|
|
Posted: 8/18/2012 8:22:29 PM
THE IMAGE ABOVE IS A PAID ADVERTISEMENT I want to buy the largest strongest safe I can afford, I was thinking about spending $3000-ish. However I do not want someone that will just drop the safe at my door, I want them to move it to my back room and drill into the foundation for me. So I went looking for local shops. The only safe shop near me deals in Liberty and Browning safes. Their Liberty safes are nice enough but after looking at this website http://www.6mmbr.com/gunsafes.html the Liberty leaves a lot to be desired. (11 gauge steel doors on their Franklin models) So what safe makers should I be looking at that makes a great safe that will actually deliver and install to me in southern Maryland? |
|
|
|
|
Posted: 8/18/2012 10:07:53 PM
Chek these out
Price includes delivery to your door. From there it's your gig. It's not that hard unless you're going up or down stairs. In that case I'd look are someone with safe moving experience. |
|
|
|
Posted: 8/18/2012 11:15:50 PM
What part of Maryland are you in?
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: 8/19/2012 12:13:34 PM
[Last Edit: 8/19/2012 12:47:46 PM by hk45shooter]
Personally I like my Liberty's.
My dealer delivered & set it up at no extra cost. Originally Posted By mrozowjj:
...I'm looking at getting a big giant freaking gun safe. ...I was thinking about spending $3000-ish. $3,000-ish won't buy much in the lines of "a big giant freaking gun safe" quality wise. Just saying. That is close to what was spent on my Liberty Lincoln 35. ETA: I guess it just depends on what your definition of "a big giant freaking gun safe" is though. |
|
|
|
Posted: 8/20/2012 8:53:43 PM
I highly recommend looking at Champion, especially the Crown Series. There are one or two on this forum who don't like Champion, but specifics are never mentioned when asked why. If you look at their construction, they are built very well for RSCs...3/16" construction, multiple relockers Their fire rating is very good (perhaps one of the best in the industry...even though there are no industry standards). Do your own research...I think you'll find them to be very good...plus three dealers in MD.
Champion |
|
|
|
Posted: 8/21/2012 2:24:19 PM
Originally Posted By Blake:
I highly recommend looking at Champion, especially the Crown Series. There are one or two on this forum who don't like Champion, but specifics are never mentioned when asked why. If you look at their construction, they are built very well for RSCs...3/16" construction, multiple relockers Their fire rating is very good (perhaps one of the best in the industry...even though there are no industry standards). Do your own research...I think you'll find them to be very good...plus three dealers in MD. Champion I called the dealer and they were asking about $4K for the C50. So much random info being thrown out there it seems to be impossible to figure out what safes are actually quality and which ones are not. |
|
|
|
|
Posted: 8/21/2012 6:20:36 PM
[Last Edit: 8/21/2012 6:22:38 PM by Blake]
Bought one today in granite for $3,500.00...being delivered and installed Monday.
Rely less on anecdotes and opinion (even though I highly value opinions here), and compare for yourself. |
|
|
|
Posted: 8/21/2012 10:12:22 PM
Originally Posted By Blake:
Bought one today in granite for $3,500.00...being delivered and installed Monday. Rely less on anecdotes and opinion (even though I highly value opinions here), and compare for yourself. Ok but how do I "compare" for myself? I highly doubt the safe companies are going to allow me to bash on their safes to see how secure they really are so everything I get is anecdotes. Every safe company likes to site statistics and "facts"about why their safe is better or what makes it the best on the market. There are videos of people prying one safe open. One guy pounds on a safe with a sledge. None of these tests are very scientific. There does not seem to be any independent body to test safes that I have found so everything is heresay and anecdotes. Every safe maker has amazing testimonials written by happy customers. |
|
|
|
|
Posted: 8/21/2012 11:05:13 PM
I'm just a consumer, but I looked at construction first. 7ga (3/16") steel in the Crown Series...Sturdy, Liberty, and Fort Knox all offer this as well. Champion's body is continuous welded, as is Sturdy and Fort Knox...not sure about Liberty. Number of active bolts was next...24 1.5" bolts for Champion...fewer with Sturdy, fewer with Fort Knox Titan and Executive, comparable with Liberty National and Presidential...the corner bolts on the Fort Knox are very nice and I think a huge plus.
