Quote History Quoted:
If keeping it fully loaded doesn't wear out the spring (dubious, but lets grant it) then why would you not keep it fully loaded? Is it for match reasons or do you do that with a carry pistol too?
View Quote
First, I'd like to thank the several people who've already done such an excellent job of answering this question. These answers are right in line with my own thinking; but there's more. I've been using and carrying guns for a lot of years. During this time I've learned a few basics about magazine springs, as well as what to expect from different semiautomatics. (Sometimes from different guns with the same model number.)
In the past 11 years I've had 3 failures to extract over a FULLY LOADED magazine. That's too many failures! Fully loading a magazine can cause top round problems. The pickup rail is subjected to increased pressure, and it may cause the slide to short stroke. Ejection can be impaired, too, when the first +1 loaded case bangs into the fully loaded top round as it starts to eject.
My uncles, the men who taught me how to handle firearms, were veterans of both the South Pacific Campaign, and Korea. Because of exposure to sand and grit, lack of proper cleaning, and the numerous pistol malfunctions the Corps experienced whenever these pistols were loaded up, they weren't allowed to fully load their 1911-A1's, and had to learn to live with only 5 rounds in the magazine. To the 1940's and 50's Marines' way of thinking their pistols were, 'last ditch' weapons; and their 1911-A1's had to be utterly reliable. I learned this precaution from them; and, for a fact, it's kept me in good stead throughout my entire long life.
Another reason, 'Why' I don't fully load my pistol magazines is because it's quite possible for me to carry a pistol for months on end with the same three magazines. If I compress the springs all the way down and give them no room, 'to breathe' I risk forcing the mag springs to take too tight a set. I tend to be very gentle on my guns; and, like my uncles, I place reliability ahead of magazine capacity. (I spent most of my life carrying only 6 or 7 rounds in a pistol. I mean, hell, if I can't get the job done with 13, 15, or 17 rounds then, maybe, it's time for me to take up archery!)
In the past decade I've had numerous years when I've gone through better than 10,000 fired rounds without any sort of mechanical pistol-related problem. I never use full magazine +1 pistol loading - Never! Neither would I gamble with my life by going even further and +1 loading anybody's polymer frame pistol. It's rare for one of my semiautomatic pistols to FTFe, FTE, or experience a mag spring problem.
To my training as well as my experience and way of thinking, stuffing a pistol as full as you can get it is just plain reckless and stupid. If I need a pistol then I need it to absolutely positively, 'go bang!' Everything else is a secondary consideration. 6 extra rounds on top of a total of 39 isn't going to do me any good if I'm lying dead and bleeding on the ground with a jammed up semi-auto in my hand.