Quote History Quoted:
Well the adventure continues.
Very little end play in this gun but it can be forced out of time with a bit of cylinder drag and it has a hair too much side play. Its shootable but I think I needs a new cylinder stop and maybe a new hand.
I've been watching the Midway video on replacing the hand and reading up on replacing the stop. I'm starting to feel confident that I can do this. It seems to be a matter of having decent stones, maintaining angles, and going SLOWLY and test fitting often.
Thoughts, advice, and warnings would be welcome!
View Quote
You should still buy the Jerry Kuhnhausen Shop Manual on the S&W revolvers.
It explains a lot you may not suspect.
One thing you need to know is that the S&W design, like most other brands except the old style Colt action, REQUIRE that the cylinder have rotational movement at ignition.
In other words, if you pull the trigger and hold it back while checking for cylinder movement the S&W MUST have some movement.
Only the old Colt's like the Python lock up tight when the trigger is pulled.
Checking the S&W, Ruger, Dan Wesson, or newer Colt's like the Mark III and later, holding the trigger back and checking the cylinder IS NOT A VALID TEST FOR ANYTHING.
The way most DA revolvers are designed to operate is when the trigger is pulled the slightly loose cylinder will allow the bullet passing from the chamber to the barrel to force the chamber into alignment.
If you set up the gun with zero cylinder looseness the bullet will hit the forcing cone off-center and you'll get bad accuracy and bullet metal spiting out the sides.
While some revolvers will seem to be tightly locked there's enough backlash built into the action to allow enough cylinder movement for proper operation.
People ask what the factory standard is for cylinder looseness.
There really isn't one.
The standard and the test for correct operation is if the gun is shooting accurately and isn't spitting bullet metal.... it's good.
Some guns will have more or less cylinder movement but that's not any kind of issue as long as the gun shoots correctly.
So, if you're planning on installing a new cylinder bolt and get a nice tightly locked cylinder, you're actually causing the gun to not work correctly AS DESIGNED.