User Panel
|
|
Cold Steel Recon Tanto. Sorry, no pics of mine.
Google, or Bing, or Duck Duck Go some Cold Steel Recon Tanto torture test videos. This thing is nearly indestructible. |
|
|
View Quote I have one. Fit and finish was much better than I expected. The entire knife looks to be made by CNC, so they're perfect like a Chris Reeve. C4 kydex sheaths are top notch too. Interchangeable scales are a cool feature and they're well made too. All around a great deal even considering the premium price. Nice people to deal with too, always helpful and pleasant. O1 steel is a feature for me, it might not be for someone who wants boutique stainless steel. O1 is tough, easy to sharpen, and it takes an extremely fine edge. That's a plus for me, but like I said, for some it's not. |
|
Quoted:
Chris Reeve http://payload132.cargocollective.com/1/10/338756/4951976/Pacific2014resize_860.jpg View Quote This! |
|
|
Quoted:
The knife in this post is the model Seal Pup SEKI - JAPAN made. Here, some Wiki infos ; SOG manufactures a knife used by the United States Navy SEALs dubbed the SEAL 2000.[3] The SOG SEAL 2000 is a 7" bladed fixed blade knife with a rubber handle that was designed for the US Navy SEAL Knife trials in 1992. The knife was manufactured from 1995 to 2007 for SOG by Kinryu of Seki Japan. Both the Seal 2000 and the smaller version, the Seal Pup are on display in the knife exhibit at the US Navy SEAL Museum in Ft.Pierce, Florida. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
I am sure this is open to debate and is high subjective, but in your opinion and if price was no object who makes the very best combat blades? In terms of aesthetics, durability, and quality. This, SOG <a href="http://s1102.photobucket.com/user/M9M4/media/M9M4%20SOGknifeSEKImadeJAPAN_zps9sttiniw.jpg.html" target="_blank">http://i1102.photobucket.com/albums/g450/M9M4/M9M4%20SOGknifeSEKImadeJAPAN_zps9sttiniw.jpg</a> Is that the SEAL or the Pup? If it was the SEAL what year was it made? The new ones aren't nearly as good as the old ones. Posted Via AR15.Com Mobile The knife in this post is the model Seal Pup SEKI - JAPAN made. Here, some Wiki infos ; SOG manufactures a knife used by the United States Navy SEALs dubbed the SEAL 2000.[3] The SOG SEAL 2000 is a 7" bladed fixed blade knife with a rubber handle that was designed for the US Navy SEAL Knife trials in 1992. The knife was manufactured from 1995 to 2007 for SOG by Kinryu of Seki Japan. Both the Seal 2000 and the smaller version, the Seal Pup are on display in the knife exhibit at the US Navy SEAL Museum in Ft.Pierce, Florida. And I have one of each Eta: of the originals... |
|
Quoted:
I have one. Fit and finish was much better than I expected. The entire knife looks to be made by CNC, so they're perfect like a Chris Reeve. C4 kydex sheaths are top notch too. Interchangeable scales are a cool feature and they're well made too. All around a great deal even considering the premium price. Nice people to deal with too, always helpful and pleasant. O1 steel is a feature for me, it might not be for someone who wants boutique stainless steel. O1 is tough, easy to sharpen, and it takes an extremely fine edge. That's a plus for me, but like I said, for some it's not. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
I have one. Fit and finish was much better than I expected. The entire knife looks to be made by CNC, so they're perfect like a Chris Reeve. C4 kydex sheaths are top notch too. Interchangeable scales are a cool feature and they're well made too. All around a great deal even considering the premium price. Nice people to deal with too, always helpful and pleasant. O1 steel is a feature for me, it might not be for someone who wants boutique stainless steel. O1 is tough, easy to sharpen, and it takes an extremely fine edge. That's a plus for me, but like I said, for some it's not. I met him and his wife at a knife show. Good people. I bought one of his recon hunters. I love it and the sheath is top notch kydex! I recently purchased a knife from a different maker and the kydex was terrible. Makes me appreciate the treemans kydex more. |
|
Quoted: Money no object yet people are naming cheap imports like Cold Steel and SOG? Randalls are pretty and well made but there modern metallurgy has produced steels that are superior in every way to what they've been using since the 1970s. For a general purpose combat knife I'd probably choose something like the Sibert Scout. http://i1288.photobucket.com/albums/b489/trbrst/7107fee7b1b5630e8392ee5453111063_zpsfjzeymdl.jpg View Quote That's a nice looking knife. The website doesn't mentioned which steel is used to make the blade. ETA - Nevermind, I found it on another page: Crucible Steels premium CPM S30V stainless is used exclusively. Knives are professionally heat treated by MET-TEK with a triple temper and cryogenic soak to a Rockwell hardness of 59-60. S30V exhibits better edge retention then ATS-34 or D-2, while still retaining a higher degree of toughness. |
|
Quoted: Money no object yet people are naming cheap imports like Cold Steel and SOG? Randalls are pretty and well made but there modern metallurgy has produced steels that are superior in every way to what they've been using since the 1970s. For a general purpose combat knife I'd probably choose something like the Sibert Scout. http://i1288.photobucket.com/albums/b489/trbrst/7107fee7b1b5630e8392ee5453111063_zpsfjzeymdl.jpg View Quote |
|
|
I think the Bowie knife has the best track record for fucking people up with a knife.
