I'm not sure what help this will be but until someone with more info posts.........
The standard 870 trigger guards all have totally different factory part numbers then the Super Mag models.
The "aluminum" 870 trigger guard unit is made of compressed, powdered aluminum, not an aluminum forging or even casting.
They aren't nearly as strong as thought.
The plastic guard has the advantages of no finish to wear off, if it's bumped or struck the guard flexes and returns to shape while the aluminum just breaks, and the plastic is self lubricating,
In actual use the plastic stands up every bit as well as the aluminum.
With that said the cops and I too just prefer the aluminum...just because.
I would NOT buy a standard 870 trigger guard and hope it will work in a Super mag unless someone says it will work.