Then you can look at weight for size..Champion is heavier than Sturdy, slightly less than Liberty...unsure about Fort Knox - too many variables. Then look at fire rating...no industry standard, but you can look at their testing methods. Champion sent me pictures of their bolt construction/support as well as their mechanism...some other RSCs are more robust, some are less robust. Aesthetics - Champion is nicer than Sturdy, comparable to Liberty, not as nice as Fort Knox. Dealer support if necessary...Champion, Fort Knox, and Liberty are all supported locally while Sturdy is not. Then look at price...Champion is slightly less than Sturdy, substantially less than Liberty, and 1/2 the cost of Fort Knox. Sturdy was my second choice, but it came down to local support. I thought Liberty was too expensive for what it is. Fort Knox was simply out of the budget. There are other considerations, but you can figure those out and decide what is important to you. Good luck. |
|
|
|
Posted: 8/22/2012 12:17:14 AM
Fort Knox or a Sturdy. Considering your budget...these 2 would fit the bill. Fort is a prettier safer of the two with better handles and paint job but the sturdy would be a little cheaper and every bit as tough! 7 gauge on both (depending on the fort model).
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: 8/22/2012 10:20:40 AM
Originally Posted By Blake:
I'm just a consumer, but I looked at construction first. 7ga (3/16") steel in the Crown Series...Sturdy, Liberty, and Fort Knox all offer this as well. Champion's body is continuous welded, as is Sturdy and Fort Knox...not sure about Liberty. Number of active bolts was next...24 1.5" bolts for Champion...fewer with Sturdy, fewer with Fort Knox Titan and Executive, comparable with Liberty National and Presidential...the corner bolts on the Fort Knox are very nice and I think a huge plus. Then you can look at weight for size..Champion is heavier than Sturdy, slightly less than Liberty...unsure about Fort Knox - too many variables. Then look at fire rating...no industry standard, but you can look at their testing methods. Champion sent me pictures of their bolt construction/support as well as their mechanism...some other RSCs are more robust, some are less robust. Aesthetics - Champion is nicer than Sturdy, comparable to Liberty, not as nice as Fort Knox. Dealer support if necessary...Champion, Fort Knox, and Liberty are all supported locally while Sturdy is not. Then look at price...Champion is slightly less than Sturdy, substantially less than Liberty, and 1/2 the cost of Fort Knox. Sturdy was my second choice, but it came down to local support. I thought Liberty was too expensive for what it is. Fort Knox was simply out of the budget. There are other considerations, but you can figure those out and decide what is important to you. Good luck. When comparing the models I would be most interested in both the Sturdy or the Champion would be 4K which is more than I'd planned on spending. I need to see what it will cost to get the Sturdy moved and then installed to my house though. |
|
|
|
|
Posted: 8/22/2012 1:38:15 PM
If there is another quality brand other than Sturdy that offers a 72" model with at least 3/16 walls, a plate rigid door, continuous welds, and strong pry resistant bolt work, plus a lifetime warranty on everything including the lock for under $2,500, I would really like to know because I haven't found it yet. My planned Sturdy comes in under that price range, even with 3/8" (double side walls) sides, but not needing fire lining does really help in the Sturdy vs. others cost comparison.
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: 8/22/2012 2:36:21 PM
[Last Edit: 8/22/2012 3:00:18 PM by Blake]
Originally Posted By Elessar:
If there is another quality brand other than Sturdy that offers a 72" model with at least 3/16 walls, a plate rigid door, continuous welds, and strong pry resistant bolt work, plus a lifetime warranty on everything including the lock for under $2,500, I would really like to know because I haven't found it yet. My planned Sturdy comes in under that price range, even with 3/8" (double side walls) sides, but not needing fire lining does really help in the Sturdy vs. others cost comparison. Hmmm. That's definitely without fire protection. Just a comparable Sturdy WITHOUT any upgrades was still a couple of hundred dollars more than Champion. Sturdy is definitely a good safe though. OP should compare several safes. From Sturdy website: $3,034.00 for the 4827-6 without fire lining. Add $945.00 for fire lining. Champion Crown 50 is the comparable size with most of the security features you mentioned at $3,600.00...fire lining is standard. Again, I think Sturdy is great. Champion just happens to have a factory here, and I think they are very nice as well. Both are good deals and offer A LOT of safe for the money. |
|
|
|
Posted: 8/22/2012 3:25:11 PM
Originally Posted By Blake:
Originally Posted By Elessar:
If there is another quality brand other than Sturdy that offers a 72" model with at least 3/16 walls, a plate rigid door, continuous welds, and strong pry resistant bolt work, plus a lifetime warranty on everything including the lock for under $2,500, I would really like to know because I haven't found it yet. My planned Sturdy comes in under that price range, even with 3/8" (double side walls) sides, but not needing fire lining does really help in the Sturdy vs. others cost comparison. Hmmm. That's definitely without fire protection. Just a comparable Sturdy WITHOUT any upgrades was still a couple of hundred dollars more than Champion. Sturdy is definitely a good safe though. OP should compare several safes. From Sturdy website: $3,034.00 for the 4827-6 without fire lining. Add $945.00 for fire lining. Champion Crown 50 is the comparable size with most of the security features you mentioned at $3,600.00...fire lining is standard. Again, I think Sturdy is great. Champion just happens to have a factory here, and I think they are very nice as well. Both are good deals and offer A LOT of safe for the money. You keep saying that Champion supports locally and that "they have a factory here" and that may be all well and good when you live in TN but it does me no good where I live. And I don't know where you are getting your prices but the closest dealer to me that deals in Champion quoted me $3900 for the Crown 50 in regular colors and $4100 for the Crown 50 in the premium color schemes. They then want an extra $170 to deliver it to my door which would not include having it moved into my house and then bolted to the foundation so which ever safe I go with Champion or Sturdy they are going to cost me $4k + installation. The Champion dealer told me it'd be months before I got a safe though. |
|
|
|
|
Posted: 8/22/2012 3:26:52 PM
Ipurchased a 32X whatever Sturdy safe, 7 guage steel walls plus stainless steel wall extra reinforcements total wall thickness of 3/8 thick. Heavy sucker at about 800 lbs plus its bolted to concrete... At about $2k the level of resistance it provides with a solid contruction is a good value IMHO.
