User Panel
Posted: 4/14/2023 9:53:44 AM EDT
For a person who wants to hunt, plink, have a handy, muli purpose .308 for general use.
Personally I am really appreciating the lighter, more simplistic scout type bolt guns. Of course a light AR-10 variant would probably be better than either. I know this has been best to death, resurrected and beat to death again.. |
|
The Q "Fix" is a more modern and improved version of the Ruger Scout. The Fix is 6.4 pounds.
That being said, I'd take the Ruger SFAR (lightweight AR10) above the others. It's 6.8 pounds. I wouldn't choose a M1A. They are cool, but heavy and obsolete to be honest. |
|
Thanks for your response and those well thought out recommendations Sir!
The reason I am starting to shy away from AR's is because I'm left handed with some post Covid lung issues, so unfortunately the less smoke etc.. I breathe the better. I'll definitely have a look at the Q Fix and SIG Cross perhaps too. |
|
Dont own one yet, but heard decent things about the mossberg MVP in .308.
|
|
I haven't seen a SFAR to compare too but my Ruger GST is a featherweight compared to my AR10 pr my M1A (scout version). The Fix has some bolt lift issues. It seems it's not talked about a whole lot but just about any video of the Q rifle shows a heavy bolt lift after firing with many guys using the scope body as leverage to lift the bolt. Not sure what that's about but I see it on a lot of videos. Even the Sig, isn't going to save any weight though it will be seen as a more accurate rifle. The GSR's I've had were very accurate with the right handload. The Mossberg offerings come with stocks that were shaped to feel like a cinderblock.
|
|
M1A Scout is an ok choice, but not the best anymore. I really like them, they are fun to shoot with irons. Optics mounting is questionable really unless you are going to put on the forward mounted scope.
SFAR is probably the best choice now if you are going with 308. Near the weight of standard AR, easy optics mounting. Probably a TA33 on an SFAR 16" with a good sling is going the be the best all around. My only qualm would be in long term SFAR use - hasn't been around that long, so not sure all the bugs are worked out. If you get one, shoot it a good bit and prove it. If you must have a bolt - Ruger Scout is OK, Sig Cross or Q Fix as noted above, Steyr Scout would also be a nice option. Sig, Q, and Steyr all are around 6.5 lbs I think. Not sure about the Ruger. |
|
My polymer stocked 308 Ruger is 7.5 lbs with sling, mag, Aimpoint 9000SC and Hill People gear ammo carrier on buttstock.
The MDT 3 round mag makes the mag almost flush with the stock and more carry friendly, in my opinion. |
|
You could always get a Howa 308 barreled action from Brownells and put it in what ever chassis or stock you want.
|
|
You can't really compare a semi-automatic battle rifle to a hunting-style bolt action.
|
|
I loved the M1A, shot it better than AR10s, FALs, HKs etc. It was more accurate than any of those when shooting anything except from a bench.
I've had standard, national match, and a Scout. With the scout, a red dot can be mounted on the forward Picatinny rail, or a scout scope / pistol scope. I've never had issues mounting a red dot or a scope on the standard receivers. Never had fitment issues, never had problems with repeatability, even when removing one optic for another, like switching between a scope and a dot, which I did, as well as a night vision optic. The mount was the same, was held in place tightly with the side screw and stripper clip guide, and one screw to level the mount on the side of the receiver top. But that screw is a one time thing. I can't tell you what to buy, but if it were me, having had all the major players other than the SFAR, I would go M1A in some configuration, with a synthetic stock. |
|
I liked my m1a bush until I switched to shooting rifles left handed, then I was constantly getting pinched by the oprod.
Steyr scout was good |
|
Held a M1a tanker the other day and was impressed with its weight.
Have played with the Ruger scouts and always found them to be kinda meh. |
|
I love a good M1A (I own two), but the only way I'd consider one for your requirements of being "handy" and "general purpose" is if you go for the SOCOM or Tanker models with their 16" barrels. In their Scout or full-length 22" guise, they're too bulky to be a "general purpose" rifle.
And at that point, for your requirements, you'd be better off getting one of the new-age bolt actions you listed off, which will be lighter, more ergonomic, and not put any gas in your face (referencing your requirement for low gas). Buy an M1A if you want one--they're super cool rifles--but I would not advise buying it specifically to fill your handy, general purpose rifle requirement. |
|
Ruger SFAR is pretty amazing(I shoot lefty also and have had no issues with it. If you are going bolt the bergara b-14 SP is really with looking at. Short handy package at a good price. It is not really a scout rifle, but if you are not intending in forward mounting scope it would fit the desired purpose nicely.
|
|
I have an M1A Scout Squad i bought years ago when they first came out. Found this Hopco mount for an RMR that fits an M1 or M1A. The mount is fairly cheap. So I ordered one.