|
|
*shrug* I like bayonets and bowie knifes for fighting / combat, not that I have ever been in a knife fight, nor do I want to be, but seeing as the Bowie was born of knife fighting it seems to be a logical way to go. I don't own a bowie, I do own some U.S. Army bayonets, I think i'll soon buy a Glock straight blade (can't remember the nomenclature off the top of my head) and BK9. BK9 is a heck of a knife for the money.
Not into blades enough to care about the super duper special custom whiz bang stuff. Though I do plan to make my own before to long using a piece of a huge elk shed as a handle, not sure if I want to do a hidden tang or full tang design with it yet, but I think I will make the blade bowie-ish. And maybe make a 2nd more as a skinning knife. I will likely value them over the others as it's something I made. Not sure what steel I want to use yet. Has the OP considered making his own custom blade? So long as you have a good bench grinder, a few files, sand paper etc. you can make something decent, you don't need a torch or forge and BFH. |
|
Quoted:
I met him and his wife at a knife show. Good people. I bought one of his recon hunters. I love it and the sheath is top notch kydex! I recently purchased a knife from a different maker and the kydex was terrible. Makes me appreciate the treemans kydex more. View Quote Those sheaths are made by Frank Landau. I have a couple of Frank's sheaths for Busses. I'm spoiled now, I want one for everything I have! |
|
Requirements for a good fixed blade-
Must be FIXED blade. Not some broken blade Under 4 inchs blade length. 4 inches is plenty to hit vitals while not being absurdly long. Longer the blade, easier to strip from your hands. No serrations. Serrations gets caught in clothing very easily. You want a blade that can move easily in and out of many clothing options. Handle must have orientation for finger placement. You may have to fight in the dark. Having a groove to indicate where your fingers should be based on edge orientation. Enlarged pummel for easier draw. Preferably a curved design. Correct choil placement. Spearpoint design. Blades just as the Izula Esee aren't good for fighting. Why? No spear point for penetration. When fighting with a blade, you want to concentrate on "entries." Not slashes. The Romans proved stabbing was far deadlier than slashing. Grind- I like convex or flat grind. Easy to sharpen both of these grinds on multiple mediums. Lastly...A GOOD SHEATH. No one talks about a sheaths for some odd reason. It's literally half the battle. Take classes! Sayoc, Pekiti, etc. There are a lot more wackos teaching blade work than in the firearms industry. Be careful who you learn from! To the OP, it would be wise to take advice from FMA practitioners. Folks who have a background in blade arts. What blades I do like. Gerber Guardian, Cold Steel Secret Edge, Rat Blade from Head Hunter blades of Guro Harley, any Joe Watson Blade. When folks post their favorite blades, try asking why they like it. It's very telling if they have good answers or not. |
|
Quoted:
And I have one of each Eta: of the originals... View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
I am sure this is open to debate and is high subjective, but in your opinion and if price was no object who makes the very best combat blades? In terms of aesthetics, durability, and quality. This, SOG <a href="http://s1102.photobucket.com/user/M9M4/media/M9M4%20SOGknifeSEKImadeJAPAN_zps9sttiniw.jpg.html" target="_blank">http://i1102.photobucket.com/albums/g450/M9M4/M9M4%20SOGknifeSEKImadeJAPAN_zps9sttiniw.jpg</a> Is that the SEAL or the Pup? If it was the SEAL what year was it made? The new ones aren't nearly as good as the old ones. Posted Via AR15.Com Mobile The knife in this post is the model Seal Pup SEKI - JAPAN made. Here, some Wiki infos ; SOG manufactures a knife used by the United States Navy SEALs dubbed the SEAL 2000.[3] The SOG SEAL 2000 is a 7" bladed fixed blade knife with a rubber handle that was designed for the US Navy SEAL Knife trials in 1992. The knife was manufactured from 1995 to 2007 for SOG by Kinryu of Seki Japan. Both the Seal 2000 and the smaller version, the Seal Pup are on display in the knife exhibit at the US Navy SEAL Museum in Ft.Pierce, Florida. And I have one of each Eta: of the originals... Got a Tigershark in 07, steel seems the same but the handle is a little bit softer. This was before they started putting the ridiculous handguard and skull crusher on the handle. IOW it's another nice example of the old SOGs. Posted Via AR15.Com Mobile |
