So I finally got to the range today and here to update my findings.
As mentioned, the octane45 utilized the brake fluid treatment and the octane9 would use Fireclean/Crisco..
The hosts are a M&P9 running the octane 9 with UMC 147gr and the Rossi Ranch Hand was running the octane45 w/fixed mount running Magtech158gr.
Firing 50rnds of ammo through each host and switching, each Octane got 200rds through it.
Lets examine the Octane45 that was treated with DOT 5 brake fluid.
Here is taken apart:
The baffles were still damp with the brake fluid. As you can see, there's nothing really caked on and had just a thin layer of carbon.
Examining the baffles, I took a quick swipe with an old sock and it pretty much cleaned 90% of the soot and powder off. Some had baked on but I didn't bother cleaning anymore.
Now lets, examine the Octane9 that was treated with Fireclean/Crisco...
Here it's taken apart:
Oddly, it appears that nothing really stuck on it. It was pretty clean and just a bare film of carbon.
Here's a picture of the piston:
As you can see, not much going on as far as it being dirty.
Here's a picture after just wiping it with a dirty sock.
There was some carbon baked on but not so bad.
Conclusion:
I'm not sure what to say that each method does ease cleaning and works as mentioned. I was actually quite shocked about the Fireclean after so much crap they are going through right now.