User Panel
Posted: 3/2/2015 4:21:38 PM EDT
Just got a Sig AR pistol with that sig brace but now I want to SBR it so I can shoulder it at the range, so what's the easiest route in MN... A trust? anyone use any of the online trusts and had good results if so which one? or is there a place in the west metro that can walk me through the process ?
Thanks for any responses |
|
I'm about to go trust route. Atomic Tactical in Bloomington does a lot of NFA business.
|
|
I used 199trust.com
Good results and got the trust docs pretty fast. waiting on my first stamp now. If you do SBR it put a real stock on it |
|
Correct me if I am wrong. Without a trust, you need the local chief of police or sheriff to sign off on the form, everything else is the same (engraving, finger prints, etc), right? Debating if I want to do one or leave the sig brace on.
|
|
I went the trust route. E-file took 31 days for all 3 of my stamps. Makes more sense than going to CLEO route once you get into it.
|
|
|
Quoted: I went the trust route. E-file took 31 days for all 3 of my stamps. Makes more sense than going to CLEO route once you get into it. View Quote With NFA trust you don't need CLEO sign off, and no finger prints. It also speeds things up for future purchases. With NFA trust right now the wait times on E-File are 30-45 days for SBR and 3-5 months for suppressors. |
|
Wait, no finger prints? What about the engraving part?
Here is what I have. KAK industries 10.5 inch barrel complete upper (308). Areo lower. KAK super tube with sig brace. Had lower sent to element arms. Since they do the paperwork on a computer, not sure how they classified my lower. So, do the trust, have engraving done according to requirements. take photos to attach to efile? Probably making more difficult than it is but don't want to screw this up if I do this. If I get it done right and get my tax stamp, I then can change out the stock to what ever? Appreciate all the help guys. |
|
*shrug* I just went to my county sheriff. It took longer to get printed than it did to get his signature. $20 for the photos, $15 for the prints, and maybe an hour total out of my day to get it all done. Why bother with a trust? Especially since the ATF has made it clear that they will be requiring photos and fingerprints for all members of a trust in the future, anyway?
The only advantage a trust will get you in the future is the ability to e-file, and the timegap between that and a paper filing is closing fast anyway... Of course if you live in a county where your sheriff won't sign, that's one thing...but if he will, why bother going another route. But, YMMV... |
|
Quoted:
Why bother with a trust? View Quote The other advantage of an NFA trust is security of possession, and versatility of possession. If, for whatever reason, in the future you get sued, and somebody tries to 'take you for all you've got,' those Trust possessions are NOT legally "Yours" to take - they are owned by the trust. Protecting them from seizure in lawsuits. As far as versatility of possession, I'm now a ND resident, and I can (and do) have a Minnesota Resident listed on my NFA Trust as a co-trustee. My NFA trust is setup so that any 'Contributors' or 'Purchasers' of items transferred into the trust are able to contribute whatever they want - and compensation is also disbursed in the same manner. SO, a Minnesota resident that desperately wants NFA goodies they cannot possess in Minnesota, are listed as Co-trustee on my NFA Trust, and can purchase any legal NFA items they so choose, but the non-MN friendly ones have to be kept in ND. As such, I can purchase a couple SBR's, a few Suppressors, and then I can go in 60/40 on a MAC11-9mm. The MN resident can then pay 100% of a full auto rated 9mm suppressor for the MAC11. They all go into the same trust, and it is recorded who paid whatever percentage of the NFA item. I can use the NFA goodies on my private 300yd range, or I can put a can on a Savage 10 FCP-K, and myself and the MN Resident can head to western ND, or file transporation paperwork ahead of time, and take a trip to SD for some long range prairie dog shooting with suppressors... Or possibly a trip down to TX for some hog hunting from a helo.... Whatever. This way I do not need to be present if the MN resident wants to go on a P-dogging trip to western ND - he's just got a copy of the NFA trust, and a copy of the stamp paperwork for that suppressor and/or MAC11, or whatever with him. IF, in the future that MAC11 and the 9mm suppressor get sold to an NFA Dealer, the funds will get split up 60/40 for the MAC11, and 100% for the suppressor based upon who contributed what to the NFA Trust. Similarly, I can Form 1 an SBR, and designate ND as the Trust location, and I can designate a MN address for the storage location of the SBR. Then the MN Resident storing the SBR needs to have us file transport paperwork if he's going to cross state border into ND, but that's not likely an issue since I don't plan on ever really transporting any NFA items out of the state in which it is listed for storage. That said, I DO have a MN resident listed on my NFA trust. He CAN purchase suppressors, and non-C&R pre-86 NFA toys, but they have to be stored in ND. He CAN Form1 an SBR, and that CAN be stored in MN. Edited to add: It DID take me a number of months of talking back & forth with ATF, and an attourney to get a multi-state capable NFA trust document set created and verified as "Acceptable" by ATF standards, but it's finished finally, and my first can will be arriving in the not-too distant future. Later this summer there will be a couple SBR's done around July too. Then later in the fall there will likely be another can going on the trust (likely a 45 Ti-Rant, or 45 Osprey and three pistons to adapt it to a few different 45acp and 9mm pistols. I just think the versatility of an NFA trust is worth the time and money to do the paperwork... |
