I've seen this a few times when teaching Armorer Courses. Could be either a bolt catch that is a little on the fat side, or the slot (pocket) that is machined out for the bolt catch is too small. Any chance you have a set of calipers handy, and could measure the thickness of the bolt catch, and measure the width of the slot (pocket) where the bolt catch sits in the receiver?
Any chance you could post a pic?
If it's an oversized bolt catch, a simple replacement is easy. If the receiver's bolt catch slot is too tight, then you could file it out, but that would void
any warranty, plus you would remove the anodizing of which is not a good thing either.
If it's a problem with the receiver, then put it back into PSA's hands and let their customer service take care of it. If it's a bad bolt catch, then put it back into Spikes hands, and let their customer service take care of it.
CY6
Greg Sullivan "Sully"
SLR15 Rifles TheDefensiveEdge.com(763) 712-0123