You can find them Here |
|
Quoted: I have an M1A Scout Squad i bought years ago when they first came out. Found this Hopco mount for an RMR that fits an M1 or M1A. The mount is fairly cheap. So I ordered one. You can find them Here https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/89/7d4d5e_ed799e3569564ec7ad1151793b8cb582_-2791605.jpg View Quote Another option as well if you want some magnification. Attached File https://cogburnarsenal.com/product/m1-m14-microprism-mount/ |
|
I want to love the M1a but the 3 I’ve owned have underwhelmed
People shoot them well somehow, it can be done just not by me I guess. AR15s spoiled me I think |
|
Quoted: Another option as well if you want some magnification. https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/424008/IMG_4242_jpeg-2791622.JPG https://cogburnarsenal.com/product/m1-m14-microprism-mount/ View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: I have an M1A Scout Squad i bought years ago when they first came out. Found this Hopco mount for an RMR that fits an M1 or M1A. The mount is fairly cheap. So I ordered one. You can find them Here https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/89/7d4d5e_ed799e3569564ec7ad1151793b8cb582_-2791605.jpg Another option as well if you want some magnification. https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/424008/IMG_4242_jpeg-2791622.JPG https://cogburnarsenal.com/product/m1-m14-microprism-mount/ Oh snap |
|
Quoted: Another option as well if you want some magnification. https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/424008/IMG_4242_jpeg-2791622.JPG https://cogburnarsenal.com/product/m1-m14-microprism-mount/ View Quote If you order that, you better order these at the same time: Attached File Attached File |
|
For op's stated purposes, the Ruger scout rifle really is a great option. Relatively lightweight (especially with the polymer stock), simple, effective.
I have a scout scope for it but i actually just enjoy shooting it with irons and never mount the scope. Attached File Attached File |
|
The new breed of small frame AR10 rifles are definitely light.
But in my opinion, a bolt gun just feels lighter and more compact for the same weight. |
|
I don't have an SFAR (yet), but I do have a 12.5" and 16" 308 Rogue, which are what the SFAR seems to have been based on.
They are what I would use if I wanted a carry around 308 in most cases. The gun itself is as light as the Ruger scout. I would want an optic and light on any gun I dedicated for "general use." The SCAR is a fun option, but it wouldn't be my top choice. A 12-13" 308 would be plenty for any hunting within a few hundred yards. But if you're a lefty with issues getting gas in the face, the bolt gun is a better option. Attached File Attached File |
|
Quoted: Another option as well if you want some magnification. https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/424008/IMG_4242_jpeg-2791622.JPG https://cogburnarsenal.com/product/m1-m14-microprism-mount/ View Quote Holy cow, that's some creative thinking. You just might have sold me on one from the picture alone. |
|
I like the Ruger Scout a lot, but for me with your intended purpose (if I couldn't get both), I'd go M1A or AR10. M1A if you want iron and wood/traditional rifle look, AR10 if you don't care about that. The AR10 is very versatile and easy for the end user to wrench on.
|
|
As a lefty, I have an lrb 308 brush/scout rifle with an 18" barrel. It's nice.
I want a socom for a general bounce around .308 but I can't find one cheap enough to do it. If I ever find one for $1100, $1200, I'll be all over it. |
|
I mean, "a handy, multi purpose rifle for general use" is pretty much exactly what the scout rifle concept was intended to be. I believe the Steyr is the only one that Cooper personally was involved with. The Ruger obviously bears the "Gunsite" name, so it would seem to have some connection to Cooper's ideas, but the question would be how much... I guess what I'm saying is, if you're into a scout, check out the options and see what you like.
|
|
If I were left handed and wanted a general purpose hunting .308 I would consider:
Browning BAR hunting semiauto in .308. The synthetic stock version is only 6 lbs 10 oz. I have a BAR in .30-'06. Its light, reliable and has more than adequate accuracy. If on a budget look for a lightly used Remington 742 or 7400 in .308. I have a 742 and it is perfect for combination brush and open country hunting out to 350 yards or so. Mine shoots good hunting handloads at about 1.5 MOA. For a left hand bolt action, it would be the Savage 110. This is a very accurate rifle that has been in production for many years with a great reputation for sub MOA right out of the box at a budget-friendly price. I would not be looking at a military-style semiauto. I would NOT want a scout rifle. Those of us who have one, and I do, know that a long eye relief magnified optic has a very narrow field of view compared to a traditional 3 to 4 inch eye relief scope. Unless you are familiar with the limitations of scout scopes or just want to use a 1x red dot, you may be disappointed. My only remaining scout rifle is that way of necessity. It has a fixed Williams receiver target sight and Lyman Globe target front sight. Since the receiver sight can't be removed I have a QD return to zero mounted scout scope ahead of the action. Its suboptimal, but the only was to scope that rifle. The optic I would chose on either rifle would a low powered variable scope in the 1-6x range with a simple illuminated retucle. |
|
Have you thought of this one? Less expensive than some of the options here, MSRP of $749, and weighs 7 pounds. I like mine.