|
Oh, I understand the versatility of it...but a lot of that versatility goes away as soon as the ATF modifies their rules to require all trustees in a trust to be printed and photographed. Suddenly submitting a Form 4 or 1 becomes a logistical exercise between every member of the trust to get photographed and fingerprinted, on ATF card stock (the ATF will only accept fingerprints done on cards they provide to you; they will not take a local PD's cards). Instead of doing a background check on one person, they'll have to do it on every person in the trust (they already do this, but they will throw in photographs and the prints into the mix, which they currently can't). And if one person in the trust winds up with a DV conviction, felony DWI, busted with a pound of pot, old arrest record, etc...hey, guess what happens to the trust? At the very least it'll need to be amended to remove a trustee and I'm not clear on the legal ramifications of that. That would require a lawyer, and more money.
Yes, the trust has advantages. It's also got disadvantages. Just like going the corporate route and forming an LLC has advantages and disadvantages. Anyone getting into NFA today needs to go in with both eyes wide open. The advantage of a simple Form 1 on an individual is that it's very simple, no bullshit; sheriff's signature, prints, photograph, check. No lawyers, no checking Schedule A and Schedule B, no wondering if it's worded right, no ordering any "completion kits" from the internet, and no hoping and praying that some guy online has a trust form that's legally valid in your state. The biggest two disadvantages are simply the time it takes for approval (which is being shortened) and that it's tied to an individual...so you can't just leave your NFA item with someone else who is in the trust. They can come out and use it at any time, but it's not theirs and must always remain in your possession/control. Right now a trust does not require prints or photographs but rest assured...it is coming. This also means existing trusts will probably need to be updated with prints and photographs as well...though to be honest I'm not sure how the ATF is going to handle existing stamps. |
|
Those are all very good points about the down side to NFA trusts & corporate filings.
Thankfully, the guy I listed on my trust has a pretty high security clearance, doesn't drink at all, and I trust him with my life. The trust also lists the very specific procedure involved with removal of co-trustees in the event of that person losing their right to own firearms, etc., but that could always get messy, but I don't think I'll likely have to deal with that in the future. |
|
Since mine is pretty much built, minus the stock I will change out, just fill out the form, get sheriff to sign (live out in country), get finger prints and photo, and mail in?
|
|
Quoted:
Since mine is pretty much built, minus the stock I will change out, just fill out the form, get sheriff to sign (live out in country), get finger prints and photo, and mail in? View Quote Pretty much; if you check the NFA subforum in the Armory section here there's a tacked thread on filling out your form 1. The form itself can be a bit confusing but once you've got it filled out, it's just a matter of making sure the sheriff will sign off on it. You'll need two copies of the form 1 (photocopied front AND back; they will not accept it on two pages..must be printed in duplex), two passport photos, two finger print cards (you need to order these from the ATF; you can do it on their web site and they're free and they take a week or so to get to you), you'll need to fill out the proof of citizenship form (also available for free on the ATF website, same place you can download the form 1 from...you only need one of these)...get the photos, have the sheriff sign it, get fingertprinted at the sheriff's office, write a check for $200, and off to the ATF the whole packet goes. Edit - some people like to wait until they get the stamp back to get it engraved, others like to get it engraved before the packet goes out to the ATF. Me, I send the receiver out to get engraved usually on the same day I put the packet in the mail to the ATF. Once the stamp is issued the receiver becomes an NFA item, regardless of whether it's been engraved or not, and I'd rather get it engraved before it becomes a title 2 firearm. You can engrave it at any time, but it's better if it's done before the ATF issues the stamp, in my opinion. The receiver should be back well before the ATF stamp if you send both out at the same time. It sounds more difficult than it really is but for the most part, once you do your first one, it's a snap to do it again once you're familiar with the steps. |
|
Bearcat, just remember - EVIL ED lives up to his EVIL name!