|
Quoted:
I'd look at Spartan Blades I just picked up the Phrike http://i647.photobucket.com/albums/uu199/starscr34m/phrikeone_zpsrv4chvc3.jpg (Top knife) Now I'm thinking about the Horkos http://www.gpknives.com/media/catalog/product/cache/1/image/800x/3d3f317666956ee07a3550dd00d02d6e/4/b/4bkgrnlbk-3.jpg Or the Ares http://cdn3.volusion.com/cwhhs.ntmeb/v/vspfiles/photos/SBW0007-2.jpg?1395182803 View Quote You always seem to have good taste in your knife selection |
|
Quoted:
You always seem to have good taste in your knife selection View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
I'd look at Spartan Blades I just picked up the Phrike http://i647.photobucket.com/albums/uu199/starscr34m/phrikeone_zpsrv4chvc3.jpg (Top knife) Now I'm thinking about the Horkos http://www.gpknives.com/media/catalog/product/cache/1/image/800x/3d3f317666956ee07a3550dd00d02d6e/4/b/4bkgrnlbk-3.jpg Or the Ares http://cdn3.volusion.com/cwhhs.ntmeb/v/vspfiles/photos/SBW0007-2.jpg?1395182803 You always seem to have good taste in your knife selection Thanks! I |
|
|
Quoted:
If you want the best fixed blade currently on the market the Busse Team Gemini Light Brigade fits the bill perfectly, you can get stupid with the knife and it is big enough to be used as a fighter. http://i.imgur.com/01Qn2UQh.jpg View Quote No longer made; in fact, it looks like there are no more Busse Combats are available? Or end of year sell-out for Christmas kind of thing? Busse Combat Knives |
|
Quoted:
No longer made; in fact, it looks like there are no more Busse Combats are available? Or end of year sell-out for Christmas kind of thing? Busse Combat Knives View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
If you want the best fixed blade currently on the market the Busse Team Gemini Light Brigade fits the bill perfectly, you can get stupid with the knife and it is big enough to be used as a fighter. http://i.imgur.com/01Qn2UQh.jpg No longer made; in fact, it looks like there are no more Busse Combats are available? Or end of year sell-out for Christmas kind of thing? Busse Combat Knives No one is really sure whats up currently I know TGLB's are readily available on the secondary market. My guess is by Black Friday or so knives will start being released. The Team Gemini has been discontinued and will probably not be made for a while unfortunately. |
|
I am by no means a knife expert
when I went ti iraq in 03 I carriesd a cold steel voyager tanto 4" 1/2 serrated that knife opened countless spam cams of war saw pact ammo, cut into tons of us made c-4 cakes, opened 1 year=s worth of ME=REs cut hundreds of feet of detcord, 550 cord. not to mention hundreds of hours od guard duty where I bored MIND NUMBED oped and closed it nonstop for entire nights at a TIME. and never broke. I could n't ask anything to perform better that was my answer when this question came up for real. in fixed blade I like the Ontario 1FT I like bayonets & I like tanto blades |
|
No love for Mick Strider ?
names that come to mind are Pete Skike L.T. Wright Battle Horse RMJ T.M Hunt Jericho blade works For production knives tops busse zombie tools southern grind spartan blades |
|
Quoted:
No love for Mick Strider ? names that come to mind are Pete Skike L.T. Wright Battle Horse RMJ T.M Hunt Jericho blade works For production knives tops busse zombie tools southern grind spartan blades View Quote Nope not for combat knives, Strider's heat treat makes the blades chip easily, and shatter if say you land on it in full ruck. Skike is getting out of the fixed blade market with the launch of his new "Rogue Shark" knives and honestly LT Wright and Battle Horse IMHO aren't good battle blades. Busse combat is still the way to go and if you are on a budget ESEE is hard to beat. |
|
I love my 3 Randalls (Model 1, Model 14 and a Model 4-6)....great knives....some of the best "fighters" made BUT I would grab my Winkler II Belt Knife if I had to "grab and go" - It is my favorite hands down.
