Beerbellybo, read my post down this page a bit:
https://www.ar15.com/forums/Armory/My-Mini-30-Experiences/52-492079/
While my Mini's are in 7.62 x 39 caliber, excepting the ammo, my experiences apply to Mini-14's as well.
Especially read the part about using a smaller gas bushing and buffers.
The main reason your scope is getting battered, is because the Mini comes WAY overgassed. Tone that down, and the brass won't be coming out of there with such force. It is still plenty to be 100% reliable. Only a doofus chokes down his Mini till the brass "Falls At His Feet". He is close to having a single shot carbine.
Not having brass slam against your scope is just one of the many advantages of mounting an optic, whether scope or dot, out on the Ultimak.
The aluminum railed handguards mount securely and help in the accuracy and heat sink department.
Having only a tiny T.V. screen dot out in front of you half way down the barrel, you can see that dot on the target clearly, but also see everything else downrange.
Shooting a scope, or even a big tube sight up close to your head, and to top it off, most guys are used to closing the other eye when shooting.
About as "tunnel vision" as you can get.
I have the Tech rear sights on both my Mini's, along with the optional smaller aperture that makes the front sight appear sharp again instead of blurry.
I've shot rear aperture sights all my life on military rifles, lever guns, air guns, you name it.
It's fun to shoot irons once in a while, but the irons pale next to the red dot, IMO.
I can shoot as accurate with irons as I can with the dot, for about the same distance, but where the dot shines is speed and low light.
You have to take a split second longer to use irons, the dot is easier to pick up, especially in low light, and move from target to target faster.
Most dots have no set eye relief, so they will work at whatever distance from your eye.
My daughter has the hang of it, but she's been shooting my Mini-30's for about 4 years now.
I set up one just like this for her, so now she has the Mini-30 and a 9mm Shield I gave her.
That Vortex red dot, or your new 1-4x would work great on the Mini.
I wouldn't mess with filing the extractor, etc. There are some ways to relieve the Ruger rails if your brass is hitting the rail instead of the scope. Toning down the excessive gas and slowing ejection is the first and best waythough, and will give help in the accuracy department too.
Either of my Mini's will shoot close to what my x39 AR will, better with some brands. And even good with cheap Russian HP ammo:
For scopes, you'll have to stick with a LER model, but there are a dozen or so to work with, including some you'd might not expect, like the Nikon scope shown here, it isn't really a "scout scope" but a handgun scope, but I've enjoyed it's clearness, 2.5-8x zoom, and a couple BDC lines for holdovers, on both Mini's and my GSR .308.
pjomalley, unless you've just funnin' with us, maybe you'd like to tell me, in as much detail as I try to give, about your experiences with the Mini.
Most guys that give a one liner remark about the Mini, either have never owned one and just repeating what they heard on the internet, or that their cousin knew someone once that said they sucked.