience with it.