I think the size 1-1/2 is recommended for 9/.38 but not .40 from what I learned recently. They aren't rated for higher pressure supposedly. I remember because I put a note on the brick I have in that size. Didn’t know that until I think I learned it recently, probably on this reloading forum.
I do have some anecdotal info- WA state ammo contract mid 90’s was Remington. Some folks complained about them having hard primers (my dad hated that ammo in .38/.357 mainly, and had issue with it sometimes). Personally I didn’t have trouble in my G22, but I did see guys having a lot of issues at the quals with S&W autos for various reasons. I wasn’t an armorer/instructor yet so I didn’t pay that much attention. Their weapons were a complete hodgepodge so that may have been part of it. (go to qual on rifles- out comes an AR15, a Mini14, a MAK90, an SKS, an M1A, etc. Crazy.). (My dad was the one with the MAK90). I was just a reserve with them so getting to go out and shoot their ammo was great. I later became an instructor at other agencies, and in my time learned to hate both CCI Blazer aluminum cased ammo, and Winchester lead free primers. (Both are great for lots of malfunction drills...)
Anyhow- To this day, my dad bitches about Remington primers.... who knows. He reloads plenty for hunting and knows what he is doing, but doesn’t do as much handgun loading.
I have loaded a lot of the Rem primers myself, no issue loading, but haven’t shot that much of those loadings up yet. No issue with the ones I have used so far.