You should look into the Winkler, you wouldn't regret it. |
|
I guess I cringe at the prices, but "feel" my comfort zone is fixed blade less than $150 for the mainliners (Cold Steel, ESEE, etc).
On the "high end" I guess I would go $200-$400 but become very wary at what I am getting at for those prices; I am still leaning towards Treeman but now Cold Steel is using O1 "high carbon" steel too. The Busse Gemini Light Brigade is $800-1000, which seems quite a bit up there (did this happen due to the Walking Dopes anti-gun Daryl?) Meh, I will keep paying attention here |
|
Quoted:
Nope not for combat knives, Strider's heat treat makes the blades chip easily, and shatter if say you land on it in full ruck. Skike is getting out of the fixed blade market with the launch of his new "Rogue Shark" knives and honestly LT Wright and Battle Horse IMHO aren't good battle blades. Busse combat is still the way to go and if you are on a budget ESEE is hard to beat. View Quote I'm an LT Wright fan but I wouldn't consider them combat knives either. |
|
Quoted:
Requirements for a good fixed blade- Must be FIXED blade. Not some broken blade Under 4 inchs blade length. 4 inches is plenty to hit vitals while not being absurdly long. Longer the blade, easier to strip from your hands. No serrations. Serrations gets caught in clothing very easily. You want a blade that can move easily in and out of many clothing options. Handle must have orientation for finger placement. You may have to fight in the dark. Having a groove to indicate where your fingers should be based on edge orientation. Enlarged pummel for easier draw. Preferably a curved design. Correct choil placement. Spearpoint design. Blades just as the Izula Esee aren't good for fighting. Why? No spear point for penetration. When fighting with a blade, you want to concentrate on "entries." Not slashes. The Romans proved stabbing was far deadlier than slashing. Grind- I like convex or flat grind. Easy to sharpen both of these grinds on multiple mediums. Lastly...A GOOD SHEATH. No one talks about a sheaths for some odd reason. It's literally half the battle. Take classes! Sayoc, Pekiti, etc. There are a lot more wackos teaching blade work than in the firearms industry. Be careful who you learn from! To the OP, it would be wise to take advice from FMA practitioners. Folks who have a background in blade arts. What blades I do like. Gerber Guardian, Cold Steel Secret Edge, Rat Blade from Head Hunter blades of Guro Harley, any Joe Watson Blade. When folks post their favorite blades, try asking why they like it. It's very telling if they have good answers or not. View Quote Great points on selecting a knife for fighting. I carried a Gerber Guardian as an Infantry LT in Korea. Loved that knife! Somehow lost it years ago. I might have to buy another one, although this thrad has me wanting an Applegate Fairbairn as well. Those Joe Watson blades look really nice. |
|
Quoted:
Great points on selecting a knife for fighting. I carried a Gerber Guardian as an Infantry LT in Korea. Loved that knife! Somehow lost it years ago. I might have to buy another one, although this thrad has me wanting an Applegate Fairbairn as well. Those Joe Watson blades look really nice. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Requirements for a good fixed blade- Must be FIXED blade. Not some broken blade Under 4 inchs blade length. 4 inches is plenty to hit vitals while not being absurdly long. Longer the blade, easier to strip from your hands. No serrations. Serrations gets caught in clothing very easily. You want a blade that can move easily in and out of many clothing options. Handle must have orientation for finger placement. You may have to fight in the dark. Having a groove to indicate where your fingers should be based on edge orientation. Enlarged pummel for easier draw. Preferably a curved design. Correct choil placement. Spearpoint design. Blades just as the Izula Esee aren't good for fighting. Why? No spear point for penetration. When fighting with a blade, you want to concentrate on "entries." Not slashes. The Romans proved stabbing was far deadlier than slashing. Grind- I like convex or flat grind. Easy to sharpen both of these grinds on multiple mediums. Lastly...A GOOD SHEATH. No one talks about a sheaths for some odd reason. It's literally half the battle. Take classes! Sayoc, Pekiti, etc. There are a lot more wackos teaching blade work than in the