User Panel
I built 2 carbines from a couple Springfield Armory receivers and some great condition parts kits.
They turned out so well, were completely reliable and accurate that I ended up selling my 2 WW2 M1 Carbines. Attached File |
|
What serial number range are your receivers ? What barrels did you use?
|
|
|
|
My “Semi custom” will be as close to 100% SA parts that I can locate with the FA Match barrel !!!! It will look just like a M1 carbine should ??
|
|
|
After this, I’m checking myself into the M1-aholics program to quit buying or building these damn addictive rifles !!!!
|
|
Quoted: After this, I’m checking myself into the M1-aholics program to quit buying or building these damn addictive rifles !!!! View Quote Tell me about it And now there are 2 M1 Garands in the house, and I'm telling myself when I get the gun fund back up if I see a nice "service" grade one for sale I should get it since both of those are CMP Expert models. I don't think we'll find any sponsors this forum Just fellow addicts |
|
Quoted: SWEET I would imagine Fulton would install the front sight and barrel band while they install the new barrel. What's your "semi-custom" plans........I hear that on M1 Carbines and visions of this come to mind https://images34.fotki.com/v1633/photos/9/4114449/16422201/photo2-vi.jpg That just ain't right Fulton still has it getting de-Bubba'd View Quote That's a pretty rifle. Someone put some time into that, just needs drilling & tapping for a scope mount w/ that stock. |
|
I have a nice M1 Carbine built off a SA M1 Carbine receiver and all US GI parts. Wish I had 2 or 3 more
|
|
Quoted: That's a pretty rifle. Someone put some time into that, just needs drilling & tapping for a scope mount w/ that stock. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: SWEET I would imagine Fulton would install the front sight and barrel band while they install the new barrel. What's your "semi-custom" plans........I hear that on M1 Carbines and visions of this come to mind https://images34.fotki.com/v1633/photos/9/4114449/16422201/photo2-vi.jpg That just ain't right Fulton still has it getting de-Bubba'd That's a pretty rifle. Someone put some time into that, just needs drilling & tapping for a scope mount w/ that stock. No drilling for scopes. Outside of jeweling the bolt it's a standard M1 Carbine. It was also the best shape USGI I ever bought, barrel gauged .05 on my CMP gauge. That's the main reason I want it back to USGI spec, it'll become a heirloom gun |
|
How does the cost compare of building a rifle and buying one?
I kind of want to do an M1A1 clone but I’m cheap. |
|
Quoted: How does the cost compare of building a rifle and buying one? I kind of want to do an M1A1 clone but I’m cheap. View Quote Honest, it's probably cheaper to buy one and get a repro Para stock than building one. I wanted a M1A1 clone myself and stalked Gunbroker for months until I saw this Don't ask what I paid, you'll hate me for it :) |
|
Quoted: Honest, it's probably cheaper to buy one and get a repro Para stock than building one. I wanted a M1A1 clone myself and stalked Gunbroker for months until I saw this Don't ask what I paid, you'll hate me for it :) View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: How does the cost compare of building a rifle and buying one? I kind of want to do an M1A1 clone but I’m cheap. Honest, it's probably cheaper to buy one and get a repro Para stock than building one. I wanted a M1A1 clone myself and stalked Gunbroker for months until I saw this Don't ask what I paid, you'll hate me for it :) Very nice. I paid $1,800 for my only carbine and I’m not willing to spend anywhere near that for another one, I guess I’m out of luck. |
|
Quoted: Very nice. I paid $1,800 for my only carbine and I’m not willing to spend anywhere near that for another one, I guess I’m out of luck. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: How does the cost compare of building a rifle and buying one? I kind of want to do an M1A1 clone but I’m cheap. Honest, it's probably cheaper to buy one and get a repro Para stock than building one. I wanted a M1A1 clone myself and stalked Gunbroker for months until I saw this Don't ask what I paid, you'll hate me for it :) Very nice. I paid $1,800 for my only carbine and I’m not willing to spend anywhere near that for another one, I guess I’m out of luck. Just get a Paratrooper stock and swap around between them. Or keep a eye on the EE and see if one comes up at a price you would pay for one. $1800 is high for a Carbine IMO depending where you are |
|
Yeah…. DonFlynn basically stole a damn nice $1500 gun for nothing. Pretty sure get could have put a GI stock and bolt and it was back to awesome GI issue shape
|
|
I have never handled a SA carbine, I suppose they are one of the better commercial made receivers?
