OK, I take this stuff serious. (right....
) So I drove down to KyGunCo and they had four of these. I got to handle one and see if first hand. The short of it was...when I left they still had four of them in stock.
Impressions:
Yes, it looks like a M-1 carbine. But, it is really short. Have I just forgotten how short the carbine was?
Its made in Italy, quality is a big ???
The action doesn't look quite right, its got an operating rod down both sides, not just one like the original. The finish is so-so. Not terrible, not wonderful.
The bolt just slides back, it doesn't rotate like the real thing.
The trigger housing is plastic. Nice plastic but plastic. So is the bayonet mount. But it is styled correctly.
The stock does have the cut out for the oilier sling mount.
The stock on the one I looked at was wood. Mystery wood covered in a very dark brown stain. Again, not perfect but OK
Conclusion:
Hard to speak for all but for me I left it on the counter. I like M-1 carbines since having one in the Army long ago. ( I was in a really out of the way station in Africa and we still had them in the late 1960's). Then I had one of those Plainsfield carbines made from surplus parts. Sort of an imitation of the original.
The M-1 carbine was, in the 60's and 70's the AR-14 of its day. Time moved on and now we pine for what was lost. If you don't have a PCC already and you want something that mostly looks like an M-1 but shoots 9mm, then this might be your rifle. Its short and small. Weight is similar to an original. From a distance it certainly resembles an M-1. It shoots 9mm ammo that is easier to find and cheaper than the .30 carbine ammo but doesn't have as much power of course.
I still want to see how they do. I know that in ten years it will be an orphan like many other guns that are fashionable. Also, I want to wait and see what the pricing does. I am betting that in a year or two they will be like $449 or something. At that price they get more interesting.