I'm looking for a low cost, decent knife for my emergency bag. I already have a nice BK2, but want something lighter (about the same length though).
So I thought I'd try the Gerber Strongarm. I loved everything about it. It seems to get great reviews, and that the (often debated) 420HC holds an edge (due to good heat treat on this model). It also has a VERY versatile sheath (huge plus for me). Add to that, it's available in fine edge (the only way I'd go) and I was sold.
Well... the first one I ordered had a VERY nice edge, great sheath retention (strong clip) but, unfortunately, was the wrong blade (combo edge) so I returned it. The second one had the correct fine edge but was the worst edge I've EVER seen from a factory knife. It's edge had rolls, chips, and both sides were VERY unevenly ground. It was a horrible mess. The sheath on the second one also has VERY weak retention (the knife would easily fall out under a good shake (upside down, with no snap strap. This model is designed to also be mounted upside down without strap, which it failed miserably).
So my question is... is it worth trying another one? Has Gerber gotten to the point of such wildly inconsistent QC that they're all over the map, or was I just so unlucky?
If recommending staying clear of them, does anyone have a comparable knife I should look at that:
Is lighter (and better balanced) than a BK2
Has a sheath with STRONG retention even with a top strap unsnapped (important for me in case a strap snap comes undone with rough handling/snagging on terrain).
Has a fairly rugged blade decent for utility (not strictly bushcraft, tactical, or other... but a "jack of all trades, master of none" type)?
I'd prefer a USA made, but open to suggestions (if not going for another Strongarm).
Thanks!