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: 8/22/2012 4:14:56 PM
Originally Posted By mrozowjj:
Originally Posted By Blake:
Originally Posted By Elessar:
If there is another quality brand other than Sturdy that offers a 72" model with at least 3/16 walls, a plate rigid door, continuous welds, and strong pry resistant bolt work, plus a lifetime warranty on everything including the lock for under $2,500, I would really like to know because I haven't found it yet. My planned Sturdy comes in under that price range, even with 3/8" (double side walls) sides, but not needing fire lining does really help in the Sturdy vs. others cost comparison. Hmmm. That's definitely without fire protection. Just a comparable Sturdy WITHOUT any upgrades was still a couple of hundred dollars more than Champion. Sturdy is definitely a good safe though. OP should compare several safes. From Sturdy website: $3,034.00 for the 4827-6 without fire lining. Add $945.00 for fire lining. Champion Crown 50 is the comparable size with most of the security features you mentioned at $3,600.00...fire lining is standard. Again, I think Sturdy is great. Champion just happens to have a factory here, and I think they are very nice as well. Both are good deals and offer A LOT of safe for the money. You keep saying that Champion supports locally and that "they have a factory here" and that may be all well and good when you live in TN but it does me no good where I live. And I don't know where you are getting your prices but the closest dealer to me that deals in Champion quoted me $3900 for the Crown 50 in regular colors and $4100 for the Crown 50 in the premium color schemes. They then want an extra $170 to deliver it to my door which would not include having it moved into my house and then bolted to the foundation so which ever safe I go with Champion or Sturdy they are going to cost me $4k + installation. The Champion dealer told me it'd be months before I got a safe though. I understand that I have an advantage with a Champion factory here in Knoxville, but my dealer is an independent dealer. There are no Sturdy dealers, so there is nobody locally to turn to if something goes wrong. $3,500.00 for a C50 in granite. I actually wanted a C60, but you are correct, it would have taken months to get one. Since he had a C50 in stock, I took it. $100.00 delivered and installed. |
|
|
|
Posted: 8/27/2012 8:37:31 PM
Originally Posted By Blake:
I highly recommend looking at Champion, especially the Crown Series. There are one or two on this forum who don't like Champion, but specifics are never mentioned when asked why. If you look at their construction, they are built very well for RSCs...3/16" construction, multiple relockers Their fire rating is very good (perhaps one of the best in the industry...even though there are no industry standards). Do your own research...I think you'll find them to be very good...plus three dealers in MD. Champion I realy like my Champion |
|
|
|
Posted: 9/3/2012 4:35:35 PM
[Last Edit: 9/3/2012 4:36:59 PM by jukeboxx13]
I am really liking the sturdy safes right now, and they have great videos on youtube proving their toughness. As compared with fortnox with price the sturdy wins, and its just as good with 7 gage. As for moving it into your house and bolting it down it will probably cost over 200 with a big safe. Good luck.
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: 9/6/2012 10:04:08 PM
Crown 50 was delivered last week. I love it. It is built very well...considerably beefier/sutrdier/tougher/more "tank-like" than the Champion Challenger 25 I also have. Again, the only knock I have against Champion is that their interiors are no where near as nice as Liberty or Fort Knox...but if I were that concerned about it I could easily cut custom shelves and upholster with much nicer fabric for less than $200.00. I feel confident you will be very pleased in Champion...again, there are plenty of good safes out there.
|
|
|
|
Posted: 9/7/2012 12:52:56 AM
The one made with the thickest metal and damn good fire rating.
|
|
|