My engraving looks perfect/factory after using the Birchwood Casey Aluminum Black.
Cleaned the engraved letters with denatured alcohol and waited 10 minutes for it to dry.
Applied the Aluminum black and let it sit for 60 seconds
Wiped the Aluminum Black off and cleaned the residue with alcohol and waited 10 minutes for it to dry
Applied a 2nd application Aluminum black and let it sit for 60 seconds
Wiped the Aluminum Black off and cleaned the residue with alcohol and waited 10 minutes for it to dry
Oiled it up and it looks great.
One thing I noticed. When the laser engraving was done it left just a tiny tiny amount of "flashing" around the letters; enough to lightly snag a kleenex tissue when wiping the letters down.
The corrosiveness of the Aluminum Black smoothed out/removed the flashing so it's perfectly smooth now.
The warning label does say "DANGER:POISON.CORROSIVE" so don't let it sit too long on the aluminum.