Please read the full report.
Well - I was one of many here who bought a lot of D&H mags and noticed when hand cycling ammo - or stripping the first round out of the mag from the right side - they would hang up on the feedramp. I bought 80 of them from a popular AR15.com source. Needless to say - I was quite concerned by what others were reporting, and what I saw in my own weapons when tested in my house. I took them to my dealer - demonstrated the issue - and we agreed I would shoot them FIRST - test them under live fire, before making a judgement call on whether to return them or not.
I got the chance to do that today. My mags are the black D&H teflons, with magpul followers, and dated 1/06. I grabbed a random sampling of 10 mags that had not been previously messed with. I took three different AR's - a bushy 20" with a VLTOR cabine stock and H buffer, a Bushy M4 with VLTOR carbine stock and H buffer, and a stock Bushy A2 20" govt profile with a rifle stock and buffer.
I wanted to do this right - so I brought my pen and notepad, setting out to record every type of malfunction I experienced in detail. Mags were loaded to full capacity (30 rounds) with Q3131A and Guatemalan M193. I had 10 "questionable" mags and 300 rounds to go, in 3 different weapons. I set up a steel plate to ding at 100yds, and sat back with my notepad and pen to my right.
I never picked the pen up once.
That's right. ZERO failures of ANY kind. The mags stripped the first round perfectly from the bolt catch, and subsequently fired, ejected and fed every single round. Every empty mag locked the carrier to the rear. These mags functioned 100%. I was elated.
I was very surprised that my weapon had no problem stripping the first round from the bolt carrier, when I had this problem when testing at home. I can only surmise that when testing at home, I had the weapon pointed straight up - where the weight of the carrier was also working against it - on the range I had the weapon level and pointed downrange just like I always would. They worked flawlessly.
I then inspected the chamber, barrel extension, lug area, and bolt face. I saw no appreciable brass or copper flaking, as some have seen when hand cycling. I can only assume they dont get scratched as bad when stripped with the velocity of a firing weapon.
I then inspected the pile of 300 rounds of fired brass. I could not see any seriously deep gouges on the brass that concerned me. There was a single noticeable scratch from the feedlip on about half the brass. I assume this would be the first 10-15 rounds stripped when the spring was at the most pressure.... and I can only assume as more rounds fired, the lips also smoothed out. A burr on aluminum wont take long at all to smooth itself out.
Even if I would have had one or two "fail to strip" from the bolt catch, I could have accepted that, assuming it would smooth out under a little use. I was hoping to have a couple of these, and continue reloading and firing them, to see if they smoothed out after "x" rounds, but I could not get these mags to fail at all under live fire.
In conclusion - all I can say - is if you have these mags and have concerns: PLEASE take them out and SHOOT them in known good weapons. What was demonstated by hand cycling did not happen under real use.