Quoted:
I've been to Charley's several years ago and my wife and I go to Shula's at least two times a year. Personally I prefer Shula's. Part of my preference is the only Charley's I've been to is the one on South OBT which is not in the best of neighborhoods. Shula's is a little nicer location.
The Palm Restaurant at the Hard Rock Hotel is a good place too. Another one in the area I've heard good things about, but never been to is Del Frisco's. One of these days I'm going to try it but places like Charley's, Del Frisco's, The Palm, and Shula's are expensive and not someplace I can afford to go frequently.
I hear ya- we want to Shula's because we wanted one nice dinner last time we were in Orlando, but also because we wanted to take on the 48oz challenge or whatever it is. Sure enough we got our "prize" and never have to go back, but it was a damn good steak. Just didn't know how much better Charlie's might be; from some of the pics the restaurant interior did not look as nice, as Shula's definitely had a very nice atmosphere.