You keep listening to his advice, you're going to wind up just like me - spending LOTS OF MONEY on pretty cool stuff! They don't call him EVIL for nothing. There were a couple things I just had to have after seeing his toys. |
|
So they don't need a pic of the engraving, correct? Can I engrave my own since I have an engraver? They won't take finger print cards the sheriff uses? Will order those and get them in sand start the process. Anyone know if the stearns county sheriff is cool on signing these?
|
|
Quoted:
Bearcat, just remember - EVIL ED lives up to his EVIL name! You keep listening to his advice, you're going to wind up just like me - spending LOTS OF MONEY on pretty cool stuff! They don't call him EVIL for nothing. There were a couple things I just had to have after seeing his toys. View Quote Already spent a ton on evil black weapons. This should be my last (I hope) but never say never. Reloading has me busy enough. With warmer weather coming, time to break out the 50BMG. |
|
Quoted: Those are all very good points about the down side to NFA trusts & corporate filings. Thankfully, the guy I listed on my trust has a pretty high security clearance, doesn't drink at all, and I trust him with my life. The trust also lists the very specific procedure involved with removal of co-trustees in the event of that person losing their right to own firearms, etc., but that could always get messy, but I don't think I'll likely have to deal with that in the future. View Quote What does the "pretty high security clearance" have to do with it? |
|
Quoted: The other advantage of an NFA trust is security of possession, and versatility of possession. If, for whatever reason, in the future you get sued, and somebody tries to 'take you for all you've got,' those Trust possessions are NOT legally "Yours" to take - they are owned by the trust. Protecting them from seizure in lawsuits. As far as versatility of possession, I'm now a ND resident, and I can (and do) have a Minnesota Resident listed on my NFA Trust as a co-trustee. My NFA trust is setup so that any 'Contributors' or 'Purchasers' of items transferred into the trust are able to contribute whatever they want - and compensation is also disbursed in the same manner. SO, a Minnesota resident that desperately wants NFA goodies they cannot possess in Minnesota, are listed as Co-trustee on my NFA Trust, and can purchase any legal NFA items they so choose, but the non-MN friendly ones have to be kept in ND. As such, I can purchase a couple SBR's, a few Suppressors, and then I can go in 60/40 on a MAC11-9mm. The MN resident can then pay 100% of a full auto rated 9mm suppressor for the MAC11. They all go into the same trust, and it is recorded who paid whatever percentage of the NFA item. I can use the NFA goodies on my private 300yd range, or I can put a can on a Savage 10 FCP-K, and myself and the MN Resident can head to western ND, or file transporation paperwork ahead of time, and take a trip to SD for some long range prairie dog shooting with suppressors... Or possibly a trip down to TX for some hog hunting from a helo.... Whatever. This way I do not need to be present if the MN resident wants to go on a P-dogging trip to western ND - he's just got a copy of the NFA trust, and a copy of the stamp paperwork for that suppressor and/or MAC11, or whatever with him. IF, in the future that MAC11 and the 9mm suppressor get sold to an NFA Dealer, the funds will get split up 60/40 for the MAC11, and 100% for the suppressor based upon who contributed what to the NFA Trust. Similarly, I can Form 1 an SBR, and designate ND as the Trust location, and I can designate a MN address for the storage location of the SBR. Then the MN Resident storing the SBR needs to have us file transport paperwork if he's going to cross state border into ND, but that's not likely an issue since I don't plan on ever really transporting any NFA items out of the state in which it is listed for storage. That said, I DO have a MN resident listed on my NFA trust. He CAN purchase suppressors, and non-C&R pre-86 NFA toys, but they have to be stored in ND. He CAN Form1 an SBR, and that CAN be stored in MN. Edited to add: It DID take me a number of months of talking back & forth with ATF, and an attourney to get a multi-state capable NFA trust document set created and verified as "Acceptable" by ATF standards, but it's finished finally, and my first can will be arriving in the not-too distant future. Later this summer there will be a couple SBR's done around July too. Then later in the fall there will likely be another can going on the trust (likely a 45 Ti-Rant, or 45 Osprey and three pistons to adapt it to a few different 45acp and 9mm pistols. I just think the versatility of an NFA trust is worth the time and money to do the paperwork... View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Why bother with a trust? The