firearms industry. Be careful who you learn from! To the OP, it would be wise to take advice from FMA practitioners. Folks who have a background in blade arts. What blades I do like. Gerber Guardian, Cold Steel Secret Edge, Rat Blade from Head Hunter blades of Guro Harley, any Joe Watson Blade. When folks post their favorite blades, try asking why they like it. It's very telling if they have good answers or not. Great points on selecting a knife for fighting. I carried a Gerber Guardian as an Infantry LT in Korea. Loved that knife! Somehow lost it years ago. I might have to buy another one, although this thrad has me wanting an Applegate Fairbairn as well. Those Joe Watson blades look really nice. Glad to see that someone else on Arfcom gets it. Few do. The guardians are cheap enough to have a few to use at throwers too! Seriously look into a JW blade. He works with titanium and CPM 154. He has EXCELLENT heat treat and the craft is phenomenal. Design is superb, unlike many knive makers. Very functional and intentional in every detail in his blades. |
|
View Quote Uh no. Fuck no |
|
Might depend on what you consider the "best." It's not high up there in price, but I know a ton of guys overseas who all carry ESSE fixed blades. They're all built like tanks, have a kick ass warranty, and can take some abuse.
|
|
Quoted: After having been overseas and running the gamut of large knives to small knives, fixed blades and folders. In my experience the perfect combo is a good folding knife with around a 3" blade and a fixed blade with a good steel around 8-9" overall with around a 3-4" blade. Having been making my own knives for a few years now one of my latest knives is what I consider a perfect EDC/COMBAT/SAR/HUNTING/ANYTHING knife. Not really a plug just showing that my tastes have evolved with experience into a small simple fixed blade. I also think the Strider DB looks like a very useful and simple knife. Godrilla47 also makes one that I would consider a great all around knife, I think its the 5to5 model. Here is the Reaper (my EDC knife, and combat blade) http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v305/ryan1105/11885690_859395850822944_639021412889088363_o_zpsjczsfkxf.jpg View Quote That's a good looking knife. |
|
Quoted: I'd look at Spartan Blades I just picked up the Phrike http://i647.photobucket.com/albums/uu199/starscr34m/phrikeone_zpsrv4chvc3.jpg (Top knife) Now I'm thinking about the Horkos http://www.gpknives.com/media/catalog/product/cache/1/image/800x/3d3f317666956ee07a3550dd00d02d6e/4/b/4bkgrnlbk-3.jpg Or the Ares http://cdn3.volusion.com/cwhhs.ntmeb/v/vspfiles/photos/SBW0007-2.jpg?1395182803 View Quote That Horkos looks damn near perfect. Never owned anything by Spartan.....that may change. |
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
After having been overseas and running the gamut of large knives to small knives, fixed blades and folders. In my experience the perfect combo is a good folding knife with around a 3" blade and a fixed blade with a good steel around 8-9" overall with around a 3-4" blade. Having been making my own knives for a few years now one of my latest knives is what I consider a perfect EDC/COMBAT/SAR/HUNTING/ANYTHING knife. Not really a plug just showing that my tastes have evolved with experience into a small simple fixed blade. I also think the Strider DB looks like a very useful and simple knife. Godrilla47 also makes one that I would consider a great all around knife, I think its the 5to5 model. Here is the Reaper (my EDC knife, and combat blade) http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v305/ryan1105/11885690_859395850822944_639021412889088363_o_zpsjczsfkxf.jpg That's a good looking knife. Thanks. It's probably my favorite knife I've designed and it's definitely my most popular. |
|
How have we gone 4 pages with no mention of Jay Fisher? If money were no object I'd have a few.
|
|
Strider's heat treat makes the blades chip easily, and shatter
This has to be the most uneducated statement I have ever heard... |
|
Also Pete is not going to stop making fixed blades all together not sure where you get your usless information from. I know Pete personally and although he is focused on his 100 pre ordered rouge sharks he will return to regular orders when done.
|
|
Walter Brend
Phillip Patton Bill Bagwell elite knives They each have some good choices. |
|
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.