I went with titanium and am happy with it. I will warn you of a few things that I learned the hard way...
First, the bit that comes with the kit is junk. I went to Fastenal and bought one of their bits for $6ish that was far superior. The supplied bit didn't drill as well and broke on the second baffle.
Second, only tighten the horizontal screw on the jig enough that your baffle doesn't spin for the majority of your drilling. Once you feel the baffle start to spin as the bit starts to break through, stop and crank it down for the rest of the drilling. If you tighten it too much at first you'll get off center holes, ask me how I know...
Third, drilling titanium is best done at slow speed with a lot of downward force. I figured it out by about the 4th or 5th baffle. Use tap magic, press hard, go slow.
Finally, if you need to touch up your holes, this file kit from Home Depot works well. https://www.homedepot.com/p/Husky-Steel-Precision-File-Set-with-Storage-Case-6-Piece-707476H/207112197
Edit: I'd buy this wrench now to help remove the can from your hosts. https://www.homedepot.com/p/Channellock-Extra-Slim-Jaw-6-in-Chrome-Adjustable-Wrench-806SW/301938569