Quoted:
I dont know the exact details of current product offerings that are comparable, but I imagine that with the advent of Holosun, Vortex, and others that there has been at least some innovation in the magnifier space. That being said, is the Eotech G-33 magnifier the best bang for the high price tag that it carries?
View Quote
For the money you can probably find a substitute item in today's market. No matter what type of setup you have, there are alternatives to it. Plus this isn't like the military.
The only way I can recommend buying specific brands is if you're going to use it in military applications and perhaps in situations where you're going to use it for hunting or self-defense. The reason being is that the other brands aren't combat proven optics and you never know where or how it might fail until you use it in real world situations. I would want something that has been proven with years of data compared to something I saved a few dollars over.
I recently had an Armson site that I bought and was planning to use it on a hunting rifle. I decided to take it to the range and zero it. Very nice and had no problem. Then I took it out on the field and a simple leaf that covered my left eye ruined everything whereas if I had my reddot on it from before, it would have worked just fine with or without the leaf obstruction. So that's a harsh lesson. As I said, at the range it's fine and just like anything else you never know what sort of failures you experience until you find them, and you just better hope it's not something you wish you learned earlier.
Back when EOTech and G-33 first came out, the market wasn't as saturated or as capable as it is today. So if you didn't buy brands 10 years ago, don't expect to have a functional item. Whereas today, you can pretty much get away without worry of brand specifics.
With that in mind, if you can afford the EOTech w/ G-33 magnifier, then pick it up. It's quite nice and you're going to enjoy it. However, there is nothing wrong with getting anything else so long as you aren't buying it to say it is the "best."