Quote History Quoted:
Manchester is good but I would go the other direction towards Palmyra and annville if possible. Good schools,lower taxes, smaller city,less traffic and way better houses for the money.
ETA: local range is $115 yr and has indoor 22rifle and all cal pistol 24/7 and outdoor everything else.
View Quote
I no longer live there, but it sounds like we used to be neighbor's! Palmyra Sportsmans club is (was) great! Lots of options and a cheap price. I loved the area, but like all things, it's getting too developed.
OP, welcome to the area, though I'm no longer there. When I look at the value of my parents' house, it's under $200k for a 2,200 sq ft house, 5 bed/2 baths/2 car garage. You should be able to find something nice if you don't mind updating it. I don't know where you're coming from in NY, but the area is very old. Annville was settled before the French and Indian War was over. There's lots of suburbs out there from the 60s/70s/80s where you can find a house that you can update for cheap.
Palmyra was a good school when I lived there, Annville (the old school) was a smaller, poorer school. A "cow school" as they would call us. Wouldn't trade it for the world now, though.
For recreation, I was a big fan of Swatara Gap and the Rails to Trails programs. Anywhere in the Lebanon Valley is a short drive to some wilderness. And congratulations, you're in the land of gunshops, as I used to call it. When I'd go home on leave, I'd hit up Shyda's, Trop, Cabelas, Enck's Gun Barn, Horseshoe Pike (a few times, they're a newcomer), Lanco Tactical, Kinnseys, etc. all in one journey.