Hardwood! When I built my house, about 45 years ago, I didn't know much about building or materials. Plus, I didn't have much money, so I had to use what I could find. I put 12" (!) thick cut stone in the foyer that I got free from a friend who had it left over after building a bombshelter. I used 1/2" thick 1' square marble tiles, that I got cheap from a college that was gutting a building to remodel, in my (one) bathroom and around the edge of my living room. In the rest of the house, I used oak hardwood planks about 3" wide and 1/2" thick that a friend of mine made in his shop. The edges of the stone are chipped and cracked. They are dangerous to walk-on for anyone in high-heels because of the voids. I've filled them with sand, but that isn't a good solution. The marble is basically falling apart in the high traffic areas. I've had to use concrete to fill-in. It doesn't look good, but it works. The hardwood, if it was refinished and a few boards replaced, would probably look as good as new. My advise, go for the hardwood if you think you're going to stay in the house for 25+ years. The marble looks "substantial," and would probably help with resale, but it is just too brittle to survive for long. I think my problems with the stone were due to the fact that I had no idea what I was doing.z