Posted: 3/16/2017 5:09:17 PM EDT
[#5]
It seems that your statement is a slight contradiction in that you need to be able to hit what your aiming at and where you would like to hit someone, as you state . So a reinforcement of fundamental shooting skills and exact bullet placement would be an asset to defensive shooting as well. To be able to"cause trauma to vital body systems" you need to be able to hit those vital body systems. I think if you train to effectively be able to place all your shots into a small area, such as center mass, or in this case dots on a target, and can do so consistently then that is a plus no matter the situation. Obviously a defensive scenario will not always allow perfect stance, perfect grip perfect sight alignment perfect breathing etc, but through muscle memory of repetitive practice, in a stressful situation many of these things will be ingrained. Basketball players shoot thousands of free throws in practice, knowing that very seldom will they have the chance to win the national championship or an NBA title by sinking a free throw at the end of regulation. You cant really mimic that stress in practice, but you practice it anyway because then under stress you should perform better. Im not saying that YSINTG should be mandatory for a CPL but I personally think some CPL classes are absolutely a joke and really dont teach anything about carrying a handgun everyday for protection. I have had a CPL for over a decade, and have attended three of these classes, once for my certification, and twice for other family members as a watcher/bystander. One particular class was all .22 semi autos Ruger MK II's. Not a very popular choice for a carry handgun. There were no holsters present, no drawing from concealment no discussions, demonstrations or activities regarding malfunctions of any kind, so in my mind calling these a CPL class was a misnomer at best. There was discussion of legal ramifications after a shooting, and there was significant discussion on safety which is excellent, but in my opinion no one came away with any more knowledge of carrying a weapon then they had before going into it. I do agree that a portion of the class on human anatomy and what vitals and where would be good, but honestly if you put multiple shots into center mass of a subject, as long as we are discounting armor, you are most definitely going to be changing the fight in your favor, whether you hit vitals or not.
Quote History Quoted:
While I do not doubt MDFI has good classes, the core idea of defensive shooting is to efficiently stop a threat.
And while bullseye quality shooting is nice for a range or easier to work on in a training class, defensively it is a liability, as " is the most efficient way to stop a threat.
Not every body is the same, and while organs are in about the same area, you still want the highest probability of striking one or more vital system of a target to stop it faster, thus small group shooting is inefficient in a defensive situation.
Also I'd bet their class doesn't work on your memorization of human anatomy for use in picking targets under stress, and making a nice little hole in the middle of the "A" zone is far from effective shot placement (if your first shot misses vitals, and all your others follow it...)
So I'll have to disagree on it being a good CPL class, though it's probably a wonderful fundamentals course. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quote History Quoted:
Quoted:
YSINTG should be mandatory to get a CPL. You actually learn putting bullets into bullet holes vs PPITH putting holes in paper. While I do not doubt MDFI has good classes, the core idea of defensive shooting is to efficiently stop a threat.
And while bullseye quality shooting is nice for a range or easier to work on in a training class, defensively it is a liability, as " is the most efficient way to stop a threat.
Not every body is the same, and while organs are in about the same area, you still want the highest probability of striking one or more vital system of a target to stop it faster, thus small group shooting is inefficient in a defensive situation.
Also I'd bet their class doesn't work on your memorization of human anatomy for use in picking targets under stress, and making a nice little hole in the middle of the "A" zone is far from effective shot placement (if your first shot misses vitals, and all your others follow it...)
So I'll have to disagree on it being a good CPL class, though it's probably a wonderful fundamentals course.
|
|