Ostensibly, my 18" 5.56 AR is my mid-range, less expensive alternative to my 6.5 Creedmoor with a 24" heavy barrel. The Creedmoor is great at distance, but it's mostly overkill for tannerite or steel at anything less than 200. Because the 18" 5.56 is a bench/prone gun that wears a bipod, I don't mind the weight or length with the can attached. That said, I still don't shoot the 18" that much because the Creedmoor is more fun to shoot, even if I am burning a quarter or more per shot. I'm on the fence about what to do with this gun.
The other non-SBR AR was a 16" lightweight Noveske 5.56. With irons and an A2 flashhider, it was a nice, handy gun. However, after the addition of a QD can, even the lightweight titanium version still felt like a brick hanging off the end of the barrel. I considered going the 10.5" or 11".5 5.56 route and SBRing that one, too, but my Blackout felt too long at 10.2" (I had it shortened), so I knew I wouldn't be happy with even a 10.5". A 7.5 5.56 would be really fun for plinking, but YHM doesn't warranty the can for that short a barrel in 5.56. I already have guns in 7.62x39, so that wasn't an appealing caliber for an AR SBR.
Although I looked at them and ruled them out a few years ago because cheap, milsurp ammo dried up, I stumbled across an old thread on running 7.62x25 Tokarev in an AR upper. Although the price per shot is slightly higher than 5.56, it's less than Blackout, so that's a plus. I can still use the same .30 cal can that I run on all my other rifles. Additionally, I figured that I could run an even shorter barrel than the Blackout and have no issues with the suppressor blast baffle wear. Finally, though it shoots pretty darned flat to 100 yards for a pistol, the velocity is still low enough that even at fairly short range it won't eat up my target steel like the 5.56 does at distances less than about 75 yards. I took the plunge and sent some parts to Tim at Heavy Metal to have a 7" Tok upper made to run factory ammo. Though the 7.62x25 can be throated to run longer, heavier bullets at subsonic speeds, like the JD Jones 7.62 Mini Whisper, I decided to stick with supersonic factory ammo for the sake of plinking. It's still a work in progress as "custom" takes time, but I can't wait to get it to the range and ring steel with it.