other advantage of an NFA trust is security of possession, and versatility of possession. If, for whatever reason, in the future you get sued, and somebody tries to 'take you for all you've got,' those Trust possessions are NOT legally "Yours" to take - they are owned by the trust. Protecting them from seizure in lawsuits. As far as versatility of possession, I'm now a ND resident, and I can (and do) have a Minnesota Resident listed on my NFA Trust as a co-trustee. My NFA trust is setup so that any 'Contributors' or 'Purchasers' of items transferred into the trust are able to contribute whatever they want - and compensation is also disbursed in the same manner. SO, a Minnesota resident that desperately wants NFA goodies they cannot possess in Minnesota, are listed as Co-trustee on my NFA Trust, and can purchase any legal NFA items they so choose, but the non-MN friendly ones have to be kept in ND. As such, I can purchase a couple SBR's, a few Suppressors, and then I can go in 60/40 on a MAC11-9mm. The MN resident can then pay 100% of a full auto rated 9mm suppressor for the MAC11. They all go into the same trust, and it is recorded who paid whatever percentage of the NFA item. I can use the NFA goodies on my private 300yd range, or I can put a can on a Savage 10 FCP-K, and myself and the MN Resident can head to western ND, or file transporation paperwork ahead of time, and take a trip to SD for some long range prairie dog shooting with suppressors... Or possibly a trip down to TX for some hog hunting from a helo.... Whatever. This way I do not need to be present if the MN resident wants to go on a P-dogging trip to western ND - he's just got a copy of the NFA trust, and a copy of the stamp paperwork for that suppressor and/or MAC11, or whatever with him. IF, in the future that MAC11 and the 9mm suppressor get sold to an NFA Dealer, the funds will get split up 60/40 for the MAC11, and 100% for the suppressor based upon who contributed what to the NFA Trust. Similarly, I can Form 1 an SBR, and designate ND as the Trust location, and I can designate a MN address for the storage location of the SBR. Then the MN Resident storing the SBR needs to have us file transport paperwork if he's going to cross state border into ND, but that's not likely an issue since I don't plan on ever really transporting any NFA items out of the state in which it is listed for storage. That said, I DO have a MN resident listed on my NFA trust. He CAN purchase suppressors, and non-C&R pre-86 NFA toys, but they have to be stored in ND. He CAN Form1 an SBR, and that CAN be stored in MN. Edited to add: It DID take me a number of months of talking back & forth with ATF, and an attourney to get a multi-state capable NFA trust document set created and verified as "Acceptable" by ATF standards, but it's finished finally, and my first can will be arriving in the not-too distant future. Later this summer there will be a couple SBR's done around July too. Then later in the fall there will likely be another can going on the trust (likely a 45 Ti-Rant, or 45 Osprey and three pistons to adapt it to a few different 45acp and 9mm pistols. I just think the versatility of an NFA trust is worth the time and money to do the paperwork... Unless something has changed, you do not need ATF Form 5320.20 transportation paperwork for a silencer |
|
Quoted: What does the "pretty high security clearance" have to do with it? View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Those are all very good points about the down side to NFA trusts & corporate filings. Thankfully, the guy I listed on my trust has a pretty high security clearance, doesn't drink at all, and I trust him with my life. The trust also lists the very specific procedure involved with removal of co-trustees in the event of that person losing their right to own firearms, etc., but that could always get messy, but I don't think I'll likely have to deal with that in the future. What does the "pretty high security clearance" have to do with it? |
|
Quoted: Unless something has changed, you do not need ATF Form 5320.20 transportation paperwork for a silencer View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: Why bother with a trust? Unless something has changed, you do not need ATF Form 5320.20 transportation paperwork for a silencer |
|
Quoted:
Excellent. While setting up my trut I was talking with a lawyer, a dealer, and the ATF, and since I was pretty clueless about many NFA regulations, I asked a lot of questions. I thought they meant all NFA items need transport papers. If it's just firearms and not suppressors, then that's even better. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Why bother with a trust? Unless something has changed, you do not need ATF Form 5320.20 transportation paperwork for a silencer Just for the guns, its not needed for a can IIRC |
|
Quoted:
Excellent. While setting up my trut I was talking with a lawyer, a dealer, and the ATF, and since I was pretty clueless about many NFA regulations, I asked a lot of questions. I thought they meant all NFA items need transport papers. If it's just firearms and not suppressors, then that's even better. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Why bother with a trust? Unless something has changed, you do not need ATF Form 5320.20 transportation paperwork for a silencer It's essentially everything but suppressors. MGs, SBR/SBS, and DDs all require a 5320.20. |
|
Quoted: I've always trusted him, but it also means our defense industry also considers him a highly trustworthy guy... View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: Those are all very good points about the down side to NFA trusts & corporate filings. Thankfully, the guy I listed on my trust has a pretty high security clearance, doesn't drink at all, and I trust him with my life. The trust also lists the very specific procedure involved with removal of co-trustees in the event of that person losing their right to own firearms, etc., but that could always get messy, but I don't think I'll likely have to deal with that in the future. What does the "pretty high security clearance" have to do with it? I trusted a guy with a Top Secret Security Clearance one time, he fucked me over pretty good and he still has his Top Secret Security Clearance That security clearance don't mean shit |
|
Quoted: It's essentially everything but suppressors. MGs, SBR/SBS, and DDs all require a 5320.20. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: Why bother with a trust? Unless something has changed, you do not need ATF Form 5320.20 transportation paperwork for a silencer It's essentially everything but suppressors. MGs, SBR/SBS, and DDs all require a 5320.20. Correct, unless of course you have a SOT |
|
Went to the ATF web site to order the finger print cards. The 1st selection was application to make a weapon packet. Included finger print card and form 1. Was this correct?
|
|
Yes those are the correct forms... Have to ask why did you not go the trust route?
|
|
Quoted:
Yes those are the correct forms... Have to ask why did you not go the trust route? View Quote Because if you check the NFA forums, the trust route is all but dead. |
|
It sucks, I know, but at least I know all three people on my trust are able to pass the background checks.
At least there will still be no need for CLEO sign-off, and I still have versatility of possession & asset protection... The ability to pool funds within co-trustees to purchase more expensive NFA goodies, so not one person needs to fork over $10,000+ for fun toys. |
|
Just got a letter in the mail that the form 1 packet I ordered is on back order. WTF? Them slowing down the process or that many folks submitting that it dried up all the paperwork?
|
|
Quoted: Just got a letter in the mail that the form 1 packet I ordered is on back order. WTF? Them slowing down the process or that many folks submitting that it dried up all the paperwork? View Quote it's online |
|
View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Just got a letter in the mail that the form 1 packet I ordered is on back order. WTF? Them slowing down the process or that many folks submitting that it dried up all the paperwork? it's online http://www.atf.gov/files/forms/download/atf-f-5320-1.pdf Thanks. I know it is but need the packet for the finger print cards since I am not doing the trust. |
|
Quoted: Thanks. I know it is but need the packet for the finger print cards since I am not doing the trust. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: Just got a letter in the mail that the form 1 packet I ordered is on back order. WTF? Them slowing down the process or that many folks submitting that it dried up all the paperwork? it's online http://www.atf.gov/files/forms/download/atf-f-5320-1.pdf Thanks. I know it is but need the packet for the finger print cards since I am not doing the trust. Call the St Paul office of the BATF&E, they will send them out to you |
|
Thanks. Next question. Anyone in Minnesota do engraving for SBR's?
|
|
There's Orion Arms but they only accept shipping...there's no store hours and you can't drop it off/pick it up in person last I remember. I don't know of anyone else local-ish to the twin cities...don't know about other major metro areas though?
|
|
Quoted:
Thanks. Next question. Anyone in Minnesota do engraving for SBR's? View Quote Atomic Tactical did mine. Quality work and fast turn around http://www.atomictactical.com/ |
|
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
Thanks for the info I just placed my order with 199trust What was the turn around time? It took them about a day or so to get mine to me. I ordered in the evening and i had it before the end of the next day. |
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.