|
|
Quoted: Just get a Paratrooper stock and swap around between them. Or keep a eye on the EE and see if one comes up at a price you would pay for one. $1800 is high for a Carbine IMO depending where you are View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: How does the cost compare of building a rifle and buying one? I kind of want to do an M1A1 clone but I’m cheap. Honest, it's probably cheaper to buy one and get a repro Para stock than building one. I wanted a M1A1 clone myself and stalked Gunbroker for months until I saw this Don't ask what I paid, you'll hate me for it :) Very nice. I paid $1,800 for my only carbine and I’m not willing to spend anywhere near that for another one, I guess I’m out of luck. Just get a Paratrooper stock and swap around between them. Or keep a eye on the EE and see if one comes up at a price you would pay for one. $1800 is high for a Carbine IMO depending where you are I may do that. It was one of the MidwayUSA VG-fine Winchesters. I’m happy with it, but even with all the early parts I know I overpaid. |
|
Quoted: Yeah…. DonFlynn basically stole a damn nice $1500 gun for nothing. Pretty sure get could have put a GI stock and bolt and it was back to awesome GI issue shape View Quote It takes a thief Theme v2 I'm just hoping FA can refinish the bolt on Bubba. That was pure luck being Xmas week on Gunbroker. Right now the plan is using a Numrich stock while it's at FA for the repark, then look for a Inland stock reasonable price or use a Boyd's I have finished here on it. That'll depend on how I like shooting the Paratrooper FA Carbine tomorrow.......it's FINALLY going to the range tomorrow |
|
Quoted: I have never handled a SA carbine, I suppose they are one of the better commercial made receivers? View Quote Springfield Armory offered two runs of M1 Carbine receivers. http://www.m1carbinesinc.com/carbine_springfield.html The 1st run were cast receivers, similar to what was offered by other commercial manufactures at the time. The 2nd, more desirable and what the OP has were made by LMT using forged receivers and were considered "USGI" spec. Their sought after by Carbine builders as the equal to USGI ones. Fulton Armory used the same supplier for their Carbines, which are considered equal to USGI production Carbines |
|
Quoted: I paid $1,800 for my only carbine and I’m not willing to spend anywhere near that for another one, I guess I’m out of luck. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: How does the cost compare of building a rifle and buying one? I kind of want to do an M1A1 clone but I’m cheap. Honest, it's probably cheaper to buy one and get a repro Para stock than building one. I wanted a M1A1 clone myself and stalked Gunbroker for months until I saw this Don't ask what I paid, you'll hate me for it :) Very nice. Honest, at that time those were the best deal in town for a 1st time Carbine. Hard core nuts like myself and M60E4 always have our eye's open for deals. That FA paratrooper for example, I posted it here to give people a chance for 3-4 days before I talked myself into it (and beat M60E4 by a hair IIRR ). Just get a Paratrooper stock and swap around between them. Or keep a eye on the EE and see if one comes up at a price you would pay for one. $1800 is high for a Carbine IMO depending where you are I may do that. It was one of the MidwayUSA VG-fine Winchesters. I’m happy with it, but even with all the early parts I know I overpaid. I paid $1,800 for my only carbine and I’m not willing to spend anywhere near that for another one, I guess I’m out of luck. https://www.gunpartscorp.com/products/983120 I was planning on getting this for "Bubba" when FA finishes the repark. Still might, it'll depend on how I like shooting the Para tomorrow when I hit the range |
|
Quoted: I built 2 carbines from a couple Springfield Armory receivers and some great condition parts kits. They turned out so well, were completely reliable and accurate that I ended up selling my 2 WW2 M1 Carbines. https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/1241/5B008D66-2BA9-41A0-964B-75076CCECF76_jpe-2357403.JPG View Quote I love that bottom stock |
