Quote History Quoted:
“ Silencer. A firearm silencer...includes any combination of parts, designed or redesigned, and intended for use in assembling...a firearm silencer.”
I hope this helps clarify things.
View Quote
Geez, I'm not sure where to begin. Your quote on the definition of a silencer is about the only thing you got right.
I never found out who started the rumor about holding in baffles, but this has nothing to do with whether an end cap is a silencer part or not.
If you use a snap ring (or other device) to hold your baffles, so as not to rely on the end cap, all you've done is made another silencer part. Your end cap is still a silencer part as well.
The real reason the SiCo (and several other) end caps are able to be purchase OTC and swapped out is due to time and money being spent on behalf of the Mfr to make it so. They've proven to the ATF that these parts are not designed, intended, or made solely for the use as a silencer part. They sell muzzle brake, flash cans which also use these end caps. A Form1 builder does not have a manufacturing license and, therefore, is unable to go about this same process.
As for LIDS/Nielsen devices:
Retails purchasable boosters are not silencer parts, because their Mfr's have, again, spent time and money to have the ATF deem them as such. They provide no sound reduction or enhancement of the silencer. They simply allow the firearm to function properly. Without the booster, the silencer will still muffle a shot just as it did w/ it on. You can research the BS YHM went through in '09, I believe I referenced this in an above post, and get more info there. Not to mention the fact that they are sold at retail, on a daily basis.
You would not be able to, legally, remove the booster from an Octane and continue using the same silencer w/o having an illegal spare, silencer part in your possession. This is because of the Octane's design. It adds volume to and serves as an initial chamber for the silencer.
As for adapters:
If it is a simple thread adapter (ie: going from 5/8-24 to 1/2-28) than it is not a silencer part. It is not a part designed to be used for the muffling of a gunshot. It does not enhance nor provide any properties to which a silencer would benefit. It merely facilitate the mounting to a firearm by which the silencer may be used. If it is an end cap (specifically the rear) than it is indeed a silencer part. Not because it holds in the baffles, but because it holds in the gas and muzzle report. If you remove your rear end cap, to facilitate mounting a LID/Booster, you can be found in violation of NFA law. Once you've mounted the LID, your silencer no longer needs the end cap to properly function, as designed, and you are in possession of an illegal spare part.
Please, stop spreading misinformation. There is plenty to be had and it helps none of us.