https://cz-usa.com/product/cz-600-alpha/ Attached File I shot the M14 with the US Navy back in the late 80s. HEAVY rifle, but accurate as the day was long. I have no experience with AR10s of any kind. |
|
Quoted: Have you thought of this one? Less expensive than some of the options here, MSRP of $749, and weighs 7 pounds. I like mine. https://cz-usa.com/product/cz-600-alpha/ https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/360589/2_3_23_7_jpg-2800297.JPG I shot the M14 with the US Navy back in the late 80s. HEAVY rifle, but accurate as the day was long. I have no experience with AR10s of any kind. View Quote Looks like a nice rifle. But, a general purpose, do all rifle, should have iron sights IMO. A scope, in addition to iron sights is great. But it should have open sights. |
|
I picked up a Ruger scout and it would only light about 1/3 of my rounds. Apparently this is a common problem and there’s an extra power firing pin spring available.
|
|
Those are all great suggestions/comments. The M1A love is great to see.
Any thoughts on 16" vs 18 inch Barrels on the Scout's? The Tikka Scout configuration seems excellent but expensive! |
|
Quoted: I mean, "a handy, multi purpose rifle for general use" is pretty much exactly what the scout rifle concept was intended to be. I believe the Steyr is the only one that Cooper personally was involved with. The Ruger obviously bears the "Gunsite" name, so it would seem to have some connection to Cooper's ideas, but the question would be how much... I guess what I'm saying is, if you're into a scout, check out the options and see what you like. View Quote Savage made a scout model a few years back. Springfield Armory also marketed an M1A "scout" with a forward scope mounting area. Is the OP really in the market for a scout configuration, or just a bolt action with iron sights and scope mounting options? |
|
Recently bought a ruger SFAR. Only have 40 rounds through it, but I am impressed. The weight alone is crazy. And just leaning/bracing against a tree for support, I was putting 5 rounds into under 4" at 100 yards. Want to put more rounds through it, but I can recommend this as a do it all .308 rifle.
|
|
|
|
Quoted: I don't have an SFAR (yet), but I do have a 12.5" and 16" 308 Rogue, which are what the SFAR seems to have been based on. They are what I would use if I wanted a carry around 308 in most cases. The gun itself is as light as the Ruger scout. I would want an optic and light on any gun I dedicated for "general use." The SCAR is a fun option, but it wouldn't be my top choice. A 12-13" 308 would be plenty for any hunting within a few hundred yards. But if you're a lefty with issues getting gas in the face, the bolt gun is a better option. https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/435611/20220716_002025_jpg-2454552_jpg-2793106.JPG https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/435611/20230312_222900_jpg-2743374_jpg-2793107.JPG View Quote I know you kind of discounted 308 AR’s, but Daggertt speaks truth. A POF Rogue or Ruger SFAR is game changing once you get to hold one. With an optic and loaded mag you’re still around the weight of a naked M14 platform. |
|
Well I've had both, and now only have the Ruger. It's the "huntin' rifle" in our house (though only my son hunts with it. The M1A was great, and I had it for 15+ years. But once I got my AR-10 I just never really gravitated back to the M1A. It's a "man's weapon" with a classic nod to history... but I rarely have the luxury on buying new things if I haven't sold old things yet.
|
|
OP,
I've owned the following guns for the purpose you described ... Mossberg MVP Scout with Aimpoint CompM4 Savage 110 Scout with Leupold Scout Scope Ruger 16" Scout with Leupold Scout Scope Ruger 18" Stainless Scout with Leupold Scout Scope Springfield Armory M1A Bush Springfield Armory M1A Scout with Leupold Scout Scope Springfield Armory M1A SOCOM with Aimpoint CompM4 I concluded that the "scout concept" is cool and Jeff Cooper had a neat idea ... but ... it is outdated and doesn't really work well in real life. Therefore, I tried the following ... DSA 16" Para FAL with Aimpoint CompM4 Sig Sauer 716i Tread AR10 with LPVO Springfield Armory SAR-48 18" FAL with Aimpoint CompM4 What did I find works the best? LMT MARS-H 16" AR10 with Trijicon TA11 ACOG + RMR Piggyback The LMT is light enough, fast, EXTREMELY ACCURATE, 100% reliable and the optic is plenty for non-precision use. |
|
General comment on Springfield M1As....
I bought my first M1A in 1991, and have owned A TON of them since. Standard, Match, Super Match, Loaded, Bush, Scout, and SOCOMs. Several of each. The ONLY reason I would own a M1A is for hobby use and nostalgia and then only if someone gave it to me for free. They simply are not the best 308 option. They're not even a good 308 option. When SA ran out of USGI parts they went from "marginal" to "unacceptable". I've had to have SA, Inc. replace receivers, bolts and barrels. SA,Inc use to have great customer service ... they needed it. I do not own one now nor will I ever own another. My father used a M14 in the Corps so I have an affinity for the general design, but they really kind of suck. It doesn't really matter if someone likes the design or not, but the SR25 pattern and HK417 pattern rifles are the standard for semi-auto 7.62mm. ETA: I also can not fathom why anyone would consider a bolt action anything unless it was required by some draconian law. They're like pump shotguns ... if an equally reliable semi-auto exits why would you hamper yourself with a manually operated arm? It would be like carrying a single-action revolver. Fun for range plinking once a year, but otherwise ... |
|
Quoted: I don't have an SFAR (yet), but I do have a 12.5" and 16" 308 Rogue, which are what the SFAR seems to have been based on. They are what I would use if I wanted a carry around 308 in most cases. The gun itself is as light as the Ruger scout. I would want an optic and light on any gun I dedicated for "general use." The SCAR is a fun option, but it wouldn't be my top choice. A 12-13" 308 would be plenty for any hunting within a few hundred yards. But if you're a lefty with issues getting gas in the face, the bolt gun is a better option. https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/435611/20220716_002025_jpg-2454552_jpg-2793106.JPG https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/435611/20230312_222900_jpg-2743374_jpg-2793107.JPG View Quote I owned "several" SCAR-H when I was trying to move out of FALs into a modern semi-auto 7.62MM. After replacing lowers with aluminum, etc I finally just accepted that I needed to go to AR10s. A couple of Colt 901s later I found LMT MWS and that was that. Now I'm onto LMT MARS-H but wouldn't turn down any MWS. ETA: I also liked my HK MR762 with Vortex Razor but it was almost a crew-served weapon based upon the weight (after adding a G 417 extended rail, etc). MY FINAL ANALYSIS: LMT MARS-H with MLOK chassis and your optic of choice is about as good as it gets. With a stainless 16" barrel, match ammo, and quality (Vortex Razor, NF, Leupold Mk6) magnified optic it is an 800 yard gun that with an offset RMR or T2 can also clear houses. |
|
Quoted: ETA: I also can not fathom why anyone would consider a bolt action anything unless it was required by some draconian law. They're like pump shotguns ... if an equally reliable semi-auto exits why would you hamper yourself with a manually operated arm? It would be like carrying a single-action revolver. Fun for range plinking once a year, but otherwise ... View Quote Back when Cooper was developing the idea, bolt actions made some sense: lighter, more accurate, easy to carry, easy to top off from strippers. It was an idea that held some attraction when the M1A, FAL or HK91 were your options. Now that light, accurate, reliable 308s are common, the idea has aged into irrelevance. |
|
Quoted: Back when Cooper was developing the idea, bolt actions made some sense: lighter, more accurate, easy to carry, easy to top off from strippers. It was an idea that held some attraction when the M1A, FAL or HK91 were your options. Now that light, accurate, reliable 308s are common, the idea has aged into irrelevance. View Quote LOL, not when you can pick up a 308 bolt action for under $500 and the lightweight AR10 platforms are all over $1000, with some over $2k. |
|
Quoted: OP, I've owned the following guns for the purpose you described ... Mossberg MVP Scout with Aimpoint CompM4 Savage 110 Scout with Leupold Scout Scope Ruger 16" Scout with Leupold Scout Scope Ruger 18" Stainless Scout with Leupold Scout Scope Springfield Armory M1A Bush Springfield Armory M1A Scout with Leupold Scout Scope Springfield Armory M1A SOCOM with Aimpoint CompM4 I concluded that the "scout concept" is cool and Jeff Cooper had a neat idea ... but ... it is outdated and doesn't really work well in real life. Therefore, I tried the following ... DSA 16" Para FAL with Aimpoint CompM4 Sig Sauer 716i Tread AR10 with LPVO Springfield Armory SAR-48 18" FAL with Aimpoint CompM4 What did I find works the best? LMT MARS-H 16" AR10 with Trijicon TA11 ACOG + RMR Piggyback The LMT is light enough, fast, EXTREMELY ACCURATE, 100% reliable and the optic is plenty for non-precision use. View Quote Curious how light you were able to get your LMT? |
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.