Quoted: I wouldn't want to stand in front of a .22 short either, but that can kill you too. It doesn't matter if the guy dies a week later in the hospital if he has enough pepper left after you shoot him to stick you with his knife or return fire.
|
Nothing is 100%, but at inside-the-room range, I'll take a 12-gauge shotgun, thank you. If the perp is wearing a vest, the impact will likely knock him down hard, and your typical vest will not stop the 5.56 from my Bushy!
I don't think equating a 12ga 00-buck round to 8 or 9 rounds of 9mm is a fair comparison. It's more like 8 or 9 .22LR's. Each pellet is ~54gr at .33" at ~1300fps. In terms of bullet weight and velocity, each pellet is more like a .22LR than a 9mm. Probably with less penetration than the .22 since we're talking about lead round balls with far less sectional density. And penetration is the thing the .22LR has going for it.
Let's not forget that the round ball or RN is not the best projectile shape for terminal performance. It will tend to part tissue without disrupting it, especially on elastic tissue.
|
Tell all that terminal ballistics stuff to the dead perp on my living room floor...heh heh! :)
I agree that slugs are far better stoppers (in general) than shot.
|
So, are you saying I'd be better off just loading up with slugs? If so, then I'll do that. In situations like that, I firmly believe in having every unfair advantage.
If 8 rounds is enough, then how many rounds do you load in your AR mags?
|
Apples and oranges, my friend...but the Bushy and the GI 30-rounders are close at hand.
Let's consider this possible scenario: multiple armed assailants have broken into your house, discovered your position, and begun to shoot at you. Are you certain that you will hit 100% of the shots fired? Are you certain that each shot will instantly incapacitate your assailant? Even if you are Wyatt Earp, it may take you a few rounds to realize that they have body armor and you'll have to make head shots. Think it can't happen? Think again.
The reality is that under this kind of stress in this kind of dynamic shooting scenario, we are all capable of missing shots. Street results, as controversial as they may be, suggest that a significant amount of people hit in the torso with a 12ga 00-round will not stop fighting instantly. My own personal results on feral hogs have been less than impressive.
Are you sure that 8-rounds is "enough" when you and your family are on the line? There are some situations where being in over your head is no excuse.
|
That's okay...the shotgun is far from the only weapon I have at hand for home defense, and I live in a second-story condo. So, unless Spiderman is one of the assailants, the only way they are getting in is through the front door, and that won't be easy without making a LOT of noise! They would be in the funnel of death, and I have a clear shot from the bedroom to the front door, plus cover options in the adjacent kitchen as well. My wife would call 911 and have the cops and paramedics come pick up the leaking human trash from the breezeway.
'nuff said! :)
Cheers,
Steve