Subscribed for more people’s input...
Right now I’m currently deciding which 6.5CM barrel I want:
JP Supermatch
Criterion Blank
Bartlein Blank
JP generally gets great reviews, but the oddball report about a JP lemon seems to surface a tad more frequently than bad reports of Criterions... and the Bartleins appear to have nothing but awesome reviews, then again they’re $$$ cut rifled, too. Plus getting a blank turned means I can customize my specs whereas the JP is a less configurable off the shelf product.
The JP is a good price, considering it comes headspaced WITH the bolt ($200 value). Having a Criterion blank turned is actually about $30 cheaper than the JP once you factor in the cost of a bolt. The Bartlein barrel plus bolt is a good $130 more than he JP and criterion and $160 more than the Criterion. Right now I’m leaning Criterion, and I’m trying to decide if the bartlein is worth the extra $150ish.
I waffling especially since WHATEVER I get I’m going to have Black Nitride coated @ H&M for a long-ass barrel life. I think it kind of hurts to drop Bartlein/Kreiger kind of money and then send it off to a Nitride shop first thing.
I wish the factory criterion hybrids (factory nitrided) would just come with a damn +2” XL gas length and I’d have bought that already. Then I wouldn’t be stuck having a blank custom turned or buying a preconfigured JP