|
Quoted: I’ll have to check tomorrow when I’m home. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: What serial number range are your receivers ? What barrels did you use? I’ll have to check tomorrow when I’m home. They are both forged receivers, serial numbers SC 129XX & SC 128XX. The kits I bought were excellent condition but definitely not original as the barrels are dated SA 11 51 & SA 8 51. I was never looking for any collector value just wanted the best parts to build the best shooting guns I could build. I’ve only ever shot them at a 25 yard indoor range but I was very happy with the accuracy and both have been 100% reliable. I have a Sarco M1 Carbine folding paratrooper stock that I had briefly installed on one of these rifles but wasn’t totally happy with it so I put the original stock back on. I don’t miss my WW2 original carbines at all, eventually sold both of them for $1,000 each, while building both of these 2 Springfield Armory carbines in 1998-1999 cost me less than $750 including receivers and parts kits. The receivers used to sell for $125 each, what a bargain, wish I’d bought 10 of them. Of course forget about buying reasonably priced parts kits today. |
|
Quoted: Quoted: I built 2 carbines from a couple Springfield Armory receivers and some great condition parts kits. They turned out so well, were completely reliable and accurate that I ended up selling my 2 WW2 M1 Carbines. https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/1241/5B008D66-2BA9-41A0-964B-75076CCECF76_jpe-2357403.JPG I love that bottom stock I actually prefer the top slimmer stock than the bottom “pot bellied” stock for shooting. Slimmer stock is more comfortable to hold while shooting. It does have nice color to it though as opposed to the dark color of the top stock. |
|
|
Don,
I didn’t really like my A1 stock. Damn things are too uncomfortable and the swing out stock isn’t firm. I kept mine for the looks only. The wood sticks are no doubt the perfect stocks as far as comfort ….. and looks !!!! |
|
Quoted: Don, I didn’t really like my A1 stock. Damn things are too uncomfortable and the swing out stock isn’t firm. I kept mine for the looks only. The wood sticks are no doubt the perfect stocks as far as comfort ….. and looks !!!! View Quote Yeah, I'm with you on that. I did not enjoy shooting the FA Para today on it's range test and think the wobble caused 1 FTF me messing with it. I'll post results on that after I eat my Chinese food here in a bit. I do know 1st chance I get I'll grab a stock from FA and finish it out, or use the 1 I'm saving for Bubba and swap around this summer when FA gets done with its repark |
|
|
|
Quoted: Right now the only game in town are the Numrich models I linked. I believe their made in Italy, they used M1a1 stocks on their Carbines and made them when they couldn't get US supplied ones View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Who makes the best A1 stocks? I’m thinking about getting one. Right now the only game in town are the Numrich models I linked. I believe their made in Italy, they used M1a1 stocks on their Carbines and made them when they couldn't get US supplied ones Oops, missed that. Thanks. |
|
|
Quoted: I mean, that was also true of early Universals, all Plainfields, most of the other clone carbines... View Quote My statement was not meant to imply otherwise. My point was that SAI Inc Carbine receivers are really nice/highly regarded and that GI parts fit them fine, not that GI parts fit them fine, but other Commercial receivers have issues with GI parts, etc. |
|
Quoted: My statement was not meant to imply otherwise. My point was that SAI Inc Carbine receivers are really nice/highly regarded and that GI parts fit them fine, not that GI parts fit them fine, but other Commercial receivers have issues with GI parts, etc. View Quote I am particularly disappointed in the Kahr Arms/Auto Ordnance. It would've cost them noting more to build a fully parts compatible carbine. |
|
Quoted: My statement was not meant to imply otherwise. My point was that SAI Inc Carbine receivers are really nice/highly regarded and that GI parts fit them fine, not that GI parts fit them fine, but other Commercial receivers have issues with GI parts, etc. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: I mean, that was also true of early Universals, all Plainfields, most of the other clone carbines... My statement was not meant to imply otherwise. My point was that SAI Inc Carbine receivers are really nice/highly regarded and that GI parts fit them fine, not that GI parts fit them fine, but other Commercial receivers have issues with GI parts, etc. Auto Ordnance and "New" Inland fall into this category. Their bolts and receivers differ from USGI specs so you can't use a A/O bolt on a USGI spec gun and vice versa. |
|
Quoted: I am particularly disappointed in the Kahr Arms/Auto Ordnance. It would've cost them noting more to build a fully parts compatible carbine. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: My statement was not meant to imply otherwise. My point was that SAI Inc Carbine receivers are really nice/highly regarded and that GI parts fit them fine, not that GI parts fit them fine, but other Commercial receivers have issues with GI parts, etc. I am particularly disappointed in the Kahr Arms/Auto Ordnance. It would've cost them noting more to build a fully parts compatible carbine. I was just disappointed with A/O Kahr's in general. I had 1 in 2007 that was a POS, spent most of the warranty period going back to A/O to fix feed issues. All they would do is cut up perfectly good USGI mags I would send in that worked on my other carbines. I've passed on cheap A/O's ever since. I could have bought a NIB one 2020 for $499 on a sale and bought a use 1966 production Plainfield instead with no regrets. Kahr screwed up when they copied the USGI Carbine they measured for their guide, they made the bolt longer but screwed up and kept the chamber USGI length. Their "fix" is reaming the chamber to fit. |
|
This thread reminds me, pretty sure I have an SA M2 stock somewhere.
I need to look for it now. |
|
|
|
|
Quoted: So my receiver and bolt are on their way to Fulton Armory to get the barrel installed. I pulled my 2 Fulton Armory Trigger Groups and I built up my SA Trigger Group for my new build. I got a gunsmith buddy who did some work on them to lighten them up and smooth them out. Fulton Armory ( Rock-ola marked) https://i.imgur.com/nzKaHvW.jpg Fulton Armory ( un marked ) https://i.imgur.com/TSoR5Au.jpg Springfield Armory https://i.imgur.com/qoabyIJ.jpg View Quote Smooth |
|
|
|
Quoted: Got my call from Fulton Armory today and my receiver and bolt arrived safe and sound. The are going to install a Chrome Lined Barrel, front and rear sight, type 3 band, and gas piston. I also received by SA stock from NoMoAmmo…. Stock is great with some character to boot. I started my own BLO and hand rubbing regiment. My trigger housing is assembled with SA housing, SA trigger, SA hammer…. I also have an SA slide. Just missing an SA mag catch. https://i.imgur.com/WkTCsm4.jpg If any of you M1aholics have any SA parts you’d like to part with please let me know. !!! View Quote Cool |
|
Quoted: My trigger housing is assembled with SA housing, SA trigger, SA hammer…. I also have an SA slide. Just missing an SA mag catch. https://i.imgur.com/WkTCsm4.jpg If any of you M1aholics have any SA parts you’d like to part with please let me know. !!! View Quote How is your SA hammer marked? Do you have an SA TIII sear? Unmarked from what I can remember, but identifiable by the machining on the nose. When I built up my SA trigger group, the only way I was able to determine that I had a SA made magazine catch was to take it out of the sealed package. It is not marked to indicate who made it. Are you going to look for an SA TIII barrel band with the bayonet lug for your Fulton barrel? I can't remember if SA made front sights at the moment, but they made milled rear sights for sure. |
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.