I'm not new to hand-guns, but I am new to Kydex holsters, but not in a good way. I recently bought my first Kydex holster for one of my Glock 19s, and it fit the holster good and snug, not too tight or too loose. But after inserting the pistol in and out of the holster just a few times, it scratched the he** out of the finish on the left front of the slide. I guess a sharp burr or something inside the holster snagged on the finish on the slide. Thing is, I did a lot of research on which holster causes less finish wear, Kydex or leather, and I guess I made the wrong decision based on what I read, or got a bad holster right off the bat.
A lot of people say that is normal; well, yea, maybe after hundreds of times holstering the pistol in and out of the holster, and not just a dozen times.
I don't blame you for wanting an old-school leather holster. That will likely be my next holster, although I've ordered some thin suede leather sheets to line the inside of Kydex holster, although the damage is done. (I don't like for something to get the best of me:-)
Here is a thread I posted about it on the Glock forum...
My first Kydex